The Best Rhode Island Auto Insurance Companies

Rhode Island’s busy streets, expensive auto repairs, and numerous uninsured drivers put its typical auto insurance premium nearly $300 above the national average. But you can beat those odds. Every insurer looks at your situation a little differently, and by taking the time to get some quotes and compare your coverage options, you can find the company that offers you the best possible value. Read our reviews of the top Rhode Island auto insurers below and then use our quote tool to see what each of them can offer you.

How We Found the Best Rhode Island Auto Insurance Companies

First, we determined which were the largest insurers in the Ocean State by market share. Then, we checked with independent financial strength rating agencies like A.M. Best to ensure that the companies would be able to pay out their claims. After that, we compared coverage limits, endorsements and discounts to figure out which provided the greatest value to Rhode Island drivers. Finally, we turned to J.D. Power and Consumer Reports’ customer satisfaction surveys to get a sense of how the companies treated their customers. We also got quotes for ourselves and spoke to local agents.

The 4 Best Auto Insurance Companies in Rhode Island

  • Amica
  • Allstate
  • Progressive
  • Liberty Mutual

Rhode Island Auto Insurance Companies Reviews

Amica

Amica was the runaway favorite in the customer satisfaction surveys with a perfect 5/5 from J.D. Power and a 96/100 from Consumer Reports. Its claims handling was also noted to be efficient and stress-free, with a majority of consumers being satisfied with the fairness and the timeliness of the payment they received.

It should be your first stop if you’re interested in a policy with high coverage limits. You can purchase up to 500,000/1,000,000/1,000,000 of liability coverage. No other company on this list offers this much coverage, and it should be more than enough to protect you even in a severe accident.

Amica offers 18 total discounts:

Loyalty
Claim-free
Home ownership
Paid in full
E-discount
Multi-line
Multiple auto
Legacy (Family)
AutoPay
Anti-theft
Passive restraint
Adaptive headlight
Electronic stability
Forward-collision warning
Defensive driver training
Driver training
Good student/College graduate
Student away at school

Amica also stands out for its unique policy features that are designed to help you save money. If your new car is totaled, Amica will pay the full value of the new vehicle without factoring in depreciation. It also offers dividend policies, which gives you a refund of up to 20 percent of your premium each year, regardless of whether you filed a claim. If you want the most complete coverage, check out its Platinum Choice Auto endorsement. This includes good driving rewards, accident forgiveness, full glass coverage, free identity fraud monitoring, and more.

Allstate

Allstate is a good place to begin if you’re looking to customize your policy with rare endorsements. It’s one of the few companies on this list that offers ridesharing coverage for Uber and Lyft drivers as well as new car replacement. There’s personal property coverage as well, which pays to repair or replace any personal items that were damaged in the crash. Along with Progressive, Allstate is also one of the only insurers to offer rideshare coverage in Rhode Island.

Rideshare coverage

Rideshare Coverage is a term used by auto insurance companies to refer to policies that protect Uber and Lyft drivers. These particular professions tend to require the use of a personal vehicle and some auto insurance policies won’t cover that (at least, not without bumping you up to a commercial auto policy).

Allstate provides several endorsements designed to help you save money for being a safe driver. The Deductible Rewards endorsement lowers your deductible by $100 every year you go without a claim up to a maximum of $500. You may also be eligible for a Safe Driving Bonus Check every policy period you’re accident-free. And all Allstate customers are automatically enrolled in the Allstate Rewards program, which enables you to earn points that you can redeem for gift cards and products.

Allstate is another company that’s worth a closer look if you’re interested in purchasing a lot of liability coverage. While its limits aren’t as high as Amica’s, you can still purchase up to 500/500/500 coverage, which should be more than enough for most drivers.

Progressive

Progressive is another company known for offering very affordable rates. It has several easy-to-achieve discounts and a few that most of its competitors don’t offer, including teen driver, participation in their Snapshot® program, and a discount for getting a quote online.

If you want the most savings, consider signing up for Progressive’s Snapshot program. It monitors your driving for several months, and if you are safe and responsible, gives you some big savings. According to their site, the average discount can be as high as $130.

If you have a custom vehicle or you don’t own your car outright, Progressive should be one of your top choices. It’s the only company on the list to offer custom parts and GAP coverage, which pays off the balance of your lease or loan if your vehicle is totaled in an accident. That way, you aren’t stuck making payments on a vehicle you no longer own.

That said, the most coverage Progressive offers is 250/500/100, so you’re better off with Amica or Liberty Mutual if you want a policy with high coverage limits. The bodily injury coverage should be fine for most people, but property damage liability coverage is pretty low compared to the rest of the industry.

Liberty Mutual

Liberty Mutual is a good choice if you own a new car. It’s one of the only companies listed here that will pay you the full value of your totaled new car without accounting for depreciation. If you drive an older car, you may want to check out its better car replacement option. Should your car get totaled, Liberty Mutual will replace it with one that is a model year newer or has 15,000 fewer miles than your old one.

The company also stands out for its endorsements designed to help you save money. Its Deductible Fund option will lower your collision deductible by $100 for every year you go without an accident up to a maximum of $500. There’s also a Lifetime Repair Guarantee endorsement. Any repairs done at one of Liberty Mutual’s approved repair facilities are guaranteed for the life of your vehicle, and if they break again, you can bring it back in and Liberty Mutual will pay for the repairs without charging you a penny.

Liberty Mutual fell slightly behind the others in the customer satisfaction surveys. While it received good overall ratings, its claims handling was noted to be a step below the rest, with the fairness and timeliness of the settlement being the most common complaint. You may not run into these problems, but if you’d rather not take the risk, you’d be better off with a company like Amica.

Guide to Rhode Island Auto Insurance Companies

Make sure you meet Rhode Island’s minimum liability requirements

In the Ocean State, every driver must carry some liability insurance in case they cause an accident. Rhode Island residents must have at least:

  • $25,000 bodily injury coverage per person
  • $50,000 bodily injury coverage per accident
  • $25,000 property damage coverage per accident

You’ll often see this written shorthand as 25/50/25 coverage. That said, this is only the minimum, and when shopping for auto insurance providers, you’ll likely see offered limits as high as 250/500/100 (in the case of Progressive).

Opt for higher coverage

25/50/25 is the amount you must have to legally drive in the state, but it’s always best to purchase more if you can. If you were to get into an accident and cause $50,000 worth of property damages, your state-minimum coverage would only cover half of that and you’d be left to come up with the rest on your own. But if you’d purchased higher liability coverage, you wouldn’t have to worry about out-of-pocket costs.

Compare quotes

The best way to save on your auto insurance is to shop around and figure out which company offers you the best value. While every company looks at the same factors, including your vehicle, location, and driving record, they all weigh these factors slightly differently. Set aside some time to get quotes and play around with your coverage options. We recommend starting with the aforementioned four companies we’ve covered.

Rhode Island Auto Insurance Companies FAQ

Do I need uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage?

Though not required by state law, it’s a good idea to add uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage to your policy. Uninsured motorist coverage pays for any hospital bills or auto repairs you need if you’re hit by an uninsured driver, while underinsured motorist coverage picks up the slack if the at-fault driver doesn’t have enough insurance to cover the total damages. It’s worth considering since over 15 percent of Rhode Island drivers don’t have insurance.

Is there a difference between collision and comprehensive coverage?

Collision coverage pays to fix your vehicle after a car accident, even if you were the one at fault. Comprehensive coverage handles all non-collision-related incidents, like run-ins with wildlife, theft, and storm damage. Both are great ideas and worth considering if you do a lot of driving in the Ocean State.

Why is Rhode Island car insurance so expensive?

As stated earlier, the typical auto insurance premium in Rhode Island can be $300 higher than the national average. One reason could be the cost of car repairs. According to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners, the average auto repair cost in Rhode Island is $3,325. That’s $737 more than the national average. Insurance companies have to pay more to fix your car following an accident, and some of that extra cost gets passed on to you in the form of higher premiums.

The Best Rhode Island Auto Insurance Companies: Summed Up

Amica
Allstate
Progressive
Liberty Mutual
A.M. Best Financial Strength Rating
A+
A+
A+
A
Rhode Island
Auto Insurance Market Share
11.5%
11.6%
21.0%
7.1%
Discounts
18
11
13
7
Consumer Reports Reader Score
96/100
88/100
87/100
88/100
J.D. Powers Overall Customer Satisfaction Score (New England Region)
879/1000
834/1000
826/1000
809/1000