The Best Dog Food

High-quality food helps your pup stay active and playful, with a shiny coat, a good appetite and a healthy weight. We reached out to nearly 50 experts and dug into more than 3,000 dog food formulas to find the very best. While we aren’t veterinarians ourselves, we’re confident all of our recommended brands offer high-quality protein and balanced nutrition. From here, your job is to find a formula your dog likes, at a price you're comfortable with.

Our Favorite Dry Dog Food Brands and Lines

Our Favorite Wet Dog Food Brands and Lines

Runners-Up for Best Dry Dog Food Brands

Born Free: We couldn’t find this brand on Amazon, Chewy, PetSmart, or PetCo, and you can’t buy directly from their website, either. Currently only available at specialty pet food stores in the Midwest. Approved formulas: any.

Dynamite: Available directly from the manufacturer’s website, but not Chewy, Amazon, PetCo, or PetSmart. Approved formulas: any.

Only Natural Pet: Again, not available at major online retailers but can be ordered directly from the company’s website. Approved formulas: MaxMeat Air-Dried.

RedPaw: Not available on Chewy, Amazon, PetCo, or PetSmart. Can be purchased through the manufacturer and at some local pet stores nationwide. Approved formulas: X-Series.

TimberWolf: Not available at major online retailers, but can be purchased directly from the manufacturer and at a handful of locations in Florida and along the East Coast. Approved formulas: any.

Runners-Up for Best Wet Dog Food Brands

Blackwood: Amazon currently carries one flavor, and it’s not available at all from Chewy, PetSmart or PetCo. We could only find it at one pet store in the greater Seattle area. Approved formulas: any.

Diamond Naturals: We had no trouble tracking down this brand’s mediocre dry food, but its wet formulas aren’t available on Chewy, Amazon, PetSmart, or PetCo. Approved wet formulas: any.

Grandma Mae's Country Naturals: Spotty availability on Amazon, and not available at all from PetSmart, PetCo or Chewy. Approved formulas: the brand's "Healthy" line.

Performatrin: Available from a small third-party retailer, PetSolutions.com, but not on Chewy, Amazon, PetCo, PetSmart, or manufacturer’s website. Approved formulas: any.

Pinnacle: Available in specialty pet food stores on the West Coast, but we couldn’t find this brand’s wet food at any major online retailer. Approved formulas: any.

PureVita: Available in some specialty pet food stores, and with hit-or-miss availability on Amazon. Approved formulas: any.

RAWZ: Available mainly in Texas. The company does not sell directly, and has a “strict” policy against 3rd-party ecommerce, so you’ll have to find it in person. Approved formulas: any.

How we chose our favorite dog foods

We started with 3,009 formulas

We began by collecting every adult dog food currently sold in the U.S. That came to 3,009 dog foods. We then made two exceptions: We excluded products that failed to list their ingredients and any manufacturer that lacked a working website. This gave us a list of 2,969 formulas, including both dry and wet dog food. It took us about a month to compile our list. But we wanted to be sure we considered every formula pet owners are likely to run into, whether they're browsing for dog food online, at the grocery store or at a specialty retailer.

Cut: Toxic ingredients

We weren’t surprised to find that most of our 2,969 formulas were free of ingredients known to be toxic to dogs, like avocados, grapes and chocolate. We were surprised to find that garlic and onion turned up in almost 200 formulas. Despite the punch that these two ingredients add to bland food, they are members of the Allium plant genus, which is toxic to both dogs and cats. Along with leeks, scallions, chives and shallots, garlic and onion can make dogs immediately sick in large quantities. If eaten in small amounts over time (say, as a flavoring in their regular food), they can damage red blood cells, causing anemia.

What we cut: 178

Dry: 99

Blue Buffalo: Blue Santa Fe Grill™ Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Grain-Free Texas BBQ™ Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Nantucket Feast™ Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Grain-Free Colorado Roast™ Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Freedom Grain-Free Beef Recipe Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Freedom Grain-Free Lamb Recipe Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Freedom Grain-Free Healthy Weight Chicken Recipe Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Freedom Grain-Free Chicken Recipe Small Breed Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Freedom Grain-Free Beef Recipe Large Breed Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Freedom Grain-Free Chicken Recipe Large Breed Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Freedom Grain-Free Lamb Recipe, Blue Buffalo: Blue Life Protection Chicken and Brown Rice Recipe Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Life Protection Fish and Brown Rice Recipe Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Life Protection Lamb and Brown Rice Recipe Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Life Protection Healthy Weight Chicken and Brown Rice Recipe Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Life Protection Small Bite Chicken and Brown Rice, Blue Buffalo: Blue Life Protection Grain-Free Chicken Recipe Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Life Protection Chicken and Brown Rice Recipe Toy Breed Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Life Protection Chicken and Brown Rice Recipe Small Breed Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Life Protection Fish and Brown Rice Recipe Small Breed Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Life Protection Lamb and Brown Rice Recipe Small Breed Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Life Protection Healthy Weight Chicken and Brown Rice, Blue Buffalo: Blue Life Protection Chicken and Brown Rice Recipe Large Breed Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Life Protection Fish and Oatmeal Recipe Large Breed Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Life Protection Lamb and Brown Rice Recipe Large Breed Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Life Protection Healthy Weight Chicken and Brown Rice, Blue Buffalo: Blue Natural Veterinary Diet WU Weight Management + Urinary Care, DAD’s Healthy Homestyle, DAD’s Kibble Select® Complete Original, DAD’s Kibble Select® Complete Healthy Weight, Dogswell: Happy Hips Chicken & Oats, Dogswell: Vitality Chicken & Oats, Dr. Gary’s Best Breed: Holistic Dog Formulas All Breed Dog Diet, Dr. Gary’s Best Breed: Holistic Dog Formulas Large Breed Dog Diet, Dr. Gary’s Best Breed: Holistic Dog Formulas Senior Dog Diet, Evolve Chicken & Rice Formula Dog Food, FirstMate & Kasiks FirstMate: Classic Formulas – High Performance, FirstMate & Kasiks FirstMate: Classic Formulas – Maintenance, Grandma Mae’s Country Naturals Senior/Low-Fat Formula for Dogs, Grandma Mae’s Country Naturals Low Fat Formula for Dogs, Happy Paws Holistic Dog Food, Harvest Blend Harvest Blend Chicken Formula for Puppies & Adult Dogs, Harvest Blend Salmon Formula for Puppies & Adult Dogs (Gluten Free), Harvest Blend Turkey Formula (Gluten Free), Lotus: Oven-Baked Dry Chicken Recipe, Lotus: Oven-Baked Dry Senior Recipe, Lotus: Oven-Baked Dry Fish Recipe, Lotus: Oven-Baked Dry Duck Recipe, Natural Planet Chicken & Oats Formula, Ol’ Roy Kibbles, Chunks & Chews Dry Dog Food–Skin & Coat, Ol’ Roy Tasty Benefits Original Flavor Dry Dog Food–Skin & Coat Care, Ol’ Roy Kibbles, Chunks & Chews Savory Beef & Chicken Flavor Dry Dog Food, Party Animal Dry Dog Food MADE WITH ORGANIC CHICKEN, GRAINS, FRUITS, VEGETABLES + VITAMINS & MINERALS, PetGuard LifeSpan, PetGuard LifeSpan, Pinnacle Grain free chicken and vegetables, President’s Choice Nutrition First First Grain-Free Salmon & Potato Premium Adult, PureVita: Dry Recipes Chicken & Brown Rice, PureVita: Dry Recipes Duck & Oatmeal, PureVita: Dry Recipes Salmon & Potato, PureVita: Grain Free Salmon & Peas Entrée Grain Free Formula, PureVita: Grain Free Turkey & Sweet Potato Entrée Grain Free, PureVita: Grain Free Beef & Red Lentils Grain Free Entree, Purina Alpo Come & Get It! Cookout Classics, Purina Alpo Prime Cuts: Savory Beef Flavor, Purina Beneful HEALTHY WEIGHT with real chicken, Purina Beneful INCREDIBITES with real beef, Purina Beneful INCREDIBITES with real chicken, Purina Beneful ORIGINALS with real beef, Purina Beneful ORIGINALS with real chicken, Purina Beneful ORIGINALS with real salmon, Purina Beneful PLAYFUL LIFE with real beef & egg, Purina: Dog Chow//Puppy Chow Natural, Purina: Dog Chow//Puppy Chow Small Dog, Purina: Dog Chow//Puppy Chow Large Dog, Purina: Dog Chow//Puppy Chow Complete Adult with Real American-Raised Chicken, Purina: Dog Chow//Puppy Chow Tender & Crunchy, Purina: Dog Chow//Puppy Chow Healthy Weight, Purina: Pro Plan Veterinary Diets EN Gastroenteric, Purina: Pro Plan Veterinary Diets HA Hydrolyzed, Purina: Pro Plan Veterinary Diets NF Kidney Function, Purina: Pro Plan Veterinary Diets DH Dental Health, Purina: Pro Plan Veterinary Diets OM Overweight Management, Purina: Pro Plan Veterinary Diets OM Select Blend Overweight Management, Three Dog Bakery: Bake to Nature OVEN-BAKED CHICKEN RECIPE FOR ADULT, Three Dog Bakery: Bake to Nature OVEN-BAKED CHICKEN RECIPE FOR ADULT HEALTHY WEIGHT, Three Dog Bakery: Bake to Nature OVEN-BAKED FISH & SWEET POTATO ADULT, Wellness: Complete Health Grain Free Deboned Chicken & Chicken Meal, Wellness: Complete Health Grain Free Whitefish & Menhaden Fish Meal, Wellness: Complete Health Grain Free Lamb & Lamb Meal, Wellness: Complete Health Grain Free Large Breed, Wellness: Core: Dry Complete Health: Lamb & Barley, Wellness: Core: Dry Complete Health: Senior, Wellness: Core: Dry Complete Health: Deboned Chicken & Oatmeal, Wellness: Core: Dry Complete Health: Healthy Weight, Wellness: Core: Dry Complete Health Large Breed: Adult, Zach’s Quality Dog Food CHICKEN MEAL & RICE, Zach’s Quality Dog Food BEEF MEAL AND RICE, Zach’s Quality Dog Food BLACK LABEL PERFORMANCE

Wet: 79

Addiction: Canned Unagi & Seaweed Entree, Azmira Chicken & Brown Rice Formula Adult Canned Dog Food, Azmira Lamb & Barley Formula, Azmira Ocean Fish Formula, Castor & Pollux Natural Ultramix Chicken, Vegetable & Brown Rice Stew, Castor & Pollux Organix Organic Chicken & Potato Recipe, Castor & Pollux Organix Organic Chicken & Potato Recipe, Castor & Pollux Organix Organic Chicken & Vegetable Recipe, Castor & Pollux Organix Organic Turkey & Vegetable Recipe, Castor & Pollux Organix Organic Turkey & Vegetable Recipe, Castor & Pollux Organix Organic Turkey, Carrot & Potato Recipe, Castor & Pollux Organix Organic Turkey, Carrot & Potato Recipe, Dave’s Pet Food: Naturally Healthy Healthy Joint Formula, Dave’s Pet Food: Stewlicious Chicken Casserole, Dave’s Pet Food: Stewlicious Luscious Lamb Stew, Dave’s Pet Food: Stewlicious Meaty Beef Stew, Dogswell: Happy Hips Chicken and Sweet Potato Stew, Dogswell: Happy Hips Duck and Sweet Potato Stew, Dogswell: Happy Hips Lamb and Sweet Potato Stew, Dogswell: Vitality Chicken and Sweet Potato Stew, Dogswell: Vitality Duck and Sweet Potato Stew, Dogswell: Vitality Lamb and Sweet Potato Stew, Drs. Foster and Smith Fish & Potato Formula Adult Canned Dog Food, Drs. Foster and Smith Lamb & Brown Rice Formula Adult Canned Dog Food, Gravy Train Chunks In Gravy With Chicken Beef & Liver Medley, Gravy Train Chunks In Gravy With Chicken Chunks, Gravy Train Meaty Ground Dinner With Beef & Bacon, Gravy Train Meaty Ground Dinner With Chicken, Halo Holistic Beef Recipe, Halo Holistic Chicken Recipe for Adult Dogs, Halo Holistic Lamb Recipe, Halo Holistic Turkey and Salmon Recipe, Holistic Health Extension Beef, Holistic Health Extension Chicken, Kibbles ‘n Bits – Chef’s Choice American Grill American Grill Burger Dinner With Real Bacon & Cheese Bits in Gravy, Kibbles ‘n Bits – Chef’s Choice Bistro Hearty Cuts With Real Beef, Chicken & Vegetables in Gravy, Kibbles ‘n Bits – Chef’s Choice Homestyle Meatballs & Pasta Dinner With Real Beef in Tomato Sauce, Merrick: Classic Classic Texas State Fair Stew Seasonal Recipe, Merrick: Grain Free Chunky Big Texas Steak Tips Dinner™ Grain Free Recipe, Merrick: Grain Free Chunky Colossal Chicken Dinner™ Grain Free Recipe, Merrick: Grain Free Chunky Pappy’s Pot Roast Dinner Grain Free Recipe, Nature’s Recipe: Healthy Skin Vegetarian Cuts in Gravy, Nature’s Variety: Prairie: Homestyle Cans Beef and Bison Stew, Nature’s Variety: Prairie: Homestyle Cans Beef Stew, Nature’s Variety: Prairie: Homestyle Cans Chicken Stew, Nature’s Variety: Prairie: Homestyle Cans Lamb Stew, Nature’s Variety: Prairie: Homestyle Cans Pork and Sweet Potato Stew, Nature’s Variety: Prairie: Homestyle Cans Salmon and Wild Rice Stew, Nature’s Variety: Prairie: Homestyle Cans Turkey and Duck Stew, Ol Roy Ol Roy Hearty Cuts In Gravy Dog Food, 22 oz, Ol Roy Ol Roy Hearty Cuts In Gravy W/Burgers N Cheez Wedges Dog Food, 13.20 oz, Ol Roy Ol’ Roy Cuts In Gravy Rottiserie Chicken Wet Dog Food, 13.2 Oz, Ol Roy Ol’ Roy Cuts in Gravy Savory Chicken Dinner Wet Dog Food, 13.2 Oz, Ol Roy Ol’ Roy Cuts in Gravy T-Bone Flavor Wet Dog Food, 13.2 oz, Ol Roy Ol’ Roy Cuts in Gravy with Lamb and Rice Wet Dog Food, 22 oz, Ol Roy Ol’ Roy Hearty Loaf Wet Dog Food, 13.20 oz, Ol Roy Ol’ Roy Meaty Loaf Savory Chicken Dinner Wet Dog Food, 13.2 Oz, 6 Ct, Ol Roy Ol’ Roy Strips In Gravy Filet Mignon Flavor Dog Food, 13.2 oz, Ol Roy Ol’ Roy Strips in Gravy Filet Mignon Flavor Wet Dog Food, 13.2 oz, 12 pk, Ol Roy Ol’ Roy Strips In Gravy New York Strip Flavor Wet Dog Food, 13.2 Oz, Performatrin Performatrin® Adult Chicken Formula Dog Food, Performatrin Performatrin® Adult Grain-Free Chicken Formula Dog Food, Performatrin Performatrin® Adult Lamb Formula Dog Food, Performatrin Performatrin® Healthy Weight Chicken Formula Dog Food, Performatrin Performatrin® Healthy Weight Lamb Formula Dog Food, Pet-Tao Harmony Beef, Pet-Tao Harmony Turkey, Pet-Tao Solution Blaze, PetKind: Tripett Canned Duck and Salmon, PetKind: Tripett Canned Green Beef Tripe, PetKind: Tripett Canned Green Beef Tripe and Venison, PetKind: Tripett Canned Green Bison Tripe, PetKind: Tripett Canned Green Lamb Tripe, PetKind: Tripett Canned Green Venison Tripe, Pure Balance Pure Balance Canned Beef Vegetables & Brown Rice Wet Dog Food, 12.5 Oz, Pure Balance Pure Balance Canned Chicken Vegetables & Brown Rice Wet Dog Food, 12.5 Oz, VeRUS VéRUS Beef and Barley Formula, VeRUS VéRUS Chicken and Brown Rice Formula, Zoe Dog Food Beef & Chicken Formula

Cut: Low-quality mystery “meats” and “meals”

Whole meats are expensive, and many manufacturers supplement their formulas with meat meal to ensure your dog is getting a balanced diet at an affordable cost. Although meat meal sounds gross if you're not a dog, there's nothing terrifying about it. It’s created through a high-pressure, high-temperature process called rendering: Fat and moisture are separated out from dried, solid protein by grinding everything up and steam cooking it all at extremely high temperatures. The dried solids make up the meal.

The FDA, which regulates pet food labeling, notes that meal can contain higher concentrations of protein, nutrients and minerals than whole meats. Meal is basically concentrated meat. But there are two reasons this ingredient is controversial.

First, manufacturers aren’t required to be transparent about how their meals are rendered. The nutritional quality of meal can vary, since natural enzymes and proteins are sometimes destroyed during very high-temperature manufacturing processes. But there's no way for consumers to monitor this since companies aren't required to disclose their exact practices.

Second, the animal parts that meal is made out of are often low quality to begin with. The American Association of Feed Control Officials, a group that helps the FDA establish labeling standards, allows anything that's labeled "meat meal" to be sourced “from mammals other than cattle, pigs, sheep or goats without further description,” which means you can’t be sure exactly what’s in it. We were pretty grossed out to learn meat meal can also be sourced from stuff like restaurant grease, diseased livestock and expired supermarket meat.

So we set two requirements.

We cut formulas that included unnamed meats of any kind. These show up on ingredient lists as “meat meal,” “meat and bone meal” or “byproduct meal” (or sometimes simply “meat”). If meat meal showed up at all, we wanted to see a named source, like “duck meal” or “salmon meal." This ensures the company manufacturing the food is being at least somewhat choosy about their ingredients.

And we a required a whole protein to occupy the first spot on the ingredient list. According to the FDA, ingredients are listed in order of weight, with the heaviest ingredients listed first. While we didn’t want to eliminate every single formula that had any type of meal anywhere (this would’ve left only a small number of extremely pricey formulas), we did feel that a truly high-quality dog food shouldn’t take shortcuts on its main ingredient. So we cut formulas without a named, whole animal protein, like chicken or venison, in the first ingredient slot.

What we cut: 437

Dry: 140

Bil-Jac: Original Adult Select Formula, Bil-Jac: Original Large Breed Adult, Bil-Jac: Original Picky No More™Large Breed, Bil-Jac: Original Picky No More™Medium Breed, Bil-Jac: Original Picky No More™Small Breed, Bil-Jac: Original Reduced Fat Formula, Bil-Jac: Original Senior Select Formula, Bil-Jac: Original Sensitive Solutions With Real Whitefish, Bil-Jac: Original Small Breed Adult, Bil-Jac: Original Small Breed Senior, Black Gold PERFORMANCE FORMULA, Cesar Filet Mignon Flavor & Spring Vegetables, Cesar Rotisserie Chicken Flavor & Spring Vegetables, Cesar Slow Roasted Lamb Flavor & Spring Vegetables, DAD’s Trail Mix, Diamond Hi-Energy, Diamond Maintenance, Diamond Original, Diamond Performance, Diamond Premium Adult, Doc’s Choice Premium Adult Formula, Eukanuba Adult Maintenance Dog Food, Eukanuba Adult Weight Management Dog Food, Eukanuba LAMB AND RICE ADULT DOG FOOD, Eukanuba LAMB AND RICE ADULT LARGE BREED DOG FOOD, Eukanuba Large Breed Adult Dog Food, Eukanuba Large Breed Weight Management Dog Food, Eukanuba Performance Dog Food: Active Dog Food, Eukanuba Premium Performance Dog Food for Sporting and Hunting Dogs, Eukanuba Small Bite Dog Food, Eukanuba Small Breed Dog Food, Eukanuba Small Breed Weight Management Dog Food, Gravy Train BEEFY CLASSIC, Gravy Train HEARTY CLASSIC CHICKEN FLAVOR, Gravy Train HEARTY POT ROAST FLAVOR, Gravy Train SMALL BITES BEEFY CLASSIC, Grreat Choice Complete Nutrition Adult Dog Food – Chicken, Grreat Choice Complete Nutrition Adult Dog Food – Steak & Veggie, Grreat Choice Targeted Nutrition Large Breed Dog Food – Chicken, Grreat Choice Targeted Nutrition Small Breed Dog Food – Chicken, Hi-Standard: Premium Performance 22/12, Hi-Standard: Premium Performance 23/16, Hi-Standard: Premium Performance 24/20 Soy Free, Hi-Standard: Premium Performance 26/18 Soy Free, Hi-Standard: Ultimate Ultimate Lamb Meal & Rice Formula, HI-TOR: Veterinary Select Eno Diet for Dogs, HI-TOR: Veterinary Select Neo Diet for Dogs, HI-TOR: Veterinary Select Reduso Diet for Dogs, Hill’s: Prescription Diet b/d Canine: Brain Aging Care, Hill’s: Prescription Diet g/d® Canine: Aging Care, Hill’s: Prescription Diet h/d® Canine: Heart Care, Hill’s: Prescription Diet i/d Stress Canine: Digestive Care, Hill’s: Prescription Diet i/d® Low Fat Canine: Digestive Care/GI Restore, Hill’s: Prescription Diet j/d Canine Small Bites: Joint Care, Hill’s: Prescription Diet j/d® Canine: Joint Care, Hill’s: Prescription Diet r/d Canine: Weight Reduction, Hill’s: Prescription Diet t/d® Canine Small Bites: Dental Care, Hill’s: Prescription Diet t/d® Canine: Dental Care, Iams: Proactive Health ADULT CHUNKS, Iams: Proactive Health ADULT LAMB MEAL & RICE, Iams: Proactive Health ADULT LARGE BREED, Iams: Proactive Health ADULT MINICHUNKS, Iams: Proactive Health ADULT OPTIMAL WEIGHT LARGE BREED, Iams: Proactive Health ADULT SMALL & TOY BREED, Iams: Proactive Health ADULT WEIGHT CONTROL, Iams: Proactive Health MATURE ADULT, Iams: Proactive Health MATURE ADULT LARGE BREED, Iams: Proactive Health MATURE ADULT SMALL & TOY BREED, Iams: Proactive Health SENIOR PLUS, Iams: Proactive Health SENIOR PLUS LARGE BREED, Joy Adult 26/18, Joy High Performance, Joy High-Energy, Joy Lamb Meal & Rice, Joy Maintenance Plus, Joy Performance 32/18, Joy Special Meal, Kibbles ‘n Bits Light & Tasty Roasted Chicken & Vegetable Flavors, Kinetic Active 26K Formula, Kinetic Power 30K Formula, Kinetic Ultra 32K Formula, Ol’ Roy Bacon Flavor Dog Food–Strong Bone, Eye Care, Coat Health, Strong Teeth, Ol’ Roy Bacon Flavor Dry Dog Food–Strong Teeth, Strong Bone, Ol’ Roy Cheeseburger Flavor Dry Dog Food, Ol’ Roy Complete Nutrition Dry Dog Food, Ol’ Roy Dinner Rounds Dry Dog Food, Ol’ Roy High Performance Dry Dog Food, Ol’ Roy High Performance Dry Dog Food–Immune System, Ol’ Roy Small Breed Dry Dog Food–Digestive Health;Muscle Maintenance;generated;Immunse System Support, Ol’ Roy Small Breed Dry Dog Food–Skin & Coat Care, Ol’ Roy T-Bone & Chicken Flavor Dry Dog Food–Eye Care, Coat Health, Strong Teeth, Strong Bone, Pedigree Dry Dog Food Active Senior Roasted Chicken, Rice & Vegetable Flavor, Pedigree Dry Dog Food Adult Grilled Steak & Vegetable Flavor, Pedigree Dry Dog Food Adult Roasted Chicken, Rice & Vegetable Flavor, Pedigree Dry Dog Food Adult Roasted Lamb, Rice & Vegetable Flavor, Pedigree Dry Dog Food For Big Dogs Roasted Chicken, Rice & Vegetable, Pedigree Dry Dog Food Healthy Weight Roasted Chicken, & Vegetable Flavor, Pedigree Dry Dog Food Small Dog Grilled Salmon, Rice and Vegetable Flavor, Pedigree Dry Dog Food Small Dog Grilled Steak and Vegetable Flavor, Pedigree Dry Dog Food Small Dog Roasted Chicken, Rice & Vegetable Flavor, PMI Nutrition: Canine Advantage Canine Advantage Formula Dog Food, Purina Bella With Real Chicken & Beef, Purina Bella With Real Chicken & Turkey, Purina: Dog Chow//Puppy Chow Complete Adult made with Real Beef, Purina: Moist & Meaty Burger with Cheddar Cheese Flavor, Purina: Moist & Meaty Chopped Burger, Purina: Moist & Meaty Rise & Shine Awaken Bacon and Egg Flavor, Purina: Moist & Meaty Steak Flavor, Purina: Pro Plan Veterinary Diets EN Gastroenteric Fiber Balance, Purina: Pro Plan Veterinary Diets JM Joint Mobility, Purina: Pro Plan Veterinary Diets UR Urinary® Ox/St, Red Flannel ADULT, Red Flannel BITES N’ BONES, Red Flannel CANINE SELECT, Red Flannel HI-PROTEIN, Red Flannel LARGE BREED, Red Flannel PRIME, Redpaw PowerEdge 38k, Signature Pet Products: Hi-Tek Rations Hi-Performance 26-18, Signature Pet Products: Hi-Tek Rations Premium Formula 23-14, Signature Pet Products: Premium Blend Adult Plus 21-9, Signature Pet Products: Premium Blend Adult Plus 26-18, SPORTMiX: Original Formulas Bite Size, SPORTMiX: Original Formulas Chunk Style, SPORTMiX: Original Formulas High Protein, SPORTMiX: Premium Formulas Energy Plus Adult Mini Chunk, SPORTMiX: Premium Formulas High Energy Adult Chunk, SPORTMiX: Premium Formulas High Energy Adult Mini Chunk, SPORTMiX: Premium Formulas Hunter’s Select Adult Mini Chunk, SPORTMiX: Premium Formulas Maintenance Adult Mini Chunk, SPORTMiX: Premium Formulas Stamina Adult Mini Chunk, Sportsman’s Pride Lamb Meal & Rice 22/12, Sportsman’s Pride Maintenance 21/12, Sportsman’s Pride Premium Formula 26/18, Sportsman’s Pride Professional 30/20, Vets Choice GOLDEN YEARS, Vets Choice LARGE BREED ADULT, Vets Choice LITE, Vets Choice PREMIUM, Vets Choice SUPERIOR

Wet: 297
4Health 4health Beef & Vegetable Stew Dog Food, 4Health 4health Beef & Vegetable Stew Formula for Adult Dogs, 4Health 4health Beef & Vegetable Stew in Gravy Dog Food, 4Health 4health Chicken & Vegetable Stew for Dogs, 4Health 4health Chicken & Vegetable Stew in Gravy Dog Food, 4Health Shredded Beef in Gravy Entrée, Almo Nature: HQS Legend HMS – Chicken and Carrots, Almo Nature: HQS Legend Tuna andChicken, Authority – Adult – Weight Management Lamb and Rice, Authority – Adult Beef and Rice, Authority – Adult Lamb and Rice, Authority – All Life Stages Pumpkin, Authority – Grain Free Beef and Vegetables, Authority – Grain Free Turkey and Sweet Potato, Authority – Mature Lamb and Rice, Authority – Stew Beef and Vegetable (Adult), Authority – Stew Chicken (Adult), Authority – Stew Chicken and Vegetable (Mature), Authority – Stew Lamb and Vegetable (Adult), Authority – Stew Turkey (Adult), Authority: GNC Pets Chicken (Adult), Authority: GNC Pets Chicken (Mature), Authority: GNC Pets Weight Management, AvoDerm – Grain Free – Stew Recipe Beef and Potatoes, AvoDerm – Grain Free – Stew Recipe Chicken and Vegetables, AvoDerm – Grain Free – Stew Recipe Salmon and Potato, AvoDerm – Grain Free – Stew Recipe Turkey and Vegetables, AvoDerm Chicken and Rice (Weight Management), AvoDerm Lamb and Rice (All Life Stages), AvoDerm Vegetarian, Bil-Jac: Pâté Pâté Platters™ withBeef & Sweet Potatoes, Bil-Jac: Stews Chunky Stew with Chicken and Vegetables, Bil-Jac: Stews Country Stew with Lamb and Beef, Bil-Jac: Stews Harvest Feast® with Turkey and Sweet Potatoes in Gravy, Bil-Jac: Stews Hearty Stew with Beef and Barley, Canidae: Under The Sun Chicken and Peas Pate, Canidae: Under The Sun Lamb and Carrots in Gravy, Canidae: Under The Sun Salmon and Shrimp Pate, Canidae: Under The Sun Turkey and Green Beens in Gravy, Caru Daily Dish Beef Stew, Caru Daily Dish Beef with Chicken Stew, Caru Daily Dish Chicken Stew, Caru Daily Dish Turkey with Lamb Stew, Castor & Pollux Natural Ultramix Real Pumpkin Ultrablend Supplement, Castor & Pollux Natural Ultramix Venison, White Potatoes & Fresh Cut Carrots Entrée, Cesar Home Delights Cheesy Chicken Pasta Dinner in Sauce, Cesar Home Delights Chicken & Turkey Casserole in Sauce, Cesar Home Delights Country Stew with Vegetables, Cesar Home Delights Grilled New York Strip Steak Flavor With Potatoes & Summer Vegetables, Cesar Home Delights Grilled Porterhouse Steak Flavor With Potatoes, Bacon & Cheese, Cesar Home Delights Grilled Ribeye Steak Flavor With Potatoes & Vegetables, Cesar Home Delights Sausage Flavor with Egg & Cheese in Gravy, Cesar Home Delights Scramble with Turkey, Spinach, and Cheese in Gravy, Cesar Home Delights T-Bone Steak Flavor with Egg & Cheese in Gravy, Dave’s Pet Food: Grain Free for Dogs Beef and Vegetable Cuts in Gravy, Dave’s Pet Food: Grain Free for Dogs Chicken and Vegetable Cuts in Gravy, Dave’s Pet Food: Grain Free for Dogs Ocean Fish and Vegetable Cuts in Gravy, Dave’s Pet Food: Grain Free for Dogs Turkey and Sweet Potato Cuts in Gravy, Dave’s Pet Food: Naturally Healthy Liver and Beef Recipe, Dave’s Pet Food: Restricted Diet Farmyard Blend, Dave’s Pet Food: Restricted Diet Farmyard Blend in Sauce, Dave’s Pet Food: Stewlicious Chunky Chicken Stew, Dave’s Pet Food: Stewlicious Chunky Turkey, Sweet Potato & Cranberry Stew, Dogswell: Nutrisca Lamb and Chickpea Stew, Drs. Foster and Smith Hearty Beef Stew with Sweet Potatoes & Carrots, Drs. Foster and Smith Roasted Turkey & Chicken Stew with Potatoes & Carrots, Earthborn Holistic Chips Chicken Casserole Stew, Earthborn Holistic Duke’s Din-Din Stew, Earthborn Holistic Lily’s Gourmet Buffet in Sauce, Earthborn Holistic Pepper’s Pot Roast, Earthborn Holistic Toby’s Turkey Dinner in Gravy, Eukanuba – Adult Beef and Vegetables Stew, Eukanuba – Adult Chicken and vegetables Stew, Eukanuba – Adult Lamb and Rice, Eukanuba – Adult Mixed Grilled Chicken and beef Dinner in Gravy, Evanger’s Super Premium Sweet Potato, Evanger’s Super Premium Sweet Potato, Evanger’s Super Premium Vegetarian, Evolve Nature’s Menu Chicken and Pasta Dinner in Gravy, Evolve Nature’s Menu Hearty Stew, Evolve Nature’s Menu Holiday Harvest, Evolve Nature’s Menu Mountain Range Medley, Forza10 Dermo Actiwet Fish, Forza10 Hypoallergenic Actiwet with Fish, Forza10 Hypoallergenic Actiwet with Lamb, Forza10 Intestinal Actiwet Fish, Forza10 Renal Actiwet with Lamb, Freshpet Select Stews Grain Free Beef and Pumpkin Recipe, Freshpet Select Stews Grain Free Chicken, Cranberry and Carrot Recipe, Fromm Lamb Pâté, Fromm Shredded Chicken in Gravy Entrée, Fromm Shredded Pork in Gravy Entrée, Fromm Venison & Beef Pâté, Fromm Venison & Lentil Pâté, Good Natured Beef and Vegetable Casserole, Good Natured Chicken and Vegetable Cuts in Gravy, Good Natured Chicken, Turkey and Vegetable in Gravy, Good Natured Lamb and Vegetable Casserole, Halo – Grain Free for Senior Dogs Chicken Recipe, Halo Holistic Garden of Vegan™ Recipe, HI-TOR Eno Can, Hill’s: Ideal Balance Roasted Beef & Zucchini Stew, Hill’s: Ideal Balance Slow Cooked Chicken & Zucchini Stew, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Chicken & Vegetable Stew, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Derm Defense – Chicken and Vegetable Stew, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Digestive Care with Turkey, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Digestive/Weight/Glucose Management Vegetable and Chicken Stew, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Digestive/Weight/Glucose Management with Chicken, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Duck Formula, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Heart Care with Chicken, Hill’s: Prescription Diet k/d® + Mobility Canine Chicken & Vegetable Stew, Hill’s: Prescription Diet k/d® Canine Beef & Vegetable Stew, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Kidney Care – Chicken and Vegetable Stew, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Kidney Care – Original, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Kidney Care with Lamb, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Liver Care – Original, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Metabolic – Chicken and Vegetable Stew, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Metabolic – Vegetable and Beef Stew, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Metabolic + Mobility Canine Vegetable & Tuna Stew, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Rice, Vegetable and Chicken Stew, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Skin and Food Sensitivity – Salmon Formula, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Skin/Food Sensitivities – Original Flavor, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Skin/Food Sensitivities – Venison Formula, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Urgent Care with Chicken, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Urinary Care – Chicken and Vegetable Stew, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Urinary Care – Chicken Flavor, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Urinary Care – Original, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Vegetable & Chicken Stew, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult 7+ Beef & Barley Entrée, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult 7+ Beef & Barley Entrée, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult 7+ Chicken & Barley Entrée, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult 7+ Healthy Cuisine Braised Beef, Carrots & Peas Stew, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult 7+ Healthy Cuisine Roasted Chicken, Carrots & Spinach Stew, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult 7+ Savory Stew with Beef & Vegetables, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult 7+ Savory Stew with Chicken & Vegetables, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult 7+ Small & Toy Chicken & Barley, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult 7+ Turkey & Barley Entrée, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Beef & Barley Entrée, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Healthy Cuisine Braised Beef, Carrots & Peas Stew, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Healthy Cuisine Roasted Chicken, Carrots & Spinach Stew, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Perfect Weight Chicken & Vegetable Entrée, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Perfect Weight Hearty Vegetable & Chicken Stew, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Savory Stew with Beef & Vegetables, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Savory Stew with Chicken & Vegetables, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Sensitive Stomach & Skin Salmon & Vegetable Entrée, Hill’s: Science Diet Small & Toy Adult 7+ Savory Stew with Chicken & Vegetables, Hill’s: Science Diet Small & Toy Adult Savory Stew with Beef & Vegetables, Hill’s: Science Diet Small & Toy Adult Savory Stew with Chicken & Vegetables, Hill’s: Science Diet Youthful Vitality Adult 7+ Chicken & Vegetable Entree Stew, Hill’s: Science Diet Youthful Vitality Adult 7+ Small & Toy Breed Chicken & Vegetable Stew, Holistic Health Extension Chunky Chicken Stew, Holistic Health Extension Savory Beef Stew, Holistic Health Extension Tasty Turkey Stew, Holistic Health Extension Vegetarian Entree, Life’s Abundance Canned Chicken & Crab, Natural Balance: Delectable Delights Bowl ‘O Barkgundy® Dog Stew, Natural Balance: Delectable Delights ChopLick’n Stew® Dog Stew, Natural Balance: Delectable Delights Chow-Down Chowder Dog Stew, Natural Balance: Delectable Delights Duck’en-itas® (Wet Cups), Natural Balance: Delectable Delights Fetchin’ Catchin’s® Dog Stew, Natural Balance: Delectable Delights Fish ‘N Chicks® (Wet Cups), Natural Balance: Delectable Delights Gobbler Cobbler® Dog Stew, Natural Balance: Delectable Delights Pawpaya Pilaf® Dog Stew, Natural Balance: Delectable Delights Woof’erole® (Wet Cups), Natural Balance: Vegetarian Brown Rice, Carrots and Potatoes, Nature’s Recipe: Grain-Free Chicken and Turkey Stew, Nature’s Recipe: Grain-Free Chicken and Venison Stew, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Original Can for Small Breed Chicken, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Original Can for Small Breed Salmon, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Wet Pouches Healthy Cravings® Real Beef in Savory Gravy, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Wet Pouches Healthy Cravings® Real Chicken in Savory Gravy, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Wet Pouches Healthy Cravings® Real Lamb in Savory Gravy, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Wet Pouches Healthy Cravings® Real Salmon in Savory Gravy, Nutro: Hearty Stews Chunky Chicken and Turkey Stew in Gravy, Nutro: Hearty Stews Grandma’s Farm Stew with Rice and Lamb, Nutro: Hearty Stews Grandpa’s Country Stew with Chicken and Turkey in Gravy, Nutro: Hearty Stews Healthy Chicken and Rice Stew in Gravy, Nutro: Hearty Stews Meaty Lamb and Rice Stew in Gravy, Nutro: Kitchen Classics Family Dinner with Turkey, Rice and Vegetables, Nutro: Kitchen Classics Grass Fed Lamb and Brown Rice Dinner, Nutro: Kitchen Classics Healthy Dinner with Lamb and Vegetables, Nutro: Kitchen Classics Rustic Chicken and Vegetable Dinner, Nutro: Kitchen Classics Slow Cooked Chicken Rice and Oarmeal Dinner, Nutro: Max BEEF & RICE DINNER, Nutro: Max BEEF & RICE DINNER CHUNKS IN GRAVY for Large Breed, Nutro: Max CHICKEN & RICE DINNER for Seniors, Nutro: Max CHICKEN, LAMB & RICE FORMULA for Puppies, Nutro: Max CHICKEN, RICE & LAMB DINNER, Nutro: Max CHICKEN, RICE & TURKEY DINNER, Nutro: Petite Eats Chef Inspired Chicken Entree in Gravy, Nutro: Petite EatsRoasted Turkey and Vegetable Entree in Gravy, Nutro: Petite EatsSignature Beef and Potato Entree in Gravy, Nutro: Ultra ADULT LARGE BREED, Nutro: Ultra ADULT PATÉ CHICKEN, LAMB AND SALMON ENTRÉE, Nutro: Ultra ADULT WEIGHT MANAGEMENT, Nutro: Ultra SENIOR CANNED FOOD, Ol Roy Healthy Mix Beef Stew Wet Dog Food, 10 Oz, Ol Roy Healthy Mix Rice & Lamb Stew Wet Dog Food, 10 Oz, Performatrin Performatrin Ultra® Beef Stew Dog Food, Performatrin Performatrin Ultra® Chicken Stew Dog Food, Performatrin Performatrin Ultra® Grain-Free Foothills Stew Dog Food, Performatrin Performatrin Ultra® Grain-Free Prairie Stew Dog Food, Performatrin Performatrin Ultra® Lamb Stew Dog Food, Performatrin Performatrin Ultra® Turkey Stew Dog Food, PetGuard Beef, Vegetables & Wheat Germ Dinner, PetGuard Beef, Vegetables & Wheat Germ Dinner, PetGuard Lamb & Brown Rice Dinner, PetGuard Lamb & Brown Rice Dinner, PetGuard Organic Vegan Formula, PetGuard Organic Vegan Formula, PetGuard Vegetarian Feast Dinner, Precise: Holistic Complete, Grain Free Grain Free – Beef With Vegetables, Precise: Holistic Complete, Grain Free Grain Free – Chicken With Vegetables, Precise: Holistic Complete, Grain Free Grain Free – Pork With Vegetables, Precise: Holistic Complete, Grain Free Wild at Heart Flight Line – Turkey & Duck, Precise: Holistic Complete, Grain Free Wild at Heart River Line – Salmon & Trout, Precise: Naturals Lamb & Rice Sensicare, Purina Beyond Grain Free Beef & Spinach Recipe In Gravy Wet Dog Food, Purina Beyond Grain Free Chicken & Sweet Potato Recipe In Gravy Wet Dog Food, Purina Beyond Grain Free Turkey & Green Bean Recipe In Gravy Wet Dog Food, Purina: Pro Plan Focus Adult Sensitive Skin and Stomach Salmon and Rice Entree, Rachael Ray Nutrish: Original Beef Stroganwoof, Rachael Ray Nutrish: Original Chicken Muttballs with Pasta, Rachael Ray Nutrish: Original Chicken Paw Pie, Rachael Ray Nutrish: Original Hearty Beef Stew, Rachael Ray Nutrish: Original Rustic Duck Stew, Rachael Ray Nutrish: Original Savory Lamb Stew, Simply Nourish Grain Free, Beef Pot Roast, Simply Nourish Grain Free, Chicken & Salmon, Simply Nourish Grain Free, Chicken & Vegetable, Simply Nourish Grain Free, Chicken Pot Pie, Simply Nourish Grain Free, Turkey & Sweet Potato, Simply Nourish Natural, Chicken & Pasta Stew, Simply Nourish Natural, Chicken & Rice Stew, Simply Nourish Natural, Chicken & Turkey Stew, Simply Nourish Natural, Grain Free, Beef Stew, Simply Nourish Natural, Grain Free, Chicken & Beef Stew, Simply Nourish Natural, Grain Free, Chicken & Beef Stew, Simply Nourish Natural, Grain Free, Chicken & Venison Stew, Simply Nourish Natural, Grain Free, Chicken, Salmon & Sweet Potato Stew, Simply Nourish Natural, Grain Free, Turkey & Duck Stew, Simply Nourish Natural, Turkey Stew, Solid Gold Mighty Mini™ With Lamb Lamb, Sweet Potato & Cranberry Recipe in Gravy, Tiki Dog Chicken & Beef Loco Moco, Tiki Dog Chicken & Duck Maui, Tiki Dog Chicken & Mackerel Poke, Tiki Dog Chicken & Salmon Lomi Lomi, Tiki Dog Chicken & Sardine Okakopa, Tiki Dog Chicken & Shrimp Saimin, Tiki Dog Chicken & Tuna North Shore, Tiki Dog Chicken Huli Huli, Triumph Triumph Grain Free Beef & Vegetable Stew, Variety Pet Foods: Healthy Coat Recipes Mom’s Tasty Mixed Grill, Variety Pet Foods: Homestyle Stew Dad’s Casserole, Variety Pet Foods: Homestyle Stew Grandad’s Roast, Variety Pet Foods: Homestyle Stew Grandma’s Stew, Variety Pet Foods: Homestyle Stew Mom’s CrockPot, Variety Pet Foods: Homestyle Stew Momma’s Best, VeRUS Duck and Potato Formula, Wellness: Complete Health 95% Lamb, Wellness: Complete Health Stews Lamb and Beef Stew with Brown Rice and Apples, Wellness: Complete Health Stews Turkey and Duck Stew with Sweet Potatoes and Cranberries, Wellness: Complete Health Stews Venison and Salmon Stew with Potatoes and Carrots, Wellness: Complete Health Wet Senior, Wellness: Complete Health: Petit Entrees Roasted Beef, Carrots & Red Peppers in Gravy, Wellness: Complete Health: Petit Entrees Roasted Chicken, Beef, Carrots & Green Beans in Gravy, Wellness: Complete Health: Petit Entrees Roasted Chicken, Carrots & Red Peppers in Gravy, Wellness: Complete Health: Petit Entrees Tender Turkey, Green Beans & White Sweet Potatoes in Gravy, Wellness: Core: Chunky Centers Lamb, Turkey and Kale, Wellness: Core: Chunky Centers Salmon, Tuna and Spinach, Wellness: Core: Chunky Centers Tuna, Chicken and Kale, Wellness: Core: Chunky Centers Turkey, Duck and White Sweet Potato, Wellness: TruFood: Tastu Pairings Carrots, Salmon and Cod, Wellness: TruFood: Tastu Pairings Chicken, Carrot and Duck, Wellness: TruFood: Tastu Pairings Chicken, Green Beans and Chicken Liver, Wellness: TruFood: Tastu Pairings Chicken, Pumpkin and Beef, Wellness: TruFood: Tastu Pairings Green Beans, Beef and Lamb Liver, Wellness: TruFood: Tastu Pairings Pumpkin, Lamb and Duck, Weruva: Dog Cuisine Hot Dayam!, Weruva: Dog Cuisine Steak Frites, Weruva: Dog Cuisine That’s my Jam!, Weruva: Dogs in the Kitchen Fowl Ball, Weruva: Dogs in the Kitchen Funk in the Trunk, Weruva: Dogs in the Kitchen Goldie Lox, Weruva: Dogs in the Kitchen Lamburgini, Weruva: Dogs in the Kitchen Love me Tender, Weruva: Dogs in the Kitchen The Double Dip, WholeHearted WholeHearted Grain Free Adult Beef and Vegetable Recipe Wet…, WholeHearted WholeHearted Grain Free Adult Chicken and Fish Recipe Wet Dog…, WholeHearted WholeHearted Grain Free Adult Chicken and Vegetable Recipe Wet…, WholeHearted WholeHearted Grain Free Adult Turkey and Sweet Potato Recipe…, Zoe Dog Food P TÉ WITH BEEF, CUTS OF CHICKEN, CARROTS & SWEET POTATOES, Zoe Dog Food P TÉ WITH CHICKEN, CUTS OF CHICKEN, CARROTS & PEAS, Zoe Dog Food P TÉ WITH LAMB, CUTS OF CHICKEN, POTATOES & PUMPKIN, Zoe Dog Food P TÉ WITH SALMON, CUTS OF CHICKEN, PUMPKIN & PEAS, Zoe Dog Food P TÉ WITH TUNA, CUTS OF CHICKEN, SWEET POTATOES & PUMPKIN, Zoe Dog Food P TÉ WITH TURKEY, CUTS OF CHICKEN, CARROTS & POTATOES

Cut for having mystery meats or meals: 372

Dry: 140
Bil-Jac: Original Adult Select Formula, Bil-Jac: Original Large Breed Adult, Bil-Jac: Original Picky No More™large Breed, Bil-Jac: Original Picky No More™medium Breed, Bil-Jac: Original Picky No More™small Breed, Bil-Jac: Original Reduced Fat Formula, Bil-Jac: Original Senior Select Formula, Bil-Jac: Original Sensitive Solutions With Real Whitefish, Bil-Jac: Original Small Breed Adult, Bil-Jac: Original Small Breed Senior, Black Gold Performance Formula, Cesar Filet Mignon Flavor & Spring Vegetables, Cesar Rotisserie Chicken Flavor & Spring Vegetables, Cesar Slow Roasted Lamb Flavor & Spring Vegetables, Dad’s Trail Mix, Diamond Hi-Energy, Diamond Maintenance, Diamond Original, Diamond Performance, Diamond Premium Adult, Doc’s Choice Premium Adult Formula, Eukanuba Adult Maintenance Dog Food, Eukanuba Adult Weight Management Dog Food, Eukanuba Lamb And Rice Adult Dog Food, Eukanuba Lamb And Rice Adult Large Breed Dog Food, Eukanuba Large Breed Adult Dog Food, Eukanuba Large Breed Weight Management Dog Food, Eukanuba Performance Dog Food: Active Dog Food, Eukanuba Premium Performance Dog Food For Sporting And Hunting Dogs, Eukanuba Small Bite Dog Food, Eukanuba Small Breed Dog Food, Eukanuba Small Breed Weight Management Dog Food, Gravy Train Beefy Classic, Gravy Train Hearty Classic Chicken Flavor, Gravy Train Hearty Pot Roast Flavor, Gravy Train Small Bites Beefy Classic, Grreat Choice Complete Nutrition Adult Dog Food – Chicken, Grreat Choice Complete Nutrition Adult Dog Food – Steak & Veggie, Grreat Choice Targeted Nutrition Large Breed Dog Food – Chicken, Grreat Choice Targeted Nutrition Small Breed Dog Food – Chicken, Hi-Standard: Premium Performance 22/12, Hi-Standard: Premium Performance 23/16 , Hi-Standard: Premium Performance 24/20 Soy Free, Hi-Standard: Premium Performance 26/18 Soy Free, Hi-Standard: Ultimate Ultimate Lamb Meal & Rice Formula, Hi-Tor: Veterinary Select Eno Diet For Dogs, Hi-Tor: Veterinary Select Neo Diet For Dogs , Hi-Tor: Veterinary Select Reduso Diet For Dogs, Hill’s: Prescription Diet B/D Canine: Brain Aging Care, Hill’s: Prescription Diet G/D® Canine: Aging Care, Hill’s: Prescription Diet H/D® Canine: Heart Care, Hill’s: Prescription Diet I/D Stress Canine: Digestive Care, Hill’s: Prescription Diet I/D® Low Fat Canine: Digestive Care/Gi Restore, Hill’s: Prescription Diet J/D Canine Small Bites: Joint Care, Hill’s: Prescription Diet J/D® Canine: Joint Care, Hill’s: Prescription Diet R/D Canine: Weight Reduction, Hill’s: Prescription Diet T/D® Canine Small Bites: Dental Care, Hill’s: Prescription Diet T/D® Canine: Dental Care, Iams: Proactive Health Adult Chunks, Iams: Proactive Health Adult Lamb Meal & Rice, Iams: Proactive Health Adult Large Breed, Iams: Proactive Health Adult Minichunks, Iams: Proactive Health Adult Optimal Weight Large Breed, Iams: Proactive Health Adult Small & Toy Breed, Iams: Proactive Health Adult Weight Control, Iams: Proactive Health Mature Adult, Iams: Proactive Health Mature Adult Large Breed, Iams: Proactive Health Mature Adult Small & Toy Breed, Iams: Proactive Health Senior Plus, Iams: Proactive Health Senior Plus Large Breed, Joy Adult 26/18, Joy High Performance, Joy High-Energy, Joy Lamb Meal & Rice, Joy Maintenance Plus, Joy Performance 32/18, Joy Special Meal, Kibbles ‘n Bits Light & Tasty Roasted Chicken & Vegetable Flavors, Kinetic Active 26K Formula, Kinetic Power 30K Formula, Kinetic Ultra 32K Formula, Ol’ Roy Bacon Flavor Dog Food–Strong Bone, Eye Care, Coat Health, Strong Teeth, Ol’ Roy Bacon Flavor Dry Dog Food–Strong Teeth, Strong Bone, Ol’ Roy Cheeseburger Flavor Dry Dog Food, Ol’ Roy Complete Nutrition Dry Dog Food, Ol’ Roy Dinner Rounds Dry Dog Food, Ol’ Roy High Performance Dry Dog Food, Ol’ Roy High Performance Dry Dog Food–Immune System, Ol’ Roy Small Breed Dry Dog Food–Digestive Health;Muscle Maintenance;Generated;Immunse System Support, Ol’ Roy Small Breed Dry Dog Food–Skin & Coat Care, Ol’ Roy T-Bone & Chicken Flavor Dry Dog Food–Eye Care, Coat Health, Strong Teeth, Strong Bone, Pedigree Dry Dog Food Active Senior Roasted Chicken, Rice & Vegetable Flavor, Pedigree Dry Dog Food Adult Grilled Steak & Vegetable Flavor, Pedigree Dry Dog Food Adult Roasted Chicken, Rice & Vegetable Flavor, Pedigree Dry Dog Food Adult Roasted Lamb, Rice & Vegetable Flavor, Pedigree Dry Dog Food For Big Dogs Roasted Chicken, Rice & Vegetable, Pedigree Dry Dog Food Healthy Weight Roasted Chicken, & Vegetable Flavor, Pedigree Dry Dog Food Small Dog Grilled Salmon, Rice And Vegetable Flavor, Pedigree Dry Dog Food Small Dog Grilled Steak And Vegetable Flavor, Pedigree Dry Dog Food Small Dog Roasted Chicken, Rice & Vegetable Flavor, Pmi Nutrition: Canine Advantage Canine Advantage Formula Dog Food, Purina Bella With Real Chicken & Beef, Purina Bella With Real Chicken & Turkey, Purina: Dog Chow//Puppy Chow Complete Adult Made With Real Beef, Purina: Moist & Meaty Burger With Cheddar Cheese Flavor , Purina: Moist & Meaty Chopped Burger, Purina: Moist & Meaty Rise & Shine Awaken Bacon And Egg Flavor, Purina: Moist & Meaty Steak Flavor, Purina: Pro Plan Veterinary Diets En Gastroenteric Fiber Balance, Purina: Pro Plan Veterinary Diets Jm Joint Mobility, Purina: Pro Plan Veterinary Diets Ur Urinary® Ox/St, Red Flannel Adult, Red Flannel Bites N’ Bones, Red Flannel Canine Select, Red Flannel Hi-Protein, Red Flannel Large Breed, Red Flannel Prime, Redpaw Poweredge 38K, Signature Pet Products: Hi-Tek Rations Hi-Performance 26-18, Signature Pet Products: Hi-Tek Rations Premium Formula 23-14, Signature Pet Products: Premium Blend Adult Plus 21-9, Signature Pet Products: Premium Blend Adult Plus 26-18, Sportmix: Original Formulas Bite Size, Sportmix: Original Formulas Chunk Style, Sportmix: Original Formulas High Protein, Sportmix: Premium Formulas Energy Plus Adult Mini Chunk, Sportmix: Premium Formulas High Energy Adult Chunk, Sportmix: Premium Formulas High Energy Adult Mini Chunk, Sportmix: Premium Formulas Hunter’s Select Adult Mini Chunk, Sportmix: Premium Formulas Maintenance Adult Mini Chunk, Sportmix: Premium Formulas Stamina Adult Mini Chunk, Sportsman’s Pride Lamb Meal & Rice 22/12, Sportsman’s Pride Maintenance 21/12, Sportsman’s Pride Premium Formula 26/18, Sportsman’s Pride Professional 30/20, Vets Choice Golden Years, Vets Choice Large Breed Adult, Vets Choice Lite, Vets Choice Premium, Vets Choice Superior, Bil-Jac: Original Adult Select Formula, Bil-Jac: Original Large Breed Adult, Bil-Jac: Original Picky No More™large Breed, Bil-Jac: Original Picky No More™medium Breed, Bil-Jac: Original Picky No More™small Breed, Bil-Jac: Original Reduced Fat Formula, Bil-Jac: Original Senior Select Formula, Bil-Jac: Original Sensitive Solutions With Real Whitefish, Bil-Jac: Original Small Breed Adult, Bil-Jac: Original Small Breed Senior, Black Gold Performance Formula, Cesar Filet Mignon Flavor & Spring Vegetables, Cesar Rotisserie Chicken Flavor & Spring Vegetables, Cesar Slow Roasted Lamb Flavor & Spring Vegetables, Dad’s Trail Mix, Diamond Hi-Energy, Diamond Maintenance, Diamond Original, Diamond Performance, Diamond Premium Adult, Doc’s Choice Premium Adult Formula, Eukanuba Adult Maintenance Dog Food, Eukanuba Adult Weight Management Dog Food, Eukanuba Lamb And Rice Adult Dog Food, Eukanuba Lamb And Rice Adult Large Breed Dog Food, Eukanuba Large Breed Adult Dog Food, Eukanuba Large Breed Weight Management Dog Food, Eukanuba Performance Dog Food: Active Dog Food, Eukanuba Premium Performance Dog Food For Sporting And Hunting Dogs, Eukanuba Small Bite Dog Food, Eukanuba Small Breed Dog Food, Eukanuba Small Breed Weight Management Dog Food, Gravy Train Beefy Classic, Gravy Train Hearty Classic Chicken Flavor, Gravy Train Hearty Pot Roast Flavor, Gravy Train Small Bites Beefy Classic, Grreat Choice Complete Nutrition Adult Dog Food – Chicken, Grreat Choice Complete Nutrition Adult Dog Food – Steak & Veggie, Grreat Choice Targeted Nutrition Large Breed Dog Food – Chicken, Grreat Choice Targeted Nutrition Small Breed Dog Food – Chicken, Hi-Standard: Premium Performance 22/12, Hi-Standard: Premium Performance 23/16 , Hi-Standard: Premium Performance 24/20 Soy Free, Hi-Standard: Premium Performance 26/18 Soy Free, Hi-Standard: Ultimate Ultimate Lamb Meal & Rice Formula, Hi-Tor: Veterinary Select Eno Diet For Dogs, Hi-Tor: Veterinary Select Neo Diet For Dogs , Hi-Tor: Veterinary Select Reduso Diet For Dogs, Hill’s: Prescription Diet B/D Canine: Brain Aging Care, Hill’s: Prescription Diet G/D® Canine: Aging Care, Hill’s: Prescription Diet H/D® Canine: Heart Care, Hill’s: Prescription Diet I/D Stress Canine: Digestive Care, Hill’s: Prescription Diet I/D® Low Fat Canine: Digestive Care/Gi Restore, Hill’s: Prescription Diet J/D Canine Small Bites: Joint Care, Hill’s: Prescription Diet J/D® Canine: Joint Care, Hill’s: Prescription Diet R/D Canine: Weight Reduction, Hill’s: Prescription Diet T/D® Canine Small Bites: Dental Care, Hill’s: Prescription Diet T/D® Canine: Dental Care, Iams: Proactive Health Adult Chunks, Iams: Proactive Health Adult Lamb Meal & Rice, Iams: Proactive Health Adult Large Breed, Iams: Proactive Health Adult Minichunks, Iams: Proactive Health Adult Optimal Weight Large Breed, Iams: Proactive Health Adult Small & Toy Breed, Iams: Proactive Health Adult Weight Control, Iams: Proactive Health Mature Adult, Iams: Proactive Health Mature Adult Large Breed, Iams: Proactive Health Mature Adult Small & Toy Breed, Iams: Proactive Health Senior Plus, Iams: Proactive Health Senior Plus Large Breed, Joy Adult 26/18, Joy High Performance, Joy High-Energy, Joy Lamb Meal & Rice, Joy Maintenance Plus, Joy Performance 32/18, Joy Special Meal, Kibbles ‘n Bits Light & Tasty Roasted Chicken & Vegetable Flavors, Kinetic Active 26K Formula, Kinetic Power 30K Formula, Kinetic Ultra 32K Formula, Ol’ Roy Bacon Flavor Dog Food–Strong Bone, Eye Care, Coat Health, Strong Teeth, Ol’ Roy Bacon Flavor Dry Dog Food–Strong Teeth, Strong Bone, Ol’ Roy Cheeseburger Flavor Dry Dog Food, Ol’ Roy Complete Nutrition Dry Dog Food, Ol’ Roy Dinner Rounds Dry Dog Food, Ol’ Roy High Performance Dry Dog Food, Ol’ Roy High Performance Dry Dog Food–Immune System, Ol’ Roy Small Breed Dry Dog Food–Digestive Health;Muscle Maintenance;Generated;Immunse System Support, Ol’ Roy Small Breed Dry Dog Food–Skin & Coat Care, Ol’ Roy T-Bone & Chicken Flavor Dry Dog Food–Eye Care, Coat Health, Strong Teeth, Strong Bone, Pedigree Dry Dog Food Active Senior Roasted Chicken, Rice & Vegetable Flavor, Pedigree Dry Dog Food Adult Grilled Steak & Vegetable Flavor, Pedigree Dry Dog Food Adult Roasted Chicken, Rice & Vegetable Flavor, Pedigree Dry Dog Food Adult Roasted Lamb, Rice & Vegetable Flavor, Pedigree Dry Dog Food For Big Dogs Roasted Chicken, Rice & Vegetable, Pedigree Dry Dog Food Healthy Weight Roasted Chicken, & Vegetable Flavor, Pedigree Dry Dog Food Small Dog Grilled Salmon, Rice And Vegetable Flavor, Pedigree Dry Dog Food Small Dog Grilled Steak And Vegetable Flavor, Pedigree Dry Dog Food Small Dog Roasted Chicken, Rice & Vegetable Flavor, Pmi Nutrition: Canine Advantage Canine Advantage Formula Dog Food, Purina Bella With Real Chicken & Beef, Purina Bella With Real Chicken & Turkey, Purina: Dog Chow//Puppy Chow Complete Adult Made With Real Beef, Purina: Moist & Meaty Burger With Cheddar Cheese Flavor , Purina: Moist & Meaty Chopped Burger, Purina: Moist & Meaty Rise & Shine Awaken Bacon And Egg Flavor, Purina: Moist & Meaty Steak Flavor, Purina: Pro Plan Veterinary Diets En Gastroenteric Fiber Balance, Purina: Pro Plan Veterinary Diets Jm Joint Mobility, Purina: Pro Plan Veterinary Diets Ur Urinary® Ox/St, Red Flannel Adult, Red Flannel Bites N’ Bones, Red Flannel Canine Select, Red Flannel Hi-Protein, Red Flannel Large Breed, Red Flannel Prime, Redpaw Poweredge 38K, Signature Pet Products: Hi-Tek Rations Hi-Performance 26-18, Signature Pet Products: Hi-Tek Rations Premium Formula 23-14, Signature Pet Products: Premium Blend Adult Plus 21-9, Signature Pet Products: Premium Blend Adult Plus 26-18, Sportmix: Original Formulas Bite Size, Sportmix: Original Formulas Chunk Style, Sportmix: Original Formulas High Protein, Sportmix: Premium Formulas Energy Plus Adult Mini Chunk, Sportmix: Premium Formulas High Energy Adult Chunk, Sportmix: Premium Formulas High Energy Adult Mini Chunk, Sportmix: Premium Formulas Hunter’s Select Adult Mini Chunk, Sportmix: Premium Formulas Maintenance Adult Mini Chunk, Sportmix: Premium Formulas Stamina Adult Mini Chunk, Sportsman’s Pride Lamb Meal & Rice 22/12, Sportsman’s Pride Maintenance 21/12, Sportsman’s Pride Premium Formula 26/18, Sportsman’s Pride Professional 30/20, Vets Choice Golden Years, Vets Choice Large Breed Adult, Vets Choice Lite, Vets Choice Premium, Vets Choice Superior

Wet: 232
Cesar Classic Beef, Cesar Classic Chicken and Beef, Cesar Classic Chicken and Liver, Cesar Classic Chicken and Veal, Cesar Classic Duck, Cesar Classic Filet Mignon Flavor, Cesar Classic Grilled Chicken Flavor, Cesar Classic Lamb, Cesar Classic Oven Roasted Chicken Flavor, Cesar Classic Porterhouse Steak Flavor, Cesar Classic T-Bone Steak Flavor, Cesar Classic Top Sirloin Flavor, Cesar Classic Turkey, Cesar Filets Filet Mignon Filets Flavor, Cesar Filets New York Strip Flavor, Cesar Filets Prime Rib Flavor, Cesar Home Delights Beef Stew, Cesar Home Delights Beef Stroganoff, Cesar Home Delights Beef With Broccoli & Brown Rice Dinner, Cesar Home Delights Hearty Chicken, Noodle & Vegetables Dinner, Cesar Home Delights Meat Lasagna, Cesar Home Delights Pot Roast With Spring Vegetables Dinner, Cesar Home Delights Slow Cooked Chicken & Vegetables Dinner, Cesar Home Delights Turkey, Green Beans & Potatoes Dinner, Cesar Savory Delights Angus Beef Flavor with Bacon & Cheese, Cesar Savory Delights Filet Mignon Flavor With Bacon & Potato, Cesar Savory Delights Ham and Egg Flavor with Potato and Cheese, Cesar Savory Delights Pork Tenderloin Flavor With Roasted Potatoes & Green Beans, Cesar Savory Delights Porterhouse Steak Flavor With Peas And Carrots, Cesar Savory Delights Rosemary Chicken Flavir with Spring Vegetables, Cesar Savory Delights Rotisserie Chicken Flavor With Bacon & Cheese, Cesar Senior Senior Canine Cuisine With Slow Simmered Chicken & Rice, Cesar Sunrise Chicken and Cheddar Cheese Souffle, Cesar Sunrise Grilled Steak and Egg Flavor, Cesar Sunrise Scramble Egg and Sausage Flavor, Cesar Sunrise Smoked Bacon and Egg, Gravy Train Chunks In Gravy With Beef Chunks, Gravy Train Chunks In Gravy With Lamb & Rice Chunks, Gravy Train Chunks In Gravy With T-Bone Flavor Chunks, Gravy Train Strips In Gravy With Beef Strips, Gravy Train Strips in Gravy with Turkey Strips, Grreat Choice Beef Cuts in Gravy, Grreat Choice Beef, Bacon and Cheese, Grreat Choice Chicken and Rice, Grreat Choice Country Stew, Grreat Choice Delectable Entrees – Chicken and Beef, Grreat Choice Delectable Entrees – Grilled Chicken Flavor, HI-TOR Neo Can, HI-TOR Reduso Can, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Aging Care – Turkey Flavor, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Joint Care with Lamb, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Metabolic – Chicken Flavor, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Original, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Urgent Care n/d with Chicken, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Urinary Care – Chicken Flavor, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Weight Reduction – Original, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Chicken & Barley Entrée, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Chicken & Beef Entrée, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Light with Liver, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Small & Toy Chicken & Barley Entrée, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Small & Toy Light with Liver, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Turkey & Barley Entree, IAMS™ PROACTIVE HEALTH™ (Adult) Beef and Rice, IAMS™ PROACTIVE HEALTH™ (Adult) Beef and Vegetables in Gravy, IAMS™ PROACTIVE HEALTH™ (Adult) Chicken and Beef in Gravy, IAMS™ PROACTIVE HEALTH™ (Adult) Chicken and Rice, IAMS™ PROACTIVE HEALTH™ (Adult) Chicken and Vegetables in Gravy, IAMS™ PROACTIVE HEALTH™ (Adult) Chicken in Gravy, IAMS™ PROACTIVE HEALTH™ (Adult) Grilled Medley with Chicken and Beef, IAMS™ PROACTIVE HEALTH™ (Adult) Lamb and Rice, IAMS™ PROACTIVE HEALTH™ (Adult) Turkey and Rice, Kibbles ‘n Bits – Chef’s Choice Bistro Tender Cuts With Real Beef & Vegetables in Gravy, Kibbles ‘n Bits – Chef’s Choice Bistro Tender Cuts With Real Turkey, Bacon & Vegetables in Gravy, Kibbles ‘n Bits – Chef’s Choice Homestyle Tender Slices With Real Beef, Chicken & Vegetables in Gravy, Ol Roy Ol Roy Ol’roy 3.5oz Filet Mignon Flavor Dog Cup, Ol Roy Ol’ Roy Grilled Chicken Flavor Wet Dog Food, 3.5 oz, Ol Roy Ol’ Roy Meaty Loaf With Savory Beef Wet Dog Food, 22 Oz, Ol Roy Ol’ Roy Mini Chunks in Gravy Country Stew Dry Dog Food, 5.3 Oz, 6 Ct, Ol Roy Ol’ Roy Mini Chunks in Gravy Filet Mignon Flavor Wet Dog Food, 5.3 Oz, 6 Ct, Ol Roy Ol’ Roy Mini Chunks in Gravy With Lamb & Rice Wet Dog Food, 5.3 Oz, 6 Ct, Ol Roy Ol’ Roy Porterhouse Steak Flavor Wet Dog Food, 3.5 oz, Ol Roy Ol’ Roy Wet Dog Food With Beef, 3.5 oz, Ol Roy Ol’ Roy With Turkey In Savory Juices Wet Dog Food, 3.5 Oz, Ol Roy Ol’Roy Meaty Loaf with Beef & Vegetables Wet Dog Food, 13.2 Oz, Pedigree – Choice Cuts in Gravy Can Beef, Pedigree – Choice Cuts in Gravy Can Beef & Barley, Pedigree – Choice Cuts in Gravy Can Beef & Liver, Pedigree – Choice Cuts in Gravy Can Beef & Rice, Pedigree – Choice Cuts in Gravy Can Chicken, Pedigree – Choice Cuts in Gravy Can Chicken & Rice, Pedigree – Choice Cuts in Gravy Can Country Stew, Pedigree – Choice Cuts in Gravy Can Lamb & Vegetables, Pedigree – Choice Cuts in Gravy Can Steak & Vegetable Flavor, Pedigree – Choice Cuts in Gravy Pouch Beef, Noodles & Vegetables Flavor in Sauce, Pedigree – Choice Cuts in Gravy Pouch Chicken Casserole, Pedigree – Choice Cuts in Gravy Pouch Filet Mignon Flavor in Gravy, Pedigree – Choice Cuts in Gravy Pouch Grilled Chicken Flavor in Sauce, Pedigree – Chopped Ground Dinner Bacon & Filet Mignon Flavor, Pedigree – Chopped Ground Dinner Beef, Pedigree – Chopped Ground Dinner Beef, Bacon and Cheese Flavors, Pedigree – Chopped Ground Dinner Chicken, Pedigree – Chopped Ground Dinner Chicken and Rice, Pedigree – Chopped Ground Dinner Chicken, Beef & Liver, Pedigree – Chopped Ground Dinner Filet Mignon & Bacon Flavor, Pedigree – Chopped Ground Dinner Filet Mignon Flavor, Pedigree – Chopped Ground Dinner Ground Dinner with Hearty Chicken, Pedigree – Chopped Ground Dinner Ground Dinner with Slow Cooked Beef, Pedigree – Chopped Ground Dinner Liver & Beef, Pedigree – Chopped Ground Dinner T-bone Steak Flavor, Pedigree – Chopped Ground Dinner Top Sirloin Steak Flavor, Pedigree – Chunky Ground Dinner Beef, Pedigree – Chunky Ground Dinner Beef, Bacon & Cheese Flavor, Pedigree – Chunky Ground Dinner Chicken, Pedigree – Chunky Ground Dinner Turkey & Bacon, Pedigree – Homestyle Meals Hearty Beef and Vegetable Flavor in Gravy, Pedigree – Homestyle Meals Hearty Chicken and Vegetable Flavor in Gravy, Pedigree – Homestyle Meals Lamb and Rice Flavor Stew, Pedigree – Homestyle Meals Porterhouse Steak and Vegetable Flavor in Gravy, Pedigree – Homestyle Meals Prime Rib, Rice, and Vegetable Flavor in Gravy, Pedigree – Homestyle Meals Roasted Chicken, Rice, and Vegetable Flavor in Gravy, Pedigree – Weight Management Beef & Liver Dinner, Pedigree – Weight Management Chicken & Rice Dinner, PetGuard Vegetarian Feast Dinner, President’s Choice Nutrition First PC Extra Meaty Dog Food – Beef Stew Cuts in Gravy, President’s Choice Nutrition First PC Extra Meaty Dog Food – Beef, Bacon & Cheese Dinner Cuts In Gravy, President’s Choice Nutrition First PC Extra Meaty Dog Food – Chicken Dinner Cuts in Gravy, Purina Alpo CHOP HOUSE® BEEF TENDERLOIN FLAVOR IN GOURMET GRAVY, Purina Alpo CHOP HOUSE® FILET MIGNON & BACON FLAVORS COOKED IN SAVORY JUICES, Purina Alpo CHOP HOUSE® PRIME RIB FLAVOR COOKED IN SAVORY JUICES, Purina Alpo CHOP HOUSE® ROASTED CHICKEN & TOP SIRLOIN FLAVORS COOKED IN SAVORY JUICES, Purina Alpo CHOP HOUSE® ROTISSERIE CHICKEN FLAVOR IN GOURMET GRAVY, Purina Alpo CHOP HOUSE® T-BONE & RIBEYE STEAK FLAVORS COOKED IN SAVORY JUICES, Purina Alpo CHOP HOUSE® T-BONE STEAK FLAVOR IN GOURMET GRAVY, Purina Alpo GRAVY CRAVERS® ROAST BEEF FLAVOR IN GRAVY, Purina Alpo GRAVY CRAVERS® WITH BEEF IN GRAVY, Purina Alpo GRAVY CRAVERS® WITH CHICKEN IN GRAVY, Purina Alpo PRIME CLASSICS™ WITH BEEF, Purina Alpo PRIME CLASSICS™ WITH BEEF PLUS BACON & CHEESE FLAVORS, Purina Alpo PRIME CLASSICS™ WITH CHICKEN & RICE, Purina Alpo PRIME CUTS® LONDON GRILL & WHOLESOME VEGGIE ACCENTS IN GRAVY, Purina Alpo PRIME CUTS® STEW WITH BEEF AND VEGETABLES IN GRAVY, Purina Alpo PRIME CUTS® WITH BEEF IN GRAVY, Purina Alpo PRIME CUTS® WITH BEEF, BACON & CHEESE IN GRAVY, Purina Alpo PRIME CUTS® WITH CHICKEN & WHOLESOME VEGGIE ACCENTS IN GRAVY, Purina Alpo PRIME CUTS® WITH LAMB & RICE IN GRAVY, Purina Alpo PRIME CUTS® WITH TURKEY & BACON IN GRAVY, Purina Bella Filet Mignon Flavor, Purina Bella Porterhouse Steak Flavor, Purina Bella With Beef, Purina Bella With Chicken & Smoked Bacon, Purina Bella With Turkey, Purina Beneful Beef and Chicken Medley with green beans, carrots, and wild rice, Purina Beneful Beef Stew with peas, carrots, rice, and barley, Purina Beneful CHICKEN STEW with rice, carrots, peas, and barley, Purina Beneful Mediterranean Style Medley, with lamb, tomatoes, brown rice, and spinach, Purina Beneful ROASTED CHICKEN RECIPE with pasta, carrots, & spinach, Purina Beneful ROASTED TURKEY MEDLEY with corn, wild rice, peas & barley, Purina Beneful ROMANA STYLE MEDLEY with chicken, carrots, pasta, and spinach, Purina Beneful SAVORY RICE & LAMB STEW with peas and carrots, Purina Beneful SIMMERED BEEF ENTRÉE with carrots, barley, wild rice, and spinach, Purina Beneful SIMMERED CHICKEN MEDLEY with green beans, carrots, and wild rice, Purina Beneful TUSCAN STYLE MEDLEY with beef, carrots, rice, and spinach, Purina Beneful with beef, carrots, peas, and barley, Purina Beneful with beef, tomatoes, carrots, and wild rice, Purina Beneful with chicken, carrots, peas, and wild rice, Purina Beneful with chicken, liver, peas, brown rice & sweet potatoes, Purina Beneful with chicken, tomatoes, carrots, and wild rice, Purina Beneful with lamb, brown rice, carrots, tomatoes, and spinach, Purina Beneful with salmon, sweet potatoes, brown rice & spinach, Purina Beneful with salmon, tomatoes, carrots, and wild rice, Purina Beneful with turkey, sweet potatoes, brown rice, and spinach, Purina: Mighty Dog Chicken and Smoked Bacon Combo, Purina: Mighty Dog Chicken, Egg & Bacon Country Platter, Purina: Mighty Dog Hearty Beef Dinner, Purina: Mighty Dog Hearty Pulled-Style Beef Dinner in Gravy, Purina: Mighty Dog Hearty Pulled-Style Chicken Dinner in Gravy, Purina: Mighty Dog Lamb and Rice, Purina: Mighty Dog Porterhouse Steak Flavor in Gravy, Purina: Mighty Dog Rotisserie Chicken Flavor, Purina: Mighty Dog Savory Steak Flavor, Purina: Mighty Dog Seared Beef Dinner with Cheese in Gravy, Purina: Mighty Dog Seared Chicken Dinner with Cheese in Gravy, Purina: Mighty Dog Tenderloin Tips Flavor in Gravy, Purina: Mighty Dog Thick-Sliced Beef Dinner in Gravy, Purina: Mighty Dog Thick-Sliced Chicken Dinner in Gravy, Purina: ONE SmartBlend Beef and Barley Entree Tender Cuts in Gravy, Purina: ONE SmartBlend Beef and Brown Rice Entree, Purina: ONE SmartBlend Chicken and Brown Rice Entree, Purina: ONE SmartBlend Chicken and Brown Rice Entree Tender Cuts in Gravy, Purina: ONE SmartBlend Lamb and Brown Rice in Gravy, Purina: ONE SmartBlend Lamb and Long Grain Rice Entree, Purina: ONE SmartBlend Turkey and Barley Entree, Purina: Pro Plan Bright Mind Beef and Brown Rice Entree in Gravy, Purina: Pro Plan Focus Adult Beef and Rice Entree in Gravy, Purina: Pro Plan Focus Adult Chicken and Rice Entree in Gravy, Purina: Pro Plan Focus Adult Weight Management Turkey and Rice Entree in Morsel Gravy, Purina: Pro Plan Focus Adults 7+ Beef and Rice Entree in Gravy, Purina: Pro Plan Savor Beef and Vegetables Entree in Gravy, Purina: Pro Plan Savor Chicken and Vegetable Entree in Gravy, Purina: Pro Plan Savor Classic Beef and Brown Rice Entree, Purina: Pro Plan Savor Classic Chicken and Rice Entree, Purina: Pro Plan Savor Grain Free Beef and Peas Entree, Purina: Pro Plan Savor Grain Free Chicken and Carrots, Purina: Pro Plan Savor Grain Free Turkey and Sweet Potato, Purina: Pro Plan Savor Lamb and Vegetable Entree in Gravy, Purina: Pro Plan Savor Seared Beef, Green Beans and Brown Rice Entree in Gravy, Purina: Pro Plan Savor Shreded Beef and Lamb Entree in Gravy, Purina: Pro Plan Savor Shreded Turkey, Peas and Brown Rice Entree in Gravy, Purina: Pro Plan Savor Turkey and Vegetables Entree in Gravy, Purina: Pro Plan Savory Meals Braised Beef Entree with Wild Rice, Purina: Pro Plan Savory Meals Braised Chicken Entre with Real Spinach, Purina: Pro Plan Savory Meals Braised Pork Entree with Real Carrots, Purina: Pro Plan Savory Meals Braised Turkey Entree with Barley, Purina: Pro Plan Savory Meals Grilled Ocean Whitefish Entree with Brown Rice, Purina: Pro Plan Savory Meals Grilled Salmon Entree with Real Sweet Potatoes, Purina: Pro Plan Veterinary Diets CN Critical Nutrition™ Canine and Feline Formula, Purina: Pro Plan Veterinary Diets EN GASTROENTERIC LOW FAT CANINE FORMULA, Purina: Pro Plan Veterinary Diets EN Gastroenteric® Canine Formula, Purina: Pro Plan Veterinary Diets NF Kidney Function™ Canine Formula, Purina: Pro Plan Veterinary Diets OM Overweight Management™ Canine Formula, Purina: Pro Plan Veterinary Diets UR Urinary® Ox/St™ Canine Formula, Purina: Winalot Cassaroles Beef, Pasta, Carrots in Gravy, Purina: Winalot Cassaroles Chicken and Vegetables in Gravy, Purina: Winalot Cassaroles Lamb, Rice and Carrots in Gravy, Purina: Winalot Classics Chicken in Jelly, Purina: Winalot Classics Cod and Plaice in Jelly, Purina: Winalot Classics Duck and Rabbit in Jelly, Purina: Winalot Classics Lamb and Turkey in Jelly, Purina: Winalot Classics Tripe and Chicken in Jelly, Purina: Winalot Classics Tripe and Duck in Jelly, Purina: Winalot Classics Tripe and Turkey in Jelly, Purina: Winalot Classics Tuna in Jelly

Cut: Formulas that relied on plant-based proteins

Deducing how much of your dog food's protein comes from meat versus plant sources is no easy task. Labeling laws don’t require a breakdown of this information, and every single one of our remaining 2,354 dog foods contained plant-based ingredients of some kind. But as a general rule, the more prominently fillers like corn, soy or beans are displayed on the ingredient list, the lower the quality of the formula.

The grocery store brand Kibbles ‘n Bits ($0.46 per pound), which has a 1-star rating on Dog Food Advisor, lists “corn” and “soybean meal" as its first two ingredients. Since we’d already established that our top picks had to have a protein like beef or chicken at the top of the list, we cut any formulas with non-meat fillers as the second ingredient.

What we cut: 537

Wet:
The wet foods on our list had fewer plant-based fillers than dry kibble. All of them passed this requirement.

Dry: 537
4Health: Special Care Weight Management Formula For Adult Dogs, 4Health: Untamed Open Highland Recipe Lamb & Lentil Formula Dog Food, 4Health: Untamed Wild River Recipe Trout & Lentil Formula Dog Food, Abound Grain Free Chicken, Chickpea & Sweet Potato Recipe, Abound Grain Free Salmon & Sweet Potato Recipe, Abound Lamb & Brown Rice Recipe, Abound Salmon & Sweet Potato Recipe, Abound Superfood Blend Salmon, Egg & Pumpkin Recipe, Addiction: Dry Le Lamb, Addiction: Dry Salmon Bleu, Addiction: Dry Viva La Venison, Addiction: Dry Wild Kangaroo & Apples, Adirondack 21% Protein Everyday Recipe For Adult Dogs, Adirondack 26% Protein Active Recipe For Adult Dogs, Adirondack 30% Protein High-Fat Recipe For Puppy & Performance Dogs, Adirondack Large Breed Recipe For Adult Dogs, American Natural Premium Basic Formula, American Natural Premium Duck & Pork, American Natural Premium Endurance Plus, American Natural Premium Exhibitor’s Choice, American Natural Premium Lamb & Rice, American Natural Premium Ocean Fish & Potato, American Natural Premium Original Recipe, American Natural Premium Pork, American Natural Premium Sensitive Care, Ancestry Chicken & Sweet Potato, Ancestry Chicken And Rice, Ancestry Duck And Potato, Ancestry Lamb & Rice, Ancestry Lamb & Sweet Potato, Ancestry Salmon & Sweet Potato, Annamaet Adult Formula, Annamaet Aqualuk Formula, Annamaet Encore Formula, Annamaet Extra Formula, Annamaet Lean Formula, Annamaet Option Formula, Annamaet Salcha Formula, Annamaet Small Breed Formula, Annamaet Ultra Formula, Authority Ender Blends Adult Dog Food – Beef & Rice, Avoderm Chicken Meal & Brown Rice Formula, Avoderm Chicken Meal & Brown Rice Formula Large Breed, Avoderm Chicken Meal & Brown Rice Formula Senior, Avoderm Chicken Meal & Brown Rice Formula Small Breed, Avoderm Grain Free Chicken Meal & Potato Formula, Avoderm Grain Free Red Meat Meal & Potato Formula, Avoderm Grain Free Salmon Meal & Potato Formula, Avoderm Joint Health Grain Free Chicken Meal Formula, Avoderm Lamb Meal & Brown Rice Formula, Avoderm Oven-Baked Original Formula With Beef Meal, Avoderm Senior Health+ Grain Free Lamb Meal Formula, Avoderm Senior Health+ Grain Free Lamb Meal Formula For Small Breeds, Avoderm Triple Protein Meal Formula, Azmira Lifestyle® Lamb Formula, Azmira Rustic Feast (Turkey) Formula, Beaverdam Adult 26/18 Hi-Energy, Beaverdam Eli’s Select – A Signature Blend Of Premium Dog Food, Beaverdam Hi-Protein 27/12, Beaverdam Skipper’s Choice 21/12 Maintenance, Bench And Field Holistic Canine Formula, Bil-Jac: Original Grain Free, Black Gold Beef Meal & Barley Formula, Black Gold Chicken Meal & Brown Rice Formula, Black Gold Grain Free Game Bird With Turkey & Quail Formula, Black Gold Grain Free Ocean Catch With Salmon & Whitefish Formula, Black Gold Grain Free Timber Ridge With Beef & Venison Formula, Black Gold Mature 7+ Formula, Black Gold Ocean Fish Meal & Oat Formula, Blackwood 1000 Everyday Diet Chicken Meal With Oats, Blackwood 2000 Active Diet Chicken Meal With Brown Rice, Blackwood 3000 Everyday Diet Lamb Meal & Brown Rice Recipe, Blackwood Adult Dog Everyday Diet: Chicken Meal & Brown Rice Recipe, Blackwood All Life Stages Special Diet Buffalo Meal & Field Pea, Blackwood All Life Stages Special Diet Chicken Meal & Field Pea, Blackwood All Life Stages Special Diet Lamb Meal & Brown Rice, Blackwood All Life Stages Special Diet Salmon Meal & Brown Rice, Blackwood All Life Stages Special Diet Salmon Meal & Field Pea, Blackwood All Life Stages Special Diet: Catfish Meal & Pearled Barley, Blackwood Large Breed Adult Dog: Whitefish Meal & Oatmeal Recipe, Blackwood Lean/Senior Adult Dog Chicken Meal & Brown Rice Recipe, Blue Buffalo: Blue Basics Grain-Free Duck & Potato Recipe Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Basics Grain-Free Lamb & Potato Large Breed Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Basics Grain-Free Lamb & Potato Recipe Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Basics Grain-Free Salmon & Potato Recipe Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Basics Healthy Weight Turkey & Potato Recipe Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Basics Salmon & Potato Recipe Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Basics Turkey & Potato Recipe Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Basics Turkey & Potato Recipe Large Breed Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Basics Turkey & Potato Recipe Small Breed Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Earth’s Essentials Harvest Table With Farm-Raised Chicken, Blue Buffalo: Blue Earth’s Essentials Mountaintop Medley With Pasture-Raised Lamb, Blue Buffalo: Blue Earth’s Essentials Pacific Grill With Fresh-Caught Salmon, Blue Buffalo: Blue Natural Veterinary Diet Ks Kidney Support, Bogo Bowl Chicken Meal & Rice Formula, Bogo Bowl Grain Free Chicken Formula, Bogo Bowl Healthy Weight Dog Formula, Bogo Bowl Lamb Meal & Rice Formula, Bogo Bowl Maintenance Formula, Bogo Bowl Salmon Meal & Rice Formula , Boka Chicken Meal & Oatmeal Recipe, Boka Pork Meal & Oatmeal Recipe, Boreal Proper Chicken – Grains With Low Carbohydrate, Boreal Proper Large Breed Chicken Meal, Boreal Proper Large Breed Red Meat – Low Carb Grains, Boreal Proper Marine Fish – Low Carbohydrate Grains, Boreal Vital All-Breed Chicken Meal, Boreal Vital Large-Breed Chicken Meal, Buckley: Liberty Chicken, Buckley: Liberty Lamb, Bully Max 30/20 High Performance Dog Food, California Natural Chicken Meal & Rice Recipe, California Natural Chicken Meal Recipe, California Natural Herring & Sweet Potato Recipe, California Natural Kangaroo & Red Lentils Recipe, California Natural Lamb Meal & Rice Recipe, California Natural Lamb Meal Recipe, California Natural Salmon Meal & Peas Recipe, California Natural Venison & Green Lentils Recipe, Canidae: All Life Stages Chicken Meal & Rice Formula, Canidae: All Life Stages Duck Meal & Brown Rice Formula, Canidae: All Life Stages Duck Meal, Brown Rice & Lentils Formula, Canidae: All Life Stages Lamb Meal & Rice Formula, Canidae: All Life Stages Multi-Protein Formula, Canidae: All Life Stages Turkey Meal & Brown Rice Formula, Canidae: Grain Free Pure Petite Small Breed With Fresh Chicken, Canidae: Grain Free Pure Petite Small Breed With Fresh Lamb, Canidae: Grain Free Pure Petite Small Breed With Fresh Salmon, Canidae: Under The Sun Grain Free Large Breed With Chicken, Canidae: Under The Sun Grain Free Small Breed With Chicken, Canidae: Under The Sun Grain Free With Chicken, Canidae: Under The Sun Grain Free With Lamb, Canidae: Under The Sun Grain Free With Whitefish, Canidae: Under The Sun Original Formula With Chicken, Canine Caviar Free Spirit, Canine Caviar Free Spirit, Canine Caviar Leaping Spirit, Canine Caviar Leaping Spirit, Canine Caviar Open Meadow, Canine Caviar Open Meadow, Canine Caviar Open Sky, Canine Caviar Open Sky, Canine Caviar Wild Ocean, Canine Caviar Wild Ocean, Country Vet Naturals Active 30-20 Formula, Country Vet Naturals Grain Free 28/16 Formula, Country Vet Naturals Healthy 24-14 Formula, Country Vet Naturals Senior 24-10 Formula, Dave’s Pet Food: Delicate Dinners Delicate Dinners, Easy To Digest, Dave’s Pet Food: Grain Free For Dogs Grain Free Countryside Blend, Dave’s Pet Food: Naturally Healthy Naturally Healthy™ Pork Meal & Sweet Potato, Dave’s Pet Food: Simply The Best Simply The Best, Diamond Naturals Adult Dog Beef Meal & Rice Formula, Diamond Naturals Adult Dog Lamb Meal & Rice Formula, Diamond Naturals Large Breed Adult Dog Lamb Meal & Rice Formula, Diamond Naturals Light Adult Dog Lamb Meal & Rice Formula, Doc’s Choice Chicken And Brown Rice, Doc’s Choice Chicken And Potato, Doc’s Choice Lamb And Brown Rice, Doc’s Choice Lamb And Sweet Potato, Dog Lovers Gold Dog Lovers Gold, Dr. Gary’s Best Breed: Holistic Dog Formulas Chicken With Vegetables And Herbs, Dr. Gary’s Best Breed: Holistic Dog Formulas Salmon With Vegetables And Herbs, Dr. Gary’s Best Breed: Holistic Grain Free Dog Formulas Grain Free Chicken With Fruits & Vegetables, Dr. Gary’s Best Breed: Holistic Grain Free Dog Formulas Grain Free Salmon With Fruits & Vegetables, Dr. Tim’s: Active Glacier, Dr. Tim’s: Active Pursuit, Dr. Tim’s: Casual Kinesis, Dr. Tim’s: Casual Kinesis Grain Free Formula, Dr. Tim’s: Extreme Athlete Momentum, Dr. Tim’s: Weight Management Metabolite, Eagle Pack Original Adult, Eagle Pack Reduced Fat Adult, Earthborn Holistic: Grain-Free Holistic Coastal Catch, Earthborn Holistic: Grain-Free Holistic Great Plains Feast™, Earthborn Holistic: Grain-Free Holistic Large Breed, Earthborn Holistic: Grain-Free Holistic Meadow Feast™, Earthborn Holistic: Grain-Free Holistic Weight Control, Earthborn Holistic: Holistic Adult Vantage, Earthborn Holistic: Holistic Ocean Fusion, Earthborn Holistic: Holistic Small Breed, Earthborn Holistic: Venture Alaska Pollock Meal & Pumpkin, Earthborn Holistic: Venture Duck Meal & Pumpkin, Earthborn Holistic: Venture Pork Meal & Butternut Squash, Earthborn Holistic: Venture Rabbit Meal & Pumpkin, Earthborn Holistic: Venture Squid & Chickpeas, Earthborn Holistic: Venture Turkey Meal & Butternut Squash, Eukanuba Adult Salmon Dog Food, Eukanuba Large Breed Salmon Dog Food, Evanger’s Grain Free Chicken With Sweet Potato & Pumpkin , Evanger’s Grain-Free Meat Lover’s Medley With Rabbit Dry Food, Evolve Beef, Barley & Brown Rice Formula Dog Food, Evolve Chicken & Rice Formula Senior Dog Food, Evolve Lamb & Rice Formula Dog Food, Firstmate & Kasiks Cage Free Chicken Meal & Oats Formula, Firstmate & Kasiks Firstmate: Australian Lamb Meal Formula, Firstmate & Kasiks Firstmate: Chicken Meal With Blueberries Formula, Firstmate & Kasiks Firstmate: Pacific Ocean Fish Meal Large Breed Formula, Firstmate & Kasiks Firstmate: Pacific Ocean Fish Meal Original Formula, Firstmate & Kasiks Free Range Lamb & Oats Formula, Firstmate & Kasiks Kasiks: Fre Run Chicken Meal Formula, Firstmate & Kasiks Kasiks: Free Range Lamb Meal Formula, Firstmate & Kasiks Kasiks: Wild Pacific Ocean Fish Meal Formula, Firstmate & Kasiks Wild Pacific Caught Fish & Oats Formula, Firstmate: Skoki Skoki, Forza10: Legend All Life M/L, Forza10: Legend All Life Small, Forza10: Legend Digestion, Forza10: Legend Skin, Forza10: Sensitive Behavioral Plus, Forza10: Sensitive Digestion Plus, Forza10: Sensitive Ear Plus, Forza10: Sensitive Joint Plus, Forza10: Sensitive Skin Plus, Forza10: Sensitive Tear Stain Plus, Fromm: Four-Star Beef Frittata Veg Dog, Fromm: Four-Star Pork & Peas, Gentle Giants Gentle Giants Canine Nutrition Chicken Dry Dog Food, Gentle Giants Gentle Giants Canine Nutrition Samon Dry Dog Food, Good Natured Grain Free Adult Dog Food – Natural, Lamb & Pea, Good Natured Grain Free Adult Dog Food – Natural, Salmon & Sweet Potato, Grandma Mae’s Country Naturals Farmhouse Blend For Dogs, Grandma Mae’s Country Naturals Grain Free Non-Gmo Duck Meal Recipe, Grandma Mae’s Country Naturals Grain Free Non-Gmo Venison Meal Recipe, Grandma Mae’s Country Naturals Large Breed Formula, Halo Halo Holistic Grain Free Turkey, Turkey Liver, And Duck Recipe For Senior Dogs, Halo Halo Holistic Healthy Weight Grain Free Turkey, Turkey Liver, And Duck Recipe For Adult Dogs, Hi-Standard: Grain Free Pure Grain Free, Hi-Standard: Premium Performance 30/20 Soy Free, Hi-Standard: Ultimate Ultimate Chicken Meal & Rice Formula, Hill’s: Ideal Balance Grain Free Natural Chicken & Potato Recipe Adult, Hill’s: Ideal Balance Large Breed Natural Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Adult Dog Food, Hill’s: Ideal Balance Natural Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Adult, Hill’s: Ideal Balance Natural Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Mature Adult, Hill’s: Ideal Balance Small Breed Natural Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Adult, Hill’s: Prescription Diet I/D® Low Fat Natural Canine: Digestive Care/Gi Restore, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Metabolic + Mobility Canine: Weight + Joint Care, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Metabolic Canine Lamb Meal & Rice Formula: Weight Management, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Metabolic Canine: Weight Management, Hill’s: Prescription Diet Metabolic Natural Canine: Weight Management, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult 11+ Small & Toy Breed Age Defying Dog Food, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult 6+ Large Breed Dog Food, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult 7+ Active Longevity Original Dog Food, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult 7+ Active Longevity Small Bites Dog Food, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult 7+ Small & Toy Breed, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Advanced Fitness Lamb Meal & Rice Recipe, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Advanced Fitness Original Dog Food, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Advanced Fitness Small Bites, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Advanced Fitness Small Bites Lamb Meal & Rice Recipe Dog Food, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Grain Free Dog Food, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Healthy Mobility™ Large Breed Dog Food, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Healthy Mobility™ Small Bites Dog Food, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Large Breed Dog Food, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Large Breed Lamb Meal & Rice Recipe Dog Food, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Large Breed Light, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Light Dog Food, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Light Small & Toy Breed Dog Food, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Light Small Bites Dog Food, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Oral Care Dog Food, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Perfect Weight Dog Food, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Perfect Weight Small & Toy Breed Dog Food, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Small & Toy Breed Dog Food, Hill’s: Science Diet Adult Small & Toy Breed Lamb Meal & Rice Recipe Dog Food, Hill’s: Science Diet Youthful Vitality Adult 7+ Chicken & Rice Recipe Dog Food, Hill’s: Science Diet Youthful Vitality Adult 7+ Small & Toy Breed Chicken & Rice Recipe Dog Food, Holistic Blend: Holistic Blend All Life Stages Chicken, Rice & Vegetable, Holistic Blend: Holistic Blend All Life Stages Lamb & Rice, Holistic Blend: The Perfect Blend The Perfect Blend – Dog, Holistic Select Adult Health: Anchovy & Sardine And Salmon Meals Recipe, Holistic Select Adult Health: Chicken Meal & Rice Recipe, Holistic Select Adult Health: Duck Meal Recipe, Holistic Select Adult Health: Lamb Meal Recipe, Holistic Select Grain Free Large Breed Adult Health: Chicken Meal & Lentils Recipe, Holistic Select Large & Giant Breed Adult Health: Chicken Meal & Oatmeal Recipe, Holistic Select Senior Health: Chicken Meal & Rice Recipe, Holistic Select Small & Mini Breed Adult Health: Anchovy & Sardine And Chicken Meals Recipe, Holistic Select Weight Management: Chicken Meal & Peas Recipe, Horizon: Complete All Life Stage, Horizon: Complete Large Breed Adult, Horizon: Pulsar Chicken, Horizon: Pulsar Fish, Horizon: Pulsar Lamb, Horizon: Pulsar Pork, Horizon: Pulsar Turkey, Humankind Active Dogs, Humankind Highly Active Dogs, Humankind Less Active Dogs, Iams: Healthy Naturals Adult Chicken + Barley Recipe, Iams: Healthy Naturals Adult Chicken + Garden Pea Recipe, Iams: Healthy Naturals Adult Grain Free Salmon + Red Lentils, Iams: Healthy Naturals Adult Ocean Fish + Rice Recipe, Iams: Healthy Naturals Adult With Lamb + Rice, Jack’s Premium Beef Meal & Brown Rice, Jack’s Premium Chicken And Rice, Jack’s Premium Grain Free Beef, Jack’s Premium Grain Free Chicken, Jack’s Premium Grain Free Whitefish, Joy Pure Grain Free, Joy Super Meal, Kirkland Signature Healthy Weight Formula Chicken & Vegetable Dog Food, Kirkland Signature Nature’s Domain Beef Meal & Sweet Potato Dog Food, Kirkland Signature Nature’s Domain Organic Chicken & Pea Dog Food, Kirkland Signature Nature’s Domain Salmon Meal & Sweet Potato Dog Food, Kirkland Signature Nature’s Domain Turkey Meal And Sweet Potato Dog Food, Life’s Abundance Adult Weight Loss, Life’s Abundance All Stage Dog Food, Livesmart Chicken Meal And Brown Rice Adult Dog Formula, Livesmart Chicken Meal And Brown Rice Senior Dog Formula, Livesmart Chicken Meal And Brown Rice Weight Management Dog Formula, Livesmart Lamb Meal And Brown Rice Adult Dog Formula, Livesmart Salmon Meal And Brown Rice Adult Dog Formula, Native Performance Native® Level 1, Native Performance Native® Level 2, Native Performance Native® Level 3, Natural Balance: L.I.D. High Protein Beef Formula Dry Dog Food, Natural Balance: L.I.D. High Protein Lamb Formula Dry Dog Food, Natural Balance: L.I.D. Lamb Meal & Brown Rice Dry Dog Formula, Natural Balance: L.I.D. Legume & Duck Meal Dry Dog Formula, Natural Balance: Ultra Whole Body Health® Chicken, Brown Rice, Duck Meal Large Breed Bites® Dry Dog Formula, Natural Balance: Ultra Whole Body Health® Chicken, Chicken Meal, Duck Meal Dry Dog Formula, Natural Balance: Ultra Whole Body Health® Chicken, Chicken Meal, Duck Meal Small Breed Bites ® Dry Dog Formula, Natural Dog Food Company Adult Salmon, Natural Planet Turkey & Peas Formula, Nature’s Logic Canine Beef Meal Feast, Nature’s Logic Canine Chicken Meal Feast, Nature’s Logic Canine Duck & Salmon Meal Feast, Nature’s Logic Canine Lamb Meal Feast, Nature’s Logic Canine Pork Meal Feast, Nature’s Logic Canine Sardine Meal Feast, Nature’s Logic Canine Turkey Meal Feast, Nature’s Recipe: Grain-Free Grain Free Easy To Digest Salmon, Sweet Potato, & Pumpkin Recipe, Nature’s Recipe: Healthy Skin Healthy Skin Venison Meal & Rice Recipe, Nature’s Recipe: Original Recipes Adult Chicken Meal & Rice Recipe, Nature’s Recipe: Original Recipes Adult Lamb Meal & Rice Recipe, Nature’s Recipe: Original Recipes Small Bites Chicken Meal & Rice Recipe, Nature’s Select Select Classic Nutrition Recipe, Nature’s Select Select High Protein Recipe, Nature’s Select Select Multi Protein Recipe, Nature’s Select Select New Zealand Recipe, Nature’s Select Select Plus Recipe, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Limited Ingredient Diet Grain-Free Recipe With Real Duck, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Limited Ingredient Diet Grain-Free Recipe With Real Lamb, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Limited Ingredient Diet Grain-Free Recipe With Real Salmon, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Limited Ingredient Diet Grain-Free Recipe With Real Turkey, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Limited Ingredient Diet Grain-Free Recipe With Real Turkey For Small Breed Dogs, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Ultimate Protein Cage-Free Chicken Recipe, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Ultimate Protein Cage-Free Chicken Recipe For Small Breed Dogs, Newman’s Own Organics: Dry Formula Adult Dog Dry Formula, Nutram Ideal Solution Support® Skin, Coat And Stomach Dog Food Lamb Meal & Brown Rice Recipe, Nutreco: Lifetime Chicken & Oatmeal – All Life Stages, Nutreco: Lifetime Fish & Oatmeal – All Life Stages, Nutreco: Lifetime Free Run Chicken Grain Free – All Life Stages, Nutreco: Lifetime Lamb & Oatmeal – All Life Stages, Nutreco: Lifetime Large Breed – All Life Stages, Nutreco: Lifetime Pasture-Fed Lamb Grain Free – All Life Stages, Nutreco: Lifetime Performance Chicken & Oatmeal – All Life Stages, Nutreco: Lifetime Wild Caught Fish Grain Free – All Life Stages, Nutreco: Naturally Fresh Chicken & Duck Recipe – All Life Stages, Nutreco: Naturally Fresh Chicken & Duck Recipe – Large Breed, Nutreco: Naturally Fresh Pork & Beef Recipe – Red Meat Formula, Nutreco: Naturally Fresh Turkey & Rabbit Recipe – Sensitive Stomach, Nutrisource Lamb Meal & Rice Formula, Nutrisource Large Breed Adult – Lamb Meal & Rice Formula, Nutro: Grain Free Lamb Meal & Peas Formula, Nutro: Grain Free Large Breed Lamb Meal & Peas Formula, Nutro: Limited Ingredient Diet Adult Dry Dog Food: Venison Meal & Sweet Potato Recipe, Nutro: Max Adult Recipe: Farm Raised Beef And Brown Rice, Nutro: Max Adult Recipe: Farm Raised Chicken, Nutro: Max Adult Recipe: Farm Raised Chicken Mini Chunk, Nutro: Max Adult Recipe: Farm Raised Chicken Mini Chunk, Nutro: Max Adult Recipe: Pasture Fed Lamb, Nutro: Max Adult Recipe: Pasture Fed Lamb, Nutro: Max Grain Free Adult Recipe: Farm Raised Chicken, Nutro: Max Grain Free Adult Recipe: Salmon Dry Dog , Nutro: Max Large Breed Adult Recipe: Farm Raised Chicken, Nutro: Max Senior Recipe: Farm Raised Chicken, Nutro: Wholesome Essentials Adult Dry Dog Food: Venison Meal, Brown Rice & Oatmeal Recipe, Nutro: Wholesome Essentials Healthy Weight Adult Dry Dog Food: Pasture-Fed Lamb & Rice Recipe, Nutro: Wholesome Essentials Healthy Weight Small Breed Adult Dry Dog Food: Farm-Raised Chicken, Brown Rice & Sweet Potato Recipe, Nutro: Wholesome Essentials Large Breed Senior Dry Dog Food: Farm-Raised Chicken, Brown Rice & Sweet Potato Recipe, Nutro: Wholesome Essentials Senior Dry Dog Food: Farm-Raised Chicken, Brown Rice & Sweet Potato Recipe, Open Farm Catch-Of-The-Season Whitefish & Green Lentil, Open Farm Farmer’s Table Pork & Root Vegetable, Open Farm Pasture Raised Lamb, Open Farm Wild-Caught Salmon, Oven-Baked Tradition Chicken-Flavoured Adult Dog Food For All Breeds, Oven-Baked Tradition Chicken-Flavoured Adult Dog Food For Large Breeds, Oven-Baked Tradition Chicken-Flavoured Adult Dog Food For Small Breeds, Oven-Baked Tradition Fish-Flavoured Adult Dog Food For All Breeds, Oven-Baked Tradition Fish-Flavoured Adult Dog Food For Small Breeds, Oven-Baked Tradition Grain-Free Duck-Flavoured Adult Dog Food For All Breeds / All Life Stages, Oven-Baked Tradition Grain-Free Duck-Flavoured Adult Dog Food For Small Breeds / All Life Stages, Oven-Baked Tradition Lamb-Flavoured Adult Dog Food For All Breeds, Oven-Baked Tradition Lamb-Flavoured Adult Dog Food For Large Breeds, Oven-Baked Tradition Lamb-Flavoured Adult Dog Food For Small Breeds, Paw Tree Real Salmon, Peas & Sweet Potato , Performatrin Adult Lamb Meal & Brown Rice , Performatrin Healthy Weight Lamb Meal & Brown Rice, Petcurean: Go! Duck Recipe, Petcurean: Go! Lamb Meal Recipe, Petcurean: Go! Salmon Dog Food Recipe, Petcurean: Now Fresh Grain Free Adult Dog Food Recipe, Petcurean: Now Fresh Grain Free Large Breed Senior Recipe, Petcurean: Now Fresh Grain Free Senior Dog Food Recipe, Petcurean: Summit Original Three Meat Adult Recipe, Petcurean: Summit Original Three Meat Large Breed Recipe, Petcurean: Summit Original Three Meat Reduced Calorie Recipe, Petway Petway Holistic Grain Free Tri Protein Select, Petway Petway Holistic Salmon & Brown Rice, Petway Petway Holistic Supreme Chicken & Rice, Petway Petway Maintenance Chicken & Brown Rice, Petway Petway Whole Life Lamb Meal & Brown Rice, Pinnacle Grain Free Trout And Sweet Potato, Pioneer Naturals Buffalo Dry Dog Food, Pioneer Naturals Chicken Dry Dog Food, Pioneer Naturals Grain-Free Chicken Dry Dog Food, Pioneer Naturals Grain-Free Pork Dry Dog Food, Pioneer Naturals Grain-Free Venison Dry Dog Food, Pioneer Naturals Grain-Free Whitefish Dry Dog Food, Precise: Holistic Complete, Grain Free Grain Free – Lamb & Turkey With Garbanzo Beans, Precise: Holistic Complete, Grain Free Grain Free – Salmon Meal & Garbanzo Bean, Precise: Naturals Chicken Meal & Rice Foundation, Precise: Naturals Endurance, Precise: Naturals Lamb Meal & Rice Sensicare, Precise: Naturals, Grain Free Grain Free – Chicken Formula, Precise: Naturals, Grain Free Grain Free – Lamb Meal, President’s Choice Nutrition First First Lamb & Brown Rice Premium Adult , President’s Choice Nutrition First First Salmon & Potato Premium Adult, Pro Pac: Superpremium Adult Chunk & Mini Chunk, Pro Pac: Ultimates Chicken Meal & Brown Rice Formula, Pro Pac: Ultimates Grain Free Bayside Select, Pro Pac: Ultimates Grain Free Heartland Choice, Pro Pac: Ultimates Grain Free Meadow Prime, Pro Pac: Ultimates Grain Free Overland Red, Pro Pac: Ultimates Lamb Meal & Brown Rice Formula, Pro Pac: Ultimates Large Breed Adult Chicken Meal & Brown Rice Formula, Pro Pac: Ultimates Mature Chicken Meal & Brown Rice Formula, Pro-Form Athlete Premium, Pro-Form Hunter’s Sport Premium, Pro-Form Lamb & Rice Premium, Pro-Form Performance Professional Premium, Rachael Ray Nutrish: Just 6 Lamb Meal & Brown Rice Recipe, Rawz Real Duck Recipe, Rawz Wild Caught Salmon Recipe, Redpaw Poweredge 26K, Redpaw Poweredge 32K, Regal Dog Food Active Bites Dog Food, Regal Dog Food Adult Bites Dog Food, Regal Dog Food Grain Free Chicken & Duck, Regal Dog Food Grain Free Lamb With Buffalo, Regal Dog Food Lamb Bites Dog Food, Regal Dog Food Large Breed Adult Bites Dog Food, Regal Dog Food Salmon Bites Dog Food, Regal Dog Food Sensi Bites Dog Food, Regal Dog Food Venison Dog Food, Satori Lamb Recipe, Signature Pet Products: Hi-Tek Naturals Chicken Meal & Rice: Fitness Formula, Signature Pet Products: Hi-Tek Naturals Grain Free Alaskan Fish Recipe, Signature Pet Products: Hi-Tek Naturals Grain Free Chicken Meal Recipe With Sweet Potato & Duck Meal, Signature Pet Products: Hi-Tek Naturals Grain Free Lamb Meal Recipe With Sweet Potato & Herring Meal, Signature Pet Products: Hi-Tek Naturals Lamb Meal & Rice Formula, Signature Pet Products: Perfectly Natural Dog Adult Formula, Signature Pet Products: Perfectly Natural Dog Senior Formula, Signature Pet Products: Premium Blend Adult Plus 22-10, Simply Nourish Adult Dog Food – Natural, Lamb & Oatmeal, Simply Nourish Limited Ingredient Diet Small Breed Dog Food – Natural, Duck & Potato, Simply Nourish Senior Dog Food – Natural, Chicken & Brown Rice, Simply Nourish Source Dual Protein Adult Dog Food – Natural, Grain Free, Halibut & Salmon Rec, Solid Gold Wild Heart™ With Quail, Sport Dog Food Canine Endurance Multi-Protein 31/22, Sport Dog Food Elite Grain Free Beef Meal 30/14, Sport Dog Food Elite Grain Free Chicken Meal 30/14, Sport Dog Food Elite Grain Free Large Breed 30/14, Sport Dog Food Elite Grain Free Venison Meal 28/14, Sport Dog Food Elite Grain Free Whitefish Meal 30/14, Sport Dog Food Limited Ingredient Grain And Potato Free Beef Meal, Sport Dog Food Maintenance Beef Meal 20/10, Sport Dog Food Performance Canine Chicken And Fish 26/18, Sport Dog Food Power Canine Athlete Chicken And Rice 30/20, Sportmix: Caninex Beef Meal & Vegetables Formula, Sportmix: Caninex Chicken Meal & Vegetables Formula, Sportmix: Wholesomes Chicken Meal & Rice Formula, Sportmix: Wholesomes Fish Meal & Rice Formula, Sportmix: Wholesomes Grain-Free Beef Meal & Chickpeas, Sportmix: Wholesomes Grain-Free Chicken Meal & Chickpeas, Sportmix: Wholesomes Grain-Free Whitefish Meal And Chickpeas, Sportmix: Wholesomes Large Breed Chicken Meal & Rice Formula, Sportmix: Wholesomes With Lamb Meal & Rice Formula, Sportsman’s Pride Limited Ingredient 26/18, Supreme Source Lamb Meal & Potato Recipe Dog Food, Supreme Source Salmon Meal & Sweet Potato Recipe Dog Food, Supreme Source Turkey Meal & Sweet Potato Recipe Dog Food, Taste Of The Wild Angus Beef Limited Ingredient Formula, Taste Of The Wild Southwest Canyon Canine Formula, Taste Of The Wild Trout Limited Ingredient Formula, Taste Of The Wild Turkey Limited Ingredient Formula, Triumph Beef, Barley & Carrot Recipe Dog Food, Triumph Lamb & Rice Recipe Dog Food, Tuscan Natural Simply Pure Lamb Meal Recipe, Variety Pet Foods: Natural Dog Kibble Grandma’s Dinner™, Variety Pet Foods: Natural Dog Kibble Mom’s Dinner™, Variety Pet Foods: Natural Dog Kibble Sunday Brunch™, Verus Adult Maintenance, Verus Advanced Opticoat, Verus Life Advantage, Victor Beef Meal & Brown Rice, Victor Hero Canine, Victor Hi Pro Plus, Victor High Energy, Victor Lamb Meal, Victor Lamb Meal & Brown Rice, Victor Ocean Fish, Victor Performance, Victor Professional, Victor Senior / Healthy Weight, Wellness: Core: Dry Complete Health: Whitefish & Sweet Potato, Wellness: Trufood: Baked Nuggets Chicken & Chicken Liver, Wellness: Trufood: Baked Nuggets Lamb & Lamb Liver, Wellness: Trufood: Baked Nuggets Salmon & Turkey Liver, Wellness: Trufood: Baked Nuggets Small Breed, Whole Earth Farms Grain Free Recipe Healthy Weight, Whole Earth Farms Grain Free Recipe Small Breed, Whole Earth Farms Grain Free Recipe With Chicken & Turkey, Whole Earth Farms Grain Free Recipe With Pork, Beef & Lamb (Poultry-Free), Whole Earth Farms Grain Free Recipe With Salmon & Whitefish, Whole Earth Farms Grain Free Recipe With Turkey & Duck, Whole Earth Farms Grain Free Small Breed Recipe With Chicken & Turkey, Whole Earth Farms Grain Free Small Breed Recipe With Pork, Beef & Lamb, Whole Earth Farms Grain Free Small Breed Recipe With Salmon & Whitefish, Wild Calling: Western Plains Stampede Beef Recipe, Wild Calling: Xotic Essentials Bison Meal Recipe, Wild Calling: Xotic Essentials Kangaroo Meal Recipe, Wild Calling: Xotic Essentials Rabbit Meal Recipe, Wishbone Ocean, Wysong: Original Diets Anergen, Wysong: Original Diets Fundamentals, Young Again 40/16 Premium High Protein

Cut: Potentially harmful artificial additives

Artificial preservatives, colors and flavors are extremely common in dog food formulas. There’s a lot of disagreement over what’s life-or-death bad and what’s probably fine but not ideal. An ingredient that is proven harmful in large doses, such as propylene glycol — a synthetic ingredient used to add moisture — can cause irritation and sometimes even organ toxicity in large amounts, but might still be approved by the FDA in very small doses.

Artificial food colorings have been known to cause hyperactivity, irritation and even cancer in humans, but are frequently used to make food look more enticing to dog owners. And artificial flavors show up with similar frequency, despite having no nutritional value and posing a risk for allergic reactions, diarrhea or excess intestinal bacteria growth over time.

“If the recipe is made with lots of meat and fruits/vegetables, why would there be a need for added flavor?”

Steve PelletierVice President of Food at Petnet

Healthy dogs won’t fall ill from occasionally eating foods with artificial additives. But if a dog eats those additives every day of his life, they could cumulatively result in negative health effects. “It’s like pointing a ship — if you’re a few degrees off you’ll end up miles away from your destination. Not a big deal for one or two feedings, but it’d be bad over the course of three or four years,” explains Pelletier.

Given how many better options there are, we felt it was best not to risk it. Instead of artificial preservatives, our top picks stay fresh with the help of rosemary, vitamin C and vitamin E.

What we cut: 524

Wet:
None of our remaining wet foods had artificial preservatives, colors or flavors.

Dry: 536
4Health: Original Chicken & Rice Formula Adult Dog Food, 4Health: Original Lamb & Rice Formula Adult Dog Food, 4Health: Original Large Breed Formula Adult Dog Food, 4Health: Original Mature Adult Formula For Adult Dogs 7+ Years Of Age Dog Food, 4Health: Original Performance Dog Food, 4Health: Original Salmon & Potato Formula Adult Dog Food, 4Health: Original Small Bites Formula Adult Dog Food, 4Health: Untamed Red Canyon Recipe Buffalo & Lentil Formula Dog Food, 4Health: Untamed Southern Bayou Recipe Wild Boar & Lentil Formula Dog Food, Abound Chicken & Brown Rice Dog Food, Abound Grain Free Duck, Sweet Potato, & Venison Recipe, Acana: Heritage Free-Run Poultry, Acana: Heritage Freshwater Fish, Acana: Heritage Heritage Meats, Acana: Regionals Appalachian Ranch, Acana: Regionals Grasslands, Acana: Regionals Meadowland, Acana: Regionals Wild Atlantic, Acana: Singles Duck & Pear, Acana: Singles Lamb & Apple, Acana: Singles Pork & Squash, Acana: Singles Wild Mackerel, American Journey: Large Breed Large Breed Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Dry Dog Food, American Journey: Large Breed Large Breed Salmon & Brown Rice Recipe Dry Dog Food, American Journey: Limited Ingredient Diet Grain-Free Duck & Sweet Potato Recipe Dry Dog Food, American Journey: Limited Ingredient Diet Grain-Free Lamb & Sweet Potato Recipe Dry Dog Food, American Journey: Limited Ingredient Diet Grain-Free Salmon & Sweet Potato Recipe Dry Dog Food, American Journey: Limited Ingredient Diet Grain-Free Turkey & Sweet Potato Recipe Dry Dog Food, American Journey: Original Beef & Brown Rice Recipe Dry Dog Food, American Journey: Original Beef & Sweet Potato Recipe Grain-Free Dry Dog Food, American Journey: Original Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Dry Dog Food, American Journey: Original Chicken & Sweet Potato Recipe Grain-Free Dry Dog Food, American Journey: Original Lamb & Brown Rice Recipe Dry Dog Food, American Journey: Original Lamb & Sweet Potato Recipe Grain-Free Dry Dog Food, American Journey: Original Salmon & Brown Rice Recipe Dry Dog Food, American Journey: Original Salmon & Sweet Potato Recipe Grain-Free Dry Dog Food, Annamaet Annamaet Sustain, Annamaet Manitok Formula, Artemis Fresh Mix Medium / Large Dog All Life Stages Dry Dog Food, Artemis Fresh Mix Small Breed Dog All Life Stages Dry Dog Food, Artemis Osopure Grain Free Bison, Salmon Meal & Garbanzo Bean Dry Dog Food, Artemis Osopure Grain Free Duck & Garbanzo Beans Dry Dog Food, Artemis Osopure Grain Free Salmon & Garbanzo Bean Dry Dog Food, Artemis Osopure Grain Free Turkey & Garbanzo Bean Dry Dog Food, Authority Adult Dog Food – Chicken & Rice, Authority Adult Dog Food – Lamb & Rice, Authority Grain Free Adult Dog Food – Chicken & Pea, Authority Grain Free High Performance Dog Food – Turkey, Pea, Duck & Salmon, Authority Grain Free Small Breed Mature Adult Dog Food – Chicken & Pea, Authority Healthy Weight + Joint Support Large Breed Adult Dog Food – Turkey & Chickpea, Authority Healthy Weight + Joint Support Small Breed Adult Dog Food – Turkey & Chickpea, Authority Immunity + Joint Support Mature Adult Dog Food – Chicken & Brown Rice, Authority Large Breed Adult Dog Food – Chicken, Authority Large Breed Adult Dog Food – Grain Free, Chicken & Pea, Authority Large Breed Adult Dog Food – Lamb & Rice, Authority Large Breed Weight Management Adult Dog Food, Authority Skin, Coat + Digestive Health Small Breed Adult Dog Food – Grain Free, Fish & Potato, Authority Small Bites All Life Stages Dog Food – Chicken & Rice, Authority Small Breed Adult Dog Food – Chicken & Rice, Authority Small Breed Adult Dog Food – Grain Free, Chicken & Pea, Authority Small Breed Adult Dog Food – Lamb & Rice, Authority Tender Blends Adult Dog Food – Chicken & Rice, Authority Weight Management Adult Dog Food, Authority: Gnc Pets Healthy Weight + Joint Support Adult Dog Food – Turkey & Chickpea, Authority: Gnc Pets Skin, Coat+ Digestive Health Support Adult Dog Food – Grain Free, Fish & Potato, Avoderm Revolving Menu Beef Recipe Small Breed, Avoderm Revolving Menu Duck Recipe, Avoderm Revolving Menu Lamb & Sweet Potato Recipe, Avoderm Revolving Menu Lamb Recipe Small Breed, Avoderm Revolving Menu Trout & Pea Recipe, Avoderm Revolving Menu Turkey Recipe, Berkeley And Jensen All Natural Grain Free Duck And Vegetables Holistic Recipe For Dogs, Berkeley And Jensen All Natural Larger Breed Chicken And Brown Rice Holistic Recipe For Dogs, Blackwood Expro Performance/Active Diet Chicken Meal With Brown Rice, Blue Buffalo: Blue Basics Grain-Free Lamb & Potato Recipe Small Breed Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Basics Grain-Free Turkey & Potato Recipe Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Freedom Grain-Free Chicken Recipe Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Natural Veterinary Diet Gi Gastrointestinal Support, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Bayou Blend With Alligator & Catfish, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Bison Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Bison Large Breed Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Chicken Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Chicken Large Breed Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Chicken Small Breed Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Chicken Toy Breed, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Denali Dinner With Wild Salmon, Venison & Halibut, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Duck Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Flatland Feast With Turkey, Quail & Duck, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Healthy Weight Chicken Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Healthy Weight Chicken Large Breed Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Healthy Weight Chicken Recipe Adult Small Breed, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Healthy Weight Red Meat Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Rabbit Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Red Meat Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Red Meat Large Breed Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Red Meat Small Breed Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Salmon Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Salmon Large Breed Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Small Bite Chicken Recipe Adult, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Snake River Grill With Trout, Venison & Rabbit, Boreal Original Lamb – Grain Free, Boreal Original Salmon – Grain Free, Boreal Original Small Breed – Duck, Boreal Original Turkey – Grain Free, Canidae: Grain Free Pure Elements With Fresh Lamb, Canidae: Grain Free Pure Fields With Fresh Chicken (Small Breed), Canidae: Grain Free Pure Land With Fresh Bison, Canidae: Grain Free Pure Resolve With Fresh Chicken, Canidae: Grain Free Pure Ridge With Fresh Chicken, Canidae: Grain Free Pure Sea With Fresh Salmon, Canidae: Grain Free Pure Sky With Fresh Duck, Canidae: Grain Free Pure Wild With Fresh Wild Boar, Castor & Pollux Natural Ultramix Grain-Free Red Meat Recipe With Raw Bites, Castor & Pollux Organix Grain Free Organic Chicken & Sweet Potato Recipe, Castor & Pollux Organix Grain Free Organic Small Breed Recipe, Castor & Pollux Organix Organic Chicken & Oatmeal Recipe, Castor & Pollux Organix Organic Healthy Weight Recipe, Castor & Pollux Pristine Grain Free Free-Range Chicken & Sweet Potato Recipe With Raw Bites, Castor & Pollux Pristine Grain Free Free-Range Chicken, Turkey & Lentil Recipe, Castor & Pollux Pristine Grain Free Grass-Fed Beef & Chickpea Recipe, Castor & Pollux Pristine Grain Free Grass-Fed Beef & Sweet Potato Recipe With Raw Bites, Castor & Pollux Pristine Grain Free Grass-Fed Lamb & Lentil Recipe, Castor & Pollux Pristine Grain Free Wild-Caught Salmon & Chickpea Recipe, Castor & Pollux Pristine Grain Free Wild-Caught Salmon & Sweet Potato Recipe With Raw Bites, Chicken Soup For The Soul Adult Dog Dry Food, Chicken Soup For The Soul Grain Free Dog Food – Beef & Legumes Recipe, Chicken Soup For The Soul Grain Free Dog Food – Chicken, Turkey, Pea & Sweet Potato Recipe, Chicken Soup For The Soul Grain Free Dog Food – Lamb, Pea, & Green Lentil Limited Ingredient Recipe, Chicken Soup For The Soul Grain Free Dog Food – Salmon, Sweet Potato & Pea Recipe, Chicken Soup For The Soul Large Breed Adult Dry Dog Food, Chicken Soup For The Soul Mature Dog Dry Food, Chicken Soup For The Soul: Grain Free Beef & Legumes Recipe, Chicken Soup For The Soul: Grain Free Chicken, Turkey, Pea & Sweet Potato Recipe, Chicken Soup For The Soul: Grain Free Lamb, Pea, & Green Lentil Limited Ingredient Recipe, Chicken Soup For The Soul: Grain Free Salmon, Sweet Potato & Pea Recipe, Chicken Soup For The Soul: Life Stages Adult Dog Dry Food, Chicken Soup For The Soul: Life Stages Adult Dog Small Bites Dog Food, Chicken Soup For The Soul: Life Stages Large Breed Adult Dry Dog Food, Chicken Soup For The Soul: Life Stages Mature Dog Dry Food, Crave With Protein From Chicken, Crave With Protein From Lamb & Venison, Crave With Protein From Salmon & Ocean Fish, Diamond Naturals All Life Stages Dog Chicken & Rice Formula, Diamond Naturals Grain Free Cage-Free Chicken & Sweet Potato Formula For Dogs, Diamond Naturals Grain Free Pasture-Raised Beef & Sweet Potato Formula For Dogs, Diamond Naturals Grain Free Wild-Caught Whitefish & Sweet Potato Formula For Dogs, Diamond Naturals Large Breed Adult Dog Chicken & Rice Formula, Diamond Naturals Small Breed Adult Dog Chicken & Rice Formula, Diamond Naturals Small Breed Adult Dog Lamb & Rice Formula, Dogswell: Grain Free Adult Chicken Recipe, Dogswell: Grain Free Adult Lamb Recipe, Dogswell: Grain Free Adult Salmon Recipe, Dogswell: Grain Free Small Breed Chicken Recipe, Dogswell: Nutrisca Chicken & Chickpea , Dogswell: Nutrisca Lamb & Chickpea, Dogswell: Nutrisca Salmon & Chickpea, Drs. Foster And Smith Signature Series® Adult Dog Food – Chicken & Brown Rice Formula, Drs. Foster And Smith Signature Series® Adult Dog Food – Lamb & Brown Rice Formula, Drs. Foster And Smith Signature Series® Adult Lite Dog Food, Drs. Foster And Smith Signature Series® Senior Dog Food, Evo Herring & Salmon Formula Adult Dog Food, Evo Red Meat Formula Large Bites Dog Food, Evo Turkey & Chicken Formula Large Bites Dog Food, Evolve Grain Free Salmon & Sweet Potato Recipe Dog Food, Evolve Grain Free Turkey, Garbanzo Bean & Pea Recipe Dog Food, Exclusive Adult Dog, Exclusive Healthy Weight Adult Dog, Exclusive Large Breed Adult Dog, Exclusive Performance 30/20, Exclusive Senior Dog, Good Natured Adult Dog Food – Natural, Chicken & Barley, Good Natured Grain Free Adult Dog Food – Natural, Beef & Brown Rice, Good Natured Grain Free Adult Dog Food – Natural, Turkey & Potato, Good Natured Large Breed Adult – Natural, Chicken & Barley, Good Natured Small Breed Adult Dog Food – Natural, Chicken & Barley, Halo Halo Holistic Chicken And Chicken Liver Recipe For Adult Dogs, Halo Halo Holistic Chicken And Chicken Liver Recipe For Small Breed Dogs, Halo Halo Holistic Game Bird Medley For Small Breed Dogs, Halo Halo Holistic Grain Free Surf And Turf Recipe For Adult Dogs, Halo Halo Holistic Grain Free Wild Salmon And Whitefish Recipe For Senior Dogs, Halo Halo Holistic Lamb And Lamb Liver Recipe For Adult Dogs, Halo Halo Holistic Wild Salmon And Whitefish Recipe For Adult Dogs, Halo Small Breed Healthy Weight Wild Salmon And Whitefish, Holistic Blend: Grain Free Marine 5 All Life Stages Dog Food Marine 5, Holistic Select Grain Free Adult & Puppy Health: Salmon And Anchovy & Sardine Meal Recipe, Holistic Select Grain Free Adult Health: Deboned Turkey & Lentils Recipe, I And Love And You: Naked Essentials Chicken + Duck, I And Love And You: Naked Essentials Lamb + Bison, I And Love And You: Naked Essentials Salmon + Trout, I And Love And You: Nude Food Poultry Palooza, I And Love And You: Nude Food Red Meat Medley, I And Love And You: Nude Food Simply Sea, Infinia Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe, Infinia Duck & Potato Recipe, Infinia Turkey & Sweet Potato Recipe, Infinia Venison Potato & Quail Recipe, Infinia Zenfood™, Kirkland Signature Adult Formula Chicken, Rice And Vegetable Dog Food, Kirkland Signature Adult Formula Lamb, Rice And Vegetable Dog Food, Kirkland Signature Mature Formula Chicken, Rice And Egg Dog Food, Merrick: Backcountry Backcountry – Raw Infused – Big Game Recipe, Merrick: Backcountry Backcountry – Raw Infused – Game Bird Recipe, Merrick: Backcountry Backcountry – Raw Infused – Great Plains Red Recipe, Merrick: Backcountry Backcountry – Raw Infused – Hero’s Banquet, Merrick: Backcountry Backcountry – Raw Infused – Large Breed Recipe, Merrick: Backcountry Backcountry – Raw Infused – Pacific Catch Recipe, Merrick: Classic Classic Real Beef + Green Peas Recipe With Ancient Grains, Merrick: Classic Classic Real Chicken + Green Peas Recipe With Ancient Grains, Merrick: Classic Classic Real Lamb + Green Peas Recipe With Ancient Grains, Merrick: Classic Classic Small Breed Recipe, Merrick: Grain Free Grain Free Healthy Weight Recipe, Merrick: Grain Free Grain Free Real Buffalo + Sweet Potato Recipe, Merrick: Grain Free Grain Free Real Chicken + Sweet Potato Recipe, Merrick: Grain Free Grain Free Real Duck + Sweet Potato Recipe, Merrick: Grain Free Grain Free Real Lamb + Sweet Potato Recipe, Merrick: Grain Free Grain Free Real Rabbit + Chickpeas Recipe, Merrick: Grain Free Grain Free Real Salmon + Sweet Potato Recipe, Merrick: Grain Free Grain Free Real Texas Beef + Sweet Potato Recipe, Merrick: Grain Free Grain Free Real Turkey + Sweet Potato Recipe, Merrick: Grain Free Grain Free Real Venison + Chickpeas Recipe, Merrick: Grain Free Grain Free Senior Real Chicken + Sweet Potato Recipe, Merrick: Grain Free Lil’ Plates Grain Free Real Chicken + Sweet Potatoes Recipe, Merrick: Grain Free Lil’ Plates Grain Free Real Lamb + Sweet Potato Recipe, Merrick: Grain Free Lil’ Plates Grain Free Real Salmon + Sweet Potatoes Recipe, Merrick: Grain Free Lil’ Plates Grain Free Real Texas Beef + Sweet Potato Recipe, Merrick: Limited Ingredient Diet Diet Grain Free – Real Lamb + Sweet Potato Recipe, Merrick: Limited Ingredient Diet Grain Free – Real Chicken Recipe, Merrick: Limited Ingredient Diet Grain Free – Real Salmon + Sweet Potato Recipe, Merrick: Limited Ingredient Diet Grain Free – Real Turkey + Sweet Potato Recipe, Merrick: Limited Ingredient Diet Grain Free- Real Duck + Sweet Potato Recipe, Natural Balance: L.I.D. Chicken & Sweet Potato Dry Dog Formula, Natural Balance: L.I.D. High Protein Turkey Formula Dry Dog Food, Natural Balance: Ultra Synergy Dry Dog Formula, Natural Balance: Wild Pursuit Beef & Lamb Meal Dry Dog Formula, Natural Balance: Wild Pursuit Chicken, Turkey Meal & Quail Dry Dog Formula, Natural Balance: Wild Pursuit Trout, Salmon Meal & Tuna Dry Dog Formula, Natural Planet Duck & Whitefish Entree, Natural Planet Kangaroo & Venison Entree, Natural Planet Rabbit & Salmon Entree, Nature’s Recipe: Grain-Free Grain Free Easy To Digest Chicken, Sweet Potato, & Pumpkin Recipe, Nature’s Recipe: Grain-Free Large Breed Grain Free Easy To Digest Chicken, Sweet Potato, & Pumpkin Recipe, Nature’s Recipe: Grain-Free Small Breed Grain Free Easy To Digest Chicken, Sweet Potato, & Pumpkin Recipe, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Original Grain-Free Recipe With Real Chicken, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Original Grain-Free Recipe With Real Chicken For Small Breed Dogs, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Original Grain-Free Recipe With Real Duck, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Original Grain-Free Recipe With Real Rabbit, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Original Grain-Free Recipe With Real Salmon, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Original Grain-Free Recipe With Real Turkey, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Raw Boost Grain-Free Recipe With Real Beef, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Raw Boost Grain-Free Recipe With Real Chicken, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Raw Boost Grain-Free Recipe With Real Chicken For Healthy Weight, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Raw Boost Grain-Free Recipe With Real Chicken For Small Breed Dogs, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Raw Boost Grain-Free Recipe With Real Chicken For Toy Breed Dogs, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Raw Boost Grain-Free Recipe With Real Duck, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Raw Boost Grain-Free Recipe With Real Duck For Small Breed Dogs, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Raw Boost Grain-Free Recipe With Real Lamb, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Raw Boost Grain-Free Recipe With Real Venison, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Ultimate Protein Cage-Free Duck Recipe, Nature’s Variety: Prairie: Kibble Beef & Barley Recipe, Nature’s Variety: Prairie: Kibble Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe, Nature’s Variety: Prairie: Kibble Lamb & Oatmeal Recipe, Nature’s Variety: Prairie: Kibble Salmon & Brown Rice Recipe, Newman’s Own Organics: Dry Formula Advanced Dog Dry Formula, Nulo: Freestyle Adult Dog: Lamb & Chickpeas Recipe, Nulo: Freestyle Adult Dog: Salmon & Peas Recipe, Nulo: Freestyle Adult Dog: Turkey & Sweet Potato Recipe, Nulo: Freestyle Adult Trim: Cod & Lentils Recipe, Nulo: Freestyle Senior: Trout & Sweet Potato Recipe, Nulo: Freestyle Small Breed: Salmon & Red Lentils Recipe, Nulo: Medal Series Adult Dog: Chicken & Peas Recipe, Nulo: Medal Series Adult Dog: Lamb & Lentils Recipe, Nulo: Medal Series Adult Dog: Salmon & Sweet Potato Recipe, Nulo: Medal Series Large Breed Dog: Turkey & Peas Recipe, Nulo: Medal Series Senior Dog: Chicken & Lentils Recipe, Nutram Total Grain-Free® Chicken & Turkey Dog Food Chicken And Turkey Recipe, Nutram Total Grain-Free® Chicken And Turkey Recipe Dog Food Chicken And Turkey Recipe, Nutram Total Grain-Free® Lamb And Lentils Recipe Dog Food Lamb And Lentils Recipe, Nutram Total Grain-Free® Lamb And Lentils Recipe Dog Food Lamb And Lentils Recipe, Nutram Total Grain-Free® Trout & Salmon Meal Dog Food Trout And Salmon Meal Recipe, Nutram Total Grain-Free® Trout And Salmon Meal Recipe Dog Food Trout And Salmon Meal Recipe, Nutreco: Naturally Fresh Toy & Small Breed – Chicken & Duck Recipe – All Life Stages, Nutreco: Wholesome Blend Grain Free – L.I.D. Salmon Dog Recipe, Nutreco: Wholesome Blend Grain Free – L.I.D. Salmon Large Breed Dog Recipe, Nutreco: Wholesome Blend Grain Free – Red Meat Adult Recipe, Nutrience Canadian Pacific Formula, Nutrience Fraser Valley Formula, Nutrience Large Breed Fraser Valley Formula, Nutrience Large Breed Prairie Red Formula, Nutrience Prairie Red Formula, Nutro: Limited Ingredient Diet Adult Dry Dog Food: Duck & Lentils Recipe, Nutro: Limited Ingredient Diet Adult Dry Dog Food: Lamb & Sweet Potato Recipe, Nutro: Limited Ingredient Diet Adult Dry Dog Food: Salmon & Lentils Recipe, Nutro: Limited Ingredient Diet Adult Large Breed Dry Dog Food: Lamb & Sweet Potato Recipe, Nutro: Limited Ingredient Diet Small Bites Adult Dry Dog Food: Lamb & Sweet Potato Recipe, Nutro: Ultra Adult Dry Dog Food: Protein Blend From Chicken, Lamb & Salmon, Nutro: Ultra Adult Weight Management Dry Dog Food: Protein Blend From Chicken, Lamb & Salmon, Nutro: Ultra Large Breed Adult Dry Dog Food: Protein Blend From Chicken, Lamb & Salmon, Nutro: Ultra Senior Dry Dog Food: Protein Blend From Chicken, Lamb & Salmon, Nutro: Ultra Small Breed Adult Dry Dog Food: Protein Blend From Chicken, Lamb & Salmon, Nutro: Ultra Small Breed Adult Weight Management Dry Dog Food: Protein Blend From Chicken, Lamb & Salmon, Nutro: Ultra Small Breed Senior Dry Dog Food: Protein Blend From Chicken, Lamb & Salmon, Nutro: Ultra Toy Breed Adult Dry Dog Food: Protein Blend From Chicken, Lamb & Salmon, Nutro: Wholesome Essentials Adult Dry Dog Food: Farm-Raised Chicken, Brown Rice & Sweet Potato Recipe, Nutro: Wholesome Essentials Adult Dry Dog Food: Pasture-Fed Lamb & Rice Recipe, Nutro: Wholesome Essentials Adult Dry Dog Food: Salmon, Brown Rice & Sweet Potato Recipe, Nutro: Wholesome Essentials Healthy Weight Large Breed Adult Dry Dog Food: Farm-Raised Chicken, Rice & Sweet Potato Recipe, Nutro: Wholesome Essentials Large Breed Adult Dog Food: Farm-Raised Chicken, Brown Rice & Sweet Potato Recipe, Nutro: Wholesome Essentials Large Breed Adult Dry Dog Food: Pasture-Fed Lamb & Rice Recipe, Nutro: Wholesome Essentials Senior Dry Dog Food: Pasture-Fed Lamb & Rice Recipe, Nutro: Wholesome Essentials Small Bites Adult Dry Dog Food: Farm-Raised Chicken, Brown Rice & Sweet Potato Recipe, Nutro: Wholesome Essentials Small Bites Adult Dry Dog Food: Pasture-Fed Lamb And Rice Recipe, Nutro: Wholesome Essentials Small Bites Adult Dry Dog Food: Salmon, Brown Rice & Sweet Potato Recipe, Nutro: Wholesome Essentials Small Breed Adult Dry Dog Food: Farm-Raised Chicken, Brown Rice & Sweet Potato Recipe, Nutro: Wholesome Essentials Small Breed Senior Dry Dog Food: Farm Raised Chicken, Brown Rice & Sweet Potato Recipe, Nutro: Wholesome Essentials Toy Breed Adult Dry Dog Food: Farm-Raised Chicken, Brown Rice & Sweet Potato Recipe, Nutro: Wild Frontier Adult Dry Dog Food: Cold Water Recipe Grain Free Salmon, Nutro: Wild Frontier Adult Dry Dog Food: Open Valley Recipe Grain Free Chicken, Nutro: Wild Frontier Adult Dry Dog Food: Rolling Meadows Recipe Grain Free Lamb, Only Natural Pet: Canine Powerfood Just Fish Feast, Only Natural Pet: Canine Powerfood Poultry Feast, Only Natural Pet: Canine Powerfood Red Meat Feast, Only Natural Pet: Canine Powerfood Wild Feast, Only Natural Pet: Reduced Fat Feast Canine Powerfood, Open Farm Homestead Turkey & Chicken, Orijen: Dry Dog Food Fit & Trim, Oven-Baked Tradition Chicken-Flavoured Senior Dog Food & Weight Management For All Breeds, Oven-Baked Tradition Chicken-Flavoured Senior Dog Food & Weight Management For Small Breeds, Oven-Baked Tradition Grain-Free Chicken-Flavoured Adult Dog Food For All Breeds / All Life Stages, Oven-Baked Tradition Grain-Free Chicken-Flavoured Adult Dog Food For Small Breeds / All Life Stages, Oven-Baked Tradition Grain-Free Fish-Flavoured Adult Dog Food For All Breeds / All Life Stages, Oven-Baked Tradition Grain-Free Fish-Flavoured Adult Dog Food For Small Breeds / All Life Stages, Paw Tree Real Chicken & Sweet Potato, Paw Tree Real Duck & Chickpeas, Paw Tree Real Turkey & Garbanzo Beans, Paw Tree Real Turkey & Sweet Potato, Performatrin Adult Chicken & Rice, Performatrin Adult Grain-Free Chicken & Potato, Performatrin Adult Large Breed, Performatrin Adult Small Breed, Performatrin Healthy Weight Chicken & Rice , Performatrin Healthy Weight Large Breed , Performatrin Healthy Weight Small Breed , Petkind: Triple Dry Green Beef Tripe Formula, Petkind: Triple Dry Green Lamb & Tripe Formula, Petkind: Triple Dry Green Tripe & Bison Formula, Petkind: Triple Dry Green Tripe & Wild Salmon Formula, Petkind: Triple Dry Lamb & Lamb Tripe Formula, Petkind: Triple Dry Venison Tripe Formula, Pinnacle Grain Free Duck And Sweet Potato, Pinnacle Grain Free Salmon And Potato, Pinnacle Grain Free Turkey And Potato, Precise: Holistic Complete Large & Giant Breed Adult, Precise: Holistic Complete Senior, Precise: Holistic Complete Small & Medium Breed Adult, Professional Plus Chicken & Lentils-Formula For Large Breed Adult Dogs, Professional Plus Chicken & Lentils-Formula For Senior Dogs, Professional Plus Chicken & Pea, Professional Plus Lamb & Lentils-Formula For Adult Dogs, Pronature Nordiko, Pure Balance Chicken And Brown Rice All Dry Dog Food, 15 Lbs, Pure Balance Grain Free Formula Salmon & Pea Dry Dog Food, 4 Lb, Pure Balance Lamb & Brown Rice Dry Dog Food , 5 Lb, Pure Balance Limited Ingredient Turkey & Potato Dry Dog Food, 11 Lb, Pure Balance Small Breed Chicken & Brown Rice Dry Dog Food, 7 Lb, Pure Balance Superfood Blend Trout & Lentil Recipe Dry Dog Food, 11 Lb, Pure Balance Trout & Lentil Recipe Dry Dog Food, 4 Lb, Pure Balance Turkey And Potato Recipe Dry Dog Food, 24 Lb, Pure Balance Wild & Free Bison & Pea Recipe Food For Dogs 11Lbs, Pure Balance Wild & Free Bison Pea & Venison Dog Food, 24 Lb, Purevita: Grain Free Duck & Green Lentils Grain Free Entree, Purina Beyond Grain Free Dry Dog Food With Chicken & Egg, Rachael Ray Nutrish: Dish Beef & Brown Rice Recipe, Rachael Ray Nutrish: Dish Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe, Rachael Ray Nutrish: Peak Northern Woodlands Recipe™ With Turkey, Duck & Quail, Rachael Ray Nutrish: Peak Open Range Recipe™ With Beef, Venison & Lamb, Rachael Ray Nutrish: Super Premium Real Beef & Brown Rice Recipe, Rachael Ray Nutrish: Super Premium Real Chicken & Veggies Recipe, Rachael Ray Nutrish: Super Premium Turkey, Brown Rice & Venison Recipe, Rachael Ray Nutrish: Zero Grain Beef, Potato & Bison Recipe, Rachael Ray Nutrish: Zero Grain Chicken & Sweet Potato Recipe, Rachael Ray Nutrish: Zero Grain Salmon & Sweet Potato Recipe, Rachael Ray Nutrish: Zero Grain Turkey & Potato Recipe, Satori Chicken Recipe, Satori Duck Recipe, Satori Oven Made Chicken Recipe, Satori Salmon Recipe, Simply Nourish Adult Dog Food – Grain Free, Natural, Chicken With Peas & Potatoes, Simply Nourish Adult Dog Food – Natural, Chicken & Brown Rice, Simply Nourish Grain Free Large Breed Adult Dog Food – Natural, Chicken With Peas & Potatoes, Simply Nourish Grain Free Small Breed Adult Dog Food – Natural, Chicken With Peas & Potatoes, Simply Nourish Healthy Weight Small Breed Adult Dog Food – Natural, Turkey & Brown Rice, Simply Nourish Limited Ingredient Diet Adult Dog Food – Natural, Lamb & Pea, Simply Nourish Limited Ingredient Diet Dog Food – Natural, Salmon & Sweet Potato Recipe, Simply Nourish Limited Ingredient Diet Dog Food – Natural, Turkey & Potato, Simply Nourish Limited Ingredient Diet Large Breed Dog Food – Natural, Salmon & Sweet Potato, Simply Nourish Limited Ingredient Diet Small Breed Dog Food – Natural, Salmon & Sweet Potato, Simply Nourish Small Breed Adult Dog Food – Natural, Chicken & Brown Rice, Simply Nourish Small Breed Senior Dog Food – Natural, Chicken & Brown Rice, Simply Nourish Source Adult Dog Food – Grain Free, High Protein, Simply Nourish Source Adult Dog Food – Grain Free, High Protein, Chicken & Rabbit, Simply Nourish Source Adult Dog Food – Grain Free, High Protein, Chicken & Turkey, Simply Nourish Source Adult Dog Food – Natural, Grain Fee, Salmon, Simply Nourish Source Adult Dog Food – Natural, Grain Free, Beef Recipe, Simply Nourish Source Adult Dog Food – Natural, Grain Free, Chicken Recipe, Simply Nourish Source Adult Dog Food – Natural, Grain Free, Duck Recipe, Simply Nourish Source Adult Dog Food – Natural, Grain Free, Turkey Recipe, Simply Nourish Source Dual Protein Adult Dog Food – Natural, Grain Free, Beef & Bison Recipe, Simply Nourish Source Large Breed Adult Dog Food – Grain Free, High Protein, Chicken & Turkey, Simply Nourish Source Large Breed Adult Dog Food – Natural, Grain Free, Chicken Recipe, Simply Nourish Source Senior Dog Food – Grain Free, High Protein, Chicken & Turkey, Simply Nourish Source Senior Dog Food – Natural, Grain Free, Chicken Recipe, Simply Nourish Source Small Breed Adult Dog Food – Grain Free, High Protein, Chicken & Turkey, Simply Nourish Source Small Breed Adult Dog Food – Natural, Grain Free, Chicken Free, Simply Nourish: Healthy Weight Adult Dog Food – Natural, Turkey & Brown Rice, Simply Nourish: Healthy Weight Large Breed Adult Dog Food – Natural, Turkey & Brown Rice, Solid Gold Barking At The Moon® With Beef, Solid Gold Buck Wild™ With Venison, Solid Gold Fit And Fabulous™ Weight Control, Solid Gold Fit And Fabulous™ Weight Control With Chicken, Solid Gold High Protein Red Meat Recipe With Buffalo, Solid Gold High Protein With Cold Water Salmon + Krill Meal, Solid Gold High Protein With Duck, Solid Gold Hund-N-Flocken® With Lamb, Solid Gold Hundchen Flocken® With Lamb, Solid Gold Leaping Waters™ With Salmon, Solid Gold Lil’ Boss™ With Turkey, Solid Gold Love At First Bark™ With Chicken, Solid Gold Mighty Mini™ With Chicken, Solid Gold Mighty Mini™ With Lamb, Solid Gold Mmillennia® With Beef, Solid Gold Star Chaser™ With Chicken, Solid Gold Sun Dancer® With Chicken, Solid Gold Sunday Sunrise™ With Lamb, Solid Gold Wee Bit™ With Bison, Solid Gold Wolf Cub® With Bison, Solid Gold Wolf King® With Bison, Solid Gold Young At Heart™ With Chicken, Stella & Chewy’s: Freeze-Dried Raw Coated Kibble Cage-Free Chicken Recipe, Stella & Chewy’s: Freeze-Dried Raw Coated Kibble Grass-Fed Beef Recipe, Stella & Chewy’s: Freeze-Dried Raw Coated Kibble Wild-Caught Whitefish Recipe, Stella & Chewy’s: Raw Blend Cage-Free Recipe, Stella & Chewy’s: Raw Blend Red Meat Recipe, Taste Of The Wild Appalachian Valley Small Breed Canine Formula, Taste Of The Wild High Prairie Canine Formula, Taste Of The Wild Pacific Stream Canine Formula, Taste Of The Wild Pine Forest Canine Formula, Taste Of The Wild Sierra Mountain Canine Formula, Taste Of The Wild Wetlands Canine Formula, Tiki Dog Grain Free Chicken Luau, Tiki Dog Grain Free Duck Luau, Tiki Dog Grain Free Fish Luau, Tiki Dog Grain Free Lamb Luau, Triumph Chicken & Rice Recipe Dog Food, Triumph Grain Free Salmon & Sweet Potato Recipe Dog Food, Triumph Grain Free Turkey, Pea & Sweet Potato Recipe Dog Food, Tuscan Natural Carne Grain Free Recipe, Tuscan Natural Harvest Turkey & Chicken Recipe, Verus Cold Water Fish, Verus Life Virtue, Victor Chicken, Victor Chicken Meal & Brown Rice, Wegmans Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Natural Dog Food, Wegmans Lamb & Brown Rice Recipe Natural Dog Food, Wegmans Salmon & Pea Recipe Natural Dog Food, Wegmans Turkey & Pea Recipe Natural Dog Food, Wellness: Complete Health Grain Free Small Breed, Wellness: Core: Dry Complete Health Small Breed: Healthy Weight, Wellness: Core: Dry Complete Health Small Breed: Senior, Wellness: Core: Dry Complete Health Small Breed: Turkey & Oatmeal, Wellness: Core: Dry Complete Health Small Breed: Whitefish, Salmon Meal & Peas, Wellness: Core: Dry Complete Health Toy Breed, Wellness: Simple: Dry Simple Limited Ingredient: Duck & Oatmeal Recipe, Wellness: Simple: Dry Simple Limited Ingredient: Lamb & Oatmeal Recipe, Wellness: Simple: Grain-Free Dry Simple Limited Ingredient: Healthy Weight, Wellness: Simple: Grain-Free Dry Simple Limited Ingredient: Salmon & Potato Recipe, Wellness: Simple: Grain-Free Dry Simple Limited Ingredient: Small Breed, Wellness: Simple: Grain-Free Dry Simple Limited Ingredient: Turkey & Potato Recipe, Weruva: Caloric Harmony Chicken Dinner With Pumpkin, Weruva: Caloric Harmony Chicken, Turkey And Salmon Dinner With Pumpkin, Weruva: Caloric Harmony Venison And Salmon Meal Dinner With Pumpkin, Weruva: Caloric Melody Chicken Dinner With Lentils, Weruva: Caloric Melody Chicken, Turkey And Salmon Dinner With Lentils, Wholehearted All Life Stages Beef & Pea Formula Dry…, Wholehearted All Life Stages Beef And Brown Rice Recipe Dry Dog…, Wholehearted All Life Stages Chicken And Rice Recipe Dry Dog Food, Wholehearted Grain Free All Life Stages Chicken & Pea Recipe…, Wholehearted Grain Free All Life Stages Duck And Lentil Recipe Dry…, Wholehearted Grain Free All Life Stages Lamb And Lentil…, Wholehearted Grain Free All Life Stages Salmon And Pea…, Wholehearted Grain Free Senior Chicken Recipe Dry Dog Food, Wholehearted Grain Free Small Breed Adult Beef And Pea Recipe…, Wholehearted Grain Free Small Breed Adult Chicken And Pea Recipe, Wild Calling: Rocky Mountain Medley Duck, Salmon Meal & Lamb Meal Recipe, Wild Calling: Rocky Mountain Medley Elk, Whitefish Meal & Turkey Meal Recipe, Wild Calling: Rocky Mountain Medley Trout, Lamb Meal & Turkey Meal Recipe, Wild Calling: Western Plains Stampede Turkey Recipe, Wild Calling: Western Plains Stampede Whitefish Recipe, Wishbone Lake, Wysong: Epigen Starch Free Epigen, Wysong: Epigen Starch Free Epigen 90, Wysong: Optimal Line Adult, Wysong: Optimal Line Performance, Wysong: Optimal Line Senior, Wysong: Original Diets Adult, Wysong: Original Diets Growth, Wysong: Original Diets Nurture With Quail, Wysong: Original Diets Senior, Wysong: Original Diets Synorgon, Zignature Catfish, Zignature Duck, Zignature Kangaroo, Zignature Lamb, Zignature Pork, Zignature Salmon, Zignature Trout & Salmon Meal, Zignature Turkey, Zignature Venison, Zignature Whitefish, Zignature Zssential, Zoic Farm Fare, Zoic Magic Marsh, Zoic Seven Seas

Cut: “Natural flavor”

When we first encountered the phrase “natural flavor,” we pictured just that — juices and drippings that result from tasty things being cooked. We learned that’s not necessarily the case. The FDA explains “natural flavor” can indicate the inclusion of “digests,” “which are materials treated with heat, enzymes and/or acids to form concentrated natural flavors.”

When we asked Pelletier about this, he clarified that while concentrated flavors themselves aren’t necessarily a bad thing, the lack of transparency that goes into processing them should provoke concern: “Natural flavoring isn’t a great ingredient. According to current labeling rules, dog food companies are allowed to consider these natural flavors proprietary, and are not required to disclose exactly what is used to make the flavoring nor what chemical processes are involved.”

Again, this ingredient is unlikely to kill your dog, but if you’re going to be feeding your best friend the same few brands his whole life, we think it’s best that he’s not continually ingesting any ingredient shrouded in mystery.

What we cut: 339

Dry: 29
Exclusive All Life Stages, Nutrisource Adult Chicken, Nutrisource Large Breed Adult – Chicken & Rice Formula, Nutrisource Performance Chicken & Rice Formula , Nutrisource Senior Chicken, Nutrisource Weight Management Chicken & Rice, NutriSource: Grain Free Chicken And Pea Formula, NutriSource: Grain Free Heartland Select, NutriSource: Grain Free High Plains Select, NutriSource: Grain Free Large Breed Chicken & Pea Formula, NutriSource: Grain Free Prairie Select, NutriSource: Grain Free Seafood Select, NutriSource: Grain Free Small Breed Chicken Formula, NutriSource: Grain Free Small Breed Seafood Select, NutriSource: Grain Free Woodlands SelectOrijen: Dry Dog Food Original, Orijen: Dry Dog Food Regional Red, Orijen: Dry Dog Food Senior, Orijen: Dry Dog Food Six Fish, Petcurean: Go! Limited Ingredient Duck Recipe For Dogs, Petcurean: Go! Limited Ingredient Lamb Recipe For Dogs, Petcurean: Go! Limited Ingredient Pollock Recipe For Dogs, Petcurean: Go! Limited Ingredient Salmon Recipe For Dogs, Petcurean: Go! Limited Ingredient Turkey Recipe For Dogs, Petcurean: Now Fresh Grain Free Fish Recipe For Adult Dogs, Petcurean: Now Fresh Grain Free Large Breed Adult Recipe, Petcurean: Now Fresh Grain Free Red Meat Recipe For Adult Dogs, Petcurean: Now Fresh Grain Free Small Breed Adult Recipe, Petcurean: Now Fresh Grain Free Small Breed Senior Recipe

Wet: 310
Redbarn Trukey Stew With Cranberries And Sweet Potato, Redbarn Lamb Stew With Peas And Egg Whites, Bil-Jac: Pâté Pâté Platters™ With Chicken & Cheese, Bil-Jac: Pâté Pâté Platters™ With Duck & Pumpkin, Bil-Jac: Pâté Pâté Platters™ With Chicken & Vegetables, Bravo! Canine Cafe™ 95% Beef, Turkey & Liver Dinner, Bravo! Canine Cafe™ 95% Chicken & Liver Dinner, Bravo! Canine Cafe™ 95% Rabbit, Pork & Liver Dinner, Bravo! Canine Cafe™ Beef Fricassee, Bravo! New Canine Cafe™ Chicken Fricassee, Bravo! Canine Cafe™ Turkey Fricassee, Dave’s Pet Food: Stewlicious Gobbledy Good Stew, Dave’s Pet Food: Stewlicious Turducken Stew, Dave’s Pet Food: Stewlicious Fisherman Stew, Dave’s Pet Food: Stewlicious Chicken Pot Pie Stew, Dave’s Pet Food: Stewlicious Hearty Beef Stew, I and Love and You: Wet Food Moo Moo Venison Stew, I and Love and You: Wet Food Lambarama Stew, I and Love and You: Wet Food Gobble It Up Stew, Natural Balance: Delectable Delights Surf ‘n Turf® (Wet Cups), Natural Balance: Dog Food Rolls Beef, Natural Balance: Dog Food Rolls Chicken, Natural Balance: Dog Food Rolls Duck And Turkey, Natural Balance: Dog Food Rolls Lamb And Chicken, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Can Stews Beef Recipe With Carrots & Peas, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Can Stews Chicken Recipe With Carrots & Peas, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Can Stews Lamb Recipe With Carrots & Green Beans, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Can Stews Turkey & Cod Recipe With Spinach & Carrots, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Can Stews Turkey & Duck Recipe With Cranberries & Green Beans, Redbarn Beef Stew With Broccoli, Carrots And Potatoes, Redbarn Chicken Stew With Peas And Egg Whites, Redbarn Trout Stew, Redbarn Quail Stew, Redbarn Duck Stew, Redbarn Steak And Egg Stew With Potatoes, Redbarn Rolled Food Beef, Redbarn Rolled Food Chicken, Redbarn Rolled Food Lamb, Redbarn Rolled Food Grain Free Beef, Redbarn Rolled Food Grain Free Chicken, Variety Pet Foods: Grain Free Recipes Dad’s Chicken And Sweet Potato Entree, Variety Pet Foods: Grain Free Recipes Mom’s Turkey And Pea Crockpot, Variety Pet Foods: Grain Free Recipes Grandma’s Beef And Potato Dinner, Variety Pet Foods: Grain Free Recipes Grandad’s Lamb And Potato Feast, Variety Pet Foods: Healthy Coat Recipes Dad’s Savory Catch, Variety Pet Foods: Healthy Coat Recipes Grandma’s Buffet Dinner, Variety Pet Foods: Original Recipes Beef And Barley Feast, Variety Pet Foods: Original Recipes Savannah Crockpot, Variety Pet Foods: Original Recipes Salmon And Chicken Entree, Variety Pet Foods: Original Recipes Mom’s Turkey Dinner, Variety Pet Foods: Original Recipes Grandma’s Casserole, Variety Pet Foods: Original Recipes Sunday Brunch, Wellness: Complete Health 95% Beef, Wellness: Complete Health 95% Chicken, Wellness: Complete Health 95% Turkey, Wellness: Complete Health 95% Salmon, Wellness: Complete Health Stews Beef Stew With Carrots And Potatoes, Wellness: Complete Health Stews Chicken Stew With Peas And Carrots, Wellness: Complete Health Stews Turkey Stew With Barley And Carrots, Wellness: Complete Health Wet Lamb And Sweet Potato, Wellness: Complete Health: Petit Entrees Tender Chicken, Green Beans & Carrots, Wellness: Complete Health: Petit Entrees Roasted Turkey, Duck, Carrots & Peas, Wellness: Complete Health: Petit Entrees Braised Beef, Salmon, Green Beans & Red Peppers, Wellness: Complete Health: Petit Entrees Roasted Lamb, Peas & White Sweet Potatoes, Wellness: Complete Health: Petit Entrees Roasted Chicken, Duck, Peas & Carrots, Wellness: Complete Health: Petit Entrees Tender Chicken, Turkey, Carrots & Green Beans, Wellness: Complete Health: Petit Entrees Roasted Chicken, Beef, Green Beans & Red Peppers, Wellness: Complete Health: Petit Entrees Braised Lamb, Venison, White Sweet Potatoes & Carrots, Wellness: Core: Chunky Centers Beef, Lamb And Sweet Potato, Wellness: Core: Chunky Centers Chicken Chicken Liver And Spinach, Wellness: Core: Hearty Cuts Beef And Venison, Wellness: Core: Hearty Cuts Turkey And Duck, Wellness: Core: Hearty Cuts Whitefish And Salmon, Wellness: Core: Hearty Cuts Chicken And Turkey, Wysong: Canned Adult, Wysong: Canned Senior, Wysong: Canned Epigen Beef, Wysong: Canned Epigen Chicken, Wysong: Canned Epigen Duck, Wysong: Canned Epigen Rabbit, Wysong: Canned Epigen Salmon, Wysong: Canned Epigen Turkey, Maximum Bully: Canned Savory Chicken In Gravy, Blue Buffalo: Blue Freedom Hearty Turkey Dinner, Blue Buffalo: Blue Freedom Hearty Lamb Dinner, Blue Buffalo: Blue Freedom Hearty Chicken Dinner, Blue Buffalo: Blue Freedom Hearty Beef Dinner, Blue Buffalo: Blue’s Stew Hearty Beef Stew, Blue Buffalo: Blue’s Stew Country Chicken Stew, Blue Buffalo: Blue’s Stew Hunter’s Stew, Blue Buffalo: Blue’s Stew Irish Lamb Stew, Blue Buffalo: Blue’s Stew Tasty Turkey Stew, Blue Buffalo: Blue’s Stew Halloween Feast (Limited Edition), Blue Braised Beef Dinner, Blue Homestyle Chicken Stew, Blue Country Chicken Dinner, Blue Savory Lamb Stew, Blue Roast Turkey Dinner, Blue Hearty Beef Stew, Blue Grain Free Texas Bbq In Gravy, Blue Family Favorite Recipes Backyard Bbq In Gravy, Blue Family Favorite Recipes Shepherd’s Pie In Gravy, Blue Family Favorite Recipes Mom’s Chicken Pie In Gravy, Blue Family Favorite Recipes Sunday Chicken Dinner In Gravy, Blue Family Favorite Recipes Turkey Day Forest In Gravy, Blue Family Favorite Recipes Turducken, Blue Homestyle Recipes Lamb Dinner With Garden Vegetables, Blue Homestyle Recipes Lamb Dinner With Garden Vegetables Small Breed, Blue Divine Delights Angus Beef Flavor, Blue Divine Delights Filet Mignon Flavor, Blue Divine Delights Filet Mignon Flavor Small Breed, Blue Divine Delights New York Strip, Blue Divine Delights Porterhouse Flavor, Blue Divine Delights Prime Rib Flavor, Blue Divine Delights Top Sirloin Flavor, Blue Divine Delights Steak And Egg Flavor, Blue Divine Delights Grilled Chicken Flavor, Blue Divine Delights Rotisserie Chicken Flavor, Blue Divine Delights Sausage Egg And Cheese Flavor, Blue Divine Delights Bacon Egg And Cheese Flavor, Blue Divine Delights Roasted Turkey Flavor, Blue Buffalo: Blue Natural Veterinary Diet Ks Kidney Support, Blue Buffalo: Blue Natural Veterinary Diet Gi Gastrointestinal Support, Blue Buffalo: Blue Natural Veterinary Diet Wu Weight Management + Urinary Care, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Savory Salmon Stew In Gravy, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Hearty Duck Stew In Gravy, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Chunky Chicken Stew In Gravy, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Hearty Beef Stew In Gravy, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness – Trail Trays Duck Grill, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness – Trail Trays Turkey Grill, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness – Trail Trays Chicken Grill, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness – Trail Trays Beef Grill, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness – Trail Tubs Beef Stew, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness – Trail Tubs Red Meat Stew, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness – Trail Tubs Chicken Stew, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness – Trail Tubs Duck Stew, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness – Trail Tubs Turkey Stew, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness – Wild Cuts Trail Toppers Chunky Beef Bites, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness – Wild Cuts Trail Toppers Chunky Chicken Bites, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness – Wild Cuts Trail Toppers Chunky Duck Bites, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness – Wild Cuts Trail Toppers Chunky Salmon Bites, Castor & Pollux Natural Ultramix Whole Chicken Thigh, Fresh Cut Carrots & Sweet Potatoes Entrée, Castor & Pollux Natural Ultramix Duck & Venison, Green Beans With Minnesota Wild Rice Entrée, Castor & Pollux Natural Ultramix Beef & Vegetable Dinner, Castor & Pollux Natural Ultramix Beef Tripe & Chicken, Apples & Green Peas Entrée, Castor & Pollux Natural Ultramix Minced Chicken & Bacon With Fresh Tomatoes Entrée, Chicken Soup for the Soul: Grain Free Chicken And Duck Stew, Chicken Soup for the Soul: Grain Free Turkey And Salmon Stew, Chicken Soup for the Soul: Grain Free Beef And Legume Recipe, Dave’s Pet Food: Naturally Healthy Chicken And Rice Recipe, Dogswell: Grain Free Chicken Recipe Savory Stew, Dogswell: Grain Free Duck Recipe Savory Stew, Dogswell: Grain Free Lamb Recipe Savory Stew, Dogswell: Grain Free Turkey Recipe Savory Stew, Dogswell: Nutrisca Chicken And Chickpea Stew, Dogswell: Nutrisca Salmon And Chickpea Stew, Dogswell: Nutrisca Turkey And Chickpea Stew, Dogswell: Nutrisca Duck And Chickpea Stew, EVO Chicken And Turkey Recipe In Gravy, EVO Beef Recipe In Gravy, Freshpet Deli Fresh Chicken With Spinach And Potato Recipe, Freshpet Nature’s Fresh Chicken With Carrots, Peas And Brown Rice, Freshpet Nature’s Fresh Turkey With Spinach, Cranberries And Blueberries, Freshpet Nature’s Fresh Salmon And Ocean Whitefish With Spinach, Cranberries And Blueberries, Freshpet Nature’s Fresh Beef With Garden Vegetables And Grains, Freshpet Nature’s Fresh Chicken Stew With Vegetables And Brown Rice, Freshpet Select Tender Chicken With Vegetables & Brown Rice, Freshpet Select Chunky Beef With Vegetables & Brown Rice, Freshpet Select Chunky Chicken & Turkey With Vegetables & Brown Rice Dog Food Recipe, Freshpet Select Tender Chicken With Vegetables & Brown Rice For Puppies, Freshpet Select Grain Free Tender Chicken With Spinach & Potato, Freshpet Select Tender Chicken With Crisp Carrots & Leafy Spinach, Freshpet Select Chicken & Oats With Garden Vegetables, Freshpet Select Grain Free Salmon With Spinach & Cranberries, Freshpet Select Fresh From The Kitchen™ Home Cooked Chicken Recipe, Freshpet Select Grain Free Tender Chicken With Garden Vegetables, Freshpet Select Chicken & Oats Recipe, Freshpet Vital Chicken Dog Food Recipe With Peas, Carrots & Brown Rice, Freshpet Vital Turkey Dog Food Recipe With Peas, Carrots & Brown Rice, Halo – Small Breed Grain Free Chicken And Salmon Recipe, Halo – Small Breed Grain Free Turkey And Duck Recipe, Merrick: Classic Brauts-N-Tots™ Classic Recipe, Merrick: Classic Cowboy Cookout™ Classic Recipe, Merrick: Classic Grammy’s Pot Pie™ Classic Recipe, Merrick: Classic Smothered Comfort™ Classic Recipe, Merrick: Classic Thanksgiving Day Dinner™ Classic Recipe, Merrick: Classic Turducken™ Classic Recipe, Merrick: Classic Venison Holiday Stew™ Classic Recipe, Merrick: Classic Wilderness Blend™ Classic Recipe, Merrick: Classic Wingaling™ Classic Recipe, Merrick: Classic Christmas Day Dinner Seasonal Recipe In Gravy, Merrick: Classic Forever Home Holiday Recipe™, Merrick: Classic Hero’s Banquet Classic Recipe In Gravy, Merrick: Classic Holly Jolly Pot Roast Seasonal Recipe, Merrick: Classic Hot Off The Grill™ Seasonal Recipe, Merrick: Classic Howl O’ Ween Stew™, Merrick: Classic New Year’s Eve Paw-Ty™, Merrick: Grain Free Hero’s Banquet Classic Recipe In Gravy, Merrick: Grain Free Hot Off The Grill™ Seasonal Recipe, Merrick: Grain Free Grain Free 96% Real Beef + Lamb + Buffalo, Merrick: Grain Free Grain Free 96% Real Chicken, Merrick: Grain Free Grain Free 96% Real Duck, Merrick: Grain Free Grain Free 96% Real Texas Beef, Merrick: Grain Free Grain Free Brauts-N-Tots™ Classic Recipe, Merrick: Grain Free Grain Free Cowboy Cookout™ Classic Recipe, Merrick: Grain Free Grain Free Grammy’s Pot Pie™ Classic Recipe, Merrick: Grain Free Grain Free Smothered Comfort™ Classic Recipe, Merrick: Grain Free Chunky Carver’s Delight Dinner Grain Free Recipe, Merrick: Lil’ Plates Grain Free Teensy Turducken, Merrick: Lil’ Plates Grain Free Tiny Thanksgiving Day Dinner, Merrick: Lil’ Plates Rascally Rabbit Stew, Merrick: Lil’ Plates Teeny Texas Steak Tips Dinner In Gravy, Merrick: Limited Ingredient Diet Grain Free – Real Turkey Recipe, Merrick: Limited Ingredient Diet Grain Free – Real Chicken Stew, Merrick: Limited Ingredient Diet Grain Free – Real Duck Recipe, Merrick: Limited Ingredient Diet Grain Free – Real Lamb Recipe, Merrick: Limited Ingredient Diet Grain Free – Real Salmon Recipe, Natural Balance: L.I.D. White Fish & Sweet Potato Formula In Broth, Natural Balance: L.I.D. Chicken & Sweet Potato Formula In Broth, Nature’s Recipe: Grain-Free Chicken And Venison Recipe In Broth, Nature’s Recipe: Grain-Free Chicken And Duck Recipe In Broth, Nature’s Recipe: Grain-Free Chicken Recipe In Broth, Nature’s Recipe: Original Recipes Chicken Recipe In Broth, Nature’s Recipe: Original Recipes Chicken And Wild Salmon Recipe In Broth, Nature’s Recipe: Original Recipes Chicken And Turkey Recipe In Broth, Nulo: Freestyle Lamb And Lentils Recipe, Nulo: Freestyle Salmon And Chickpea Recipe, Nulo: Freestyle Chicken, Carrots And Peas Recipe, Nulo: Freestyle Beef, Peas And Carrots Recipe, Nulo: Freestyle Turkey And Sweet Potato Recipe, Nulo: Medal Series Lamb And Lentils Recipe, Nulo: Medal Series Salmon And Chickpea Recipe, Nulo: Medal Series Chicken, Carrots And Peas Recipe, Nulo: Medal Series Beef, Peas And Carrots Recipe, Nulo: Medal Series Turkey And Sweet Potato Recipe, Nutro: Ultra Small Breed Adult Paté Chicken, Lamb And Salmon Entrée, Nutro: Ultra Protein Boost Chicken, Nutro: Ultra Senior Paté Blend, Nutro: Ultra Protein Boost Turkey, Nutro: Ultra Antioxidant Boost Chicken, Nutro: Ultra Shiny Coat Boost Salmon, Purina Beyond Grain Free Dry Dog Food With Chicken & Egg, Purina: Pro Plan Veterinary Diets En Gastroenteric Naturals™ Canine Formula With Added Vitamins And Minerals, Solid Gold Leaping Waters™ Chicken, Salmon & Vegetables Recipe In Gravy, Taste of the Wild High Prairie Canine Formula, Taste of the Wild Pacific Stream Canine Formula, Taste of the Wild Sierra Mountain Canine Formula, Taste of the Wild Southwest Canyon Canine Formula, Taste of the Wild Wetlands Canine Formula, Triumph Triumph Beef Formula For Dogs, Triumph Triumph Chicken Formula For Dogs, Triumph Triumph Chicken, Rice And Vegetable Formula For Dogs, Triumph Triumph Lamb, Rice And Vegetable Formula For Dogs, Triumph Triumph Turkey Formula For Dogs, Triumph Triumph Grain Free Turkey & Sweet Potato Stew, Victor Cuts In Gravy With Chicken And Vegetables, Victor Cuts In Gravy With Beef And Vegetables, Whole Earth Farms Adult Recipe, Whole Earth Farms Grain Free Hearty Duck Stew, Whole Earth Farms Grain Free Hearty Salmon Stew, Whole Earth Farms Grain Free Recipe Chicken & Turkey Recipe, Whole Earth Farms Grain Free Recipe Hearty Beef Stew, Whole Earth Farms Grain Free Recipe Hearty Chicken Stew, Whole Earth Farms Grain Free Recipe Hearty Lamb Stew, Whole Earth Farms Grain Free Recipe Hearty Turkey Stew, Whole Earth Farms Grain Free Recipe Red Meat, Whole Earth Farms Grain Free Small Breed Beef Recipe, Whole Earth Farms Grain Free Small Breed Chicken Recipe, Whole Earth Farms Grain Free Small Breed Duck Recipe, Whole Earth Farms Grain Free Small Breed Lamb Recipe, Whole Earth Farms Grain Free Small Breed Turkey Recipe, Wysong Organic Chicken, Wysong Beef, Wysong: Epigen Chicken, Wysong: Epigen Duck, Wysong: Epigen Rabbit, Wysong: Epigen Salmon, Wysong: Epigen Turkey, Chicken Soup for the Soul Grain Free Wet Dog Food – Chicken & Duck Stew, Chicken Soup for the Soul Grain Free Wet Dog Food – Turkey & Salmon Stew, Chicken Soup for the Soul Grain Free Wet Dog Food – Beef & Legume Recipe, Chicken Soup for the Soul Canned Turkey & Shrimp, Life’s Abundance Canned Pork & Venison, Oven-Baked Tradition Duck Pâté Canned Dog Food, Performatrin Performatrin Ultra® Chicken Pate Dog Food, Performatrin Performatrin Ultra® Grain-Free Ocean Stew Dog Food, Performatrin Performatrin Ultra® Lamb Pate Dog Food, Performatrin Performatrin Ultra® Turkey, Salmon & Duck Pate Dog Food, Performatrin Performatrin Ultra® Venison Stew Dog Food, Pure Balance Pure Balance Beef Dinner Gravy Carrots & Sun Dried Tomatoes Canned Wet Dog Food, 3.5 Oz, Pure Balance Pure Balance Canned Chicken Peas & Sweet Potatoes Dog Food, 3.5 Oz, Simply Nourish Simply Nourish™ Essentials Adult Dog Food – Natural, Turkey, Sweet Potato & Cranberry, Simply Nourish Simply Nourish™ Essentials Adult Dog Food – Natural, Beef & Vegetable, Simply Nourish Simply Nourish™ Essentials Adult Dog Food – Natural, Chicken, Brown Rice & Vegetables, Simply Nourish Simply Nourish™ Essentials Adult Dog Food – Natural, Lamb & Carrot, Simply Nourish Simply Nourish™ Essentials Adult Dog Food – Natural, Duck & Wild Rice, Simply Nourish Simply Nourish™ Essentials Adult Dog Food – Natural, Chicken, Vegetables & Quinoa, Simply Nourish Simply Nourish™ Source Adult Dog Food – Grain Free, High Protein, Chicken, Simply Nourish Simply Nourish™ Source Adult Dog Food – Grain Free, High Protein, Beef, Simply Nourish Simply Nourish™ Source Adult Dog Food – Grain Free, High Protein, Turkey, Simply Nourish Simply Nourish™ Source Adult Dog Food – Grain Free, High Protein, Venison, Simply Nourish Simply Nourish™ Adult Dog Food – Grain Free, Lamb & Vegetable, Wegmans Beef Cuts & Vegetables In Gravy Natural Dog Food, Wegmans Chicken Cuts & Vegetables In Gravy Natural Dog Food, Wegmans Beef Dinner In Gravy Natural Dog Food, Wegmans Wholehearted Grain Free Adult Lamb And Carrot Recipe Wet Dog…, VeRUS Verus Nz Lamb And Tripe, VeRUS Verus Nz Chicken And Salmon, VeRUS Verus Beef And Kiwi, VeRUS Verus Nz Lamb & Veggies

Cut: Wet food formulas with “gravy” or extra water

The FDA rules that the maximum moisture percentage for wet dog foods is 78 percent. But many companies exceed this limit, in part because there's a loophole. The FDA allows moisture to cap out at 87.5 percent if the formula’s name includes the words “stew,” “in sauce” or “in gravy,” even though there's no consensus about what stew, sauce and gravy are.

The FDA notes that “review of cookbooks and other references shows no common definition or formula for generic terms such as gravy, sauce or broth.” In other words, there’s no guarantee you’re not just paying for extra water. Adding to the confusion, we discovered that even some formulas without the “stew,” “sauce” or “gravy” disclaimer exceeded the FDA’s 78 percent maximum moisture rule.

Water obviously isn’t going to harm your dog. But Dr. Joseph Bartges explained that the higher the moisture percentage, “the more nutrient dense the dry matter must be; otherwise the diet will not be complete and balanced.” It’s possible to calculate the exact nutrient profile of a food’s dry matter. But the general principle is this: the less water, the more protein and fat, and the higher the overall nutrient levels. We cut all formulas exceeding 78 percent moisture, including dog foods with sauce, gravy or stew.

What we cut: 144

4Health 4Health Chicken & Rice Formula For Adult Dogs, Addiction: Canned King Salmon & Potatoes Entree, Addiction: Canned New Zealand Brushtail & Vegetables, Addiction: Canned New Zealand Venison & Apples Entree, Against the Grain: Nothing Else 100% Beef Nothing Else! Loaf In Gravy Food For Dogs, Against the Grain: Nothing Else 100% Chicken Nothing Else! Loaf In Gravy Food For Dogs, Against the Grain: Nothing Else 100% Duck Nothing Else! Loaf In Gravy Food For Dogs, Against the Grain: Nothing Else 100% Pork Nothing Else! Loaf In Gravy Food For Dogs, Against the Grain: Nothing Else 100% Salmon Nothing Else! Loaf In Gravy Food For Dogs, Against the Grain: Pulled Meat Dog Food Pulled Beef With Gravy, Against the Grain: Pulled Meat Dog Food Pulled Chicken With Gravy, Almo Nature: HQS Legend Beef, Almo Nature: HQS Legend Beef With Potatoes And Peas, Almo Nature: HQS Legend Chicken Drumstick, Almo Nature: HQS Legend Chicken Fillet, Almo Nature: HQS Legend Skip Jack Tuna, Applaws – Dog Cans in a Tasty Broth Chicken Breast, Applaws – Dog Cans in a Tasty Broth Chicken Breast With Beef Liver And Vegetables, Applaws – Dog Cans in a Tasty Broth Chicken Breast With Pork And Vegetables, Applaws – Dog Cans in a Tasty Broth Chicken Breast With Salmon And Vegetables, Applaws – Dog Cans in a Tasty Broth Chicken Breast With Tuna And Vegetables, Applaws – Dog Cans in a Tasty Broth Chicken Breast With Vegetables In Broth, Applaws – Dog Layers Chicken With Carrots And Peas In Aspic, Applaws – Dog Layers Chicken With Lamb In Aspic, Applaws – Dog Layers Chicken With Pumpkin In Aspic, Applaws – Dog Layers Tuna With Shrimp In Aspic, Artemis OSOPURE Beef, Artemis OSOPURE Chicken, Artemis OSOPURE Duck, Artemis OSOPURE Lamb, Artemis OSOPURE Turkey And Salmon, Blue Grain Free Colorado Roast In Gravy, Blue Grain Free Nuntucket Feast In Gravy, Blue Grain Free Santa Fe Grill In Gravy, Boreal Chicken And Beef 690Gm, Boreal Lamb And Beef 690Gm, Boreal Wild Pacific Salmon 690Gm, Canine Caviar Venison Tripe, Caru Real Beef Stew, Caru Real Chicken Stew, Caru Real Chicken With Duck Stew, Caru Real Pork Stew, Caru Real Turkey Stew, Caru Real Turkey With Lamb Stew, Castor & Pollux Natural Ultramix All-Beef Sausage Links & Sweet Potato Entrée, Castor & Pollux Organix Butcher and Bushel Grain Free Organic Carved Turkey Dinner With Carrots & Sweet Potatoes In Gravy, Castor & Pollux Organix Butcher and Bushel Grain Free Organic Chicken Wing & Thigh Dinner With Sweet Potatoes In Gravy, Castor & Pollux Organix Butcher and Bushel Grain Free Organic Chopped Turkey & Chicken Dinner With Chicken Liver & Peas In Gravy, Castor & Pollux Organix Butcher and Bushel Grain Free Organic Shredded Chicken Dinner With Potatoes In Gravy, Castor & Pollux Organix Butcher and Bushel Grain Free Organic Tender Chicken Dinner With Potatoes & Apples In Gravy, Castor & Pollux Organix Tiny Feasts Grain Free Organic Chicken & Potato Stew, Castor & Pollux Organix Tiny Feasts Grain Free Organic Turkey & Potato Stew, Castor & Pollux Organix Tiny Feasts Organic Chicken, Quinoa & Carrot Stew, Castor & Pollux Organix Tiny Feasts Organic Turkey, Quinoa & Carrot Stew, Castor & Pollux Pristine Chicken, Pea & Carrot Stew, Castor & Pollux Pristine Free-Range Turkey, Carrot & Apple Stew, Castor & Pollux Pristine Grass-Fed Lamb, Carrot & Apple Stew, Drs. Foster and Smith Grandma’s Grain Free Non-Gmo Chicken Soft Stew, Evanger’s Grain Free Hand Packed Braised Beef Chunks, Evanger’s Grain Free Hand Packed Chunky Chicken Casserole, Evanger’s Grain Free Hand Packed Hunk Of Beef Au Jus, Evanger’s Grain Free Hand Packed Roasted Whole Chicken Drummets, Evanger’s Grain Free Hand Packed Whole Chicken Thighs, Evanger’s Grain Free Hand Packed Whole Uncut Sardines, Evanger’s Signature Series Slow Cooked Beed Stew, Evanger’s Signature Series Slow Cooked Chicken Stew, Evanger’s Signature Series Slow Cooked Lamb Stew, Evanger’s Signature Series Slow Cooked Turkey Stew, FirstMate Wild Salmon, Grandma Mae’s Country Naturals Grandma’s Grain Free Non-Gmo Beef Soft Stew, Grandma Mae’s Country Naturals Grandma’s Grain Free Non-Gmo Salmon Soft Stew, K9 Natural Chicken Feast Can, Koha – Stew Recipes Chicken Stew, Koha – Stew Recipes Duck Stew, Koha – Stew Recipes Guineafowl Stew, Koha – Stew Recipes Kangaroo Stew, Koha – Stew Recipes Pork Stew, Koha – Stew Recipes Turkey Stew, Koha – Stew Recipes Venison Stew, Life’s Abundance Chicken Stew Canned Dog Food, Lotus: Canned Just Juicy Beef Shank Stew, Lotus: Canned Just Juicy Pork Shoulder Stew, Lotus: Canned Stew Beef & Asparagus Stew, Lotus: Canned Stew Chicken & Asparagus Stew, Maximum Bully: Canned Chicken And Beef Cubes In Broth, Maximum Bully: Canned Chicken And Mackerel Chunks In Broth, Maximum Bully: Canned Chunky Duck And Tuna In Broth, Maximum Bully: Canned Mackerel Chunks And Tuna In Broth, Maximum Bully: Canned Tuna And Shredded Chicken In Broth, Merrick: Classic Friday Night Lights Feast Seasonal Recipe In Gravy, Merrick: Classic Gracie’s Favorite Stew Classic Recipe, Merrick: Classic Presidential Platter Seasonal Recipe In Gravy, Merrick: Grain Free Night Lights Feast Seasonal Recipe In Gravy, Merrick: Grain Free Winner Winner Chicken Dinner Seasonal Recipe, Newman’s Own Organics: Canned Beef And Vegetables Premium Stews, Newman’s Own Organics: Canned Beef Liver And Vegetables Premium Stews, Newman’s Own Organics: Canned Lamb, Liver And Vegetables Premium Stews, Nutro: Petite Eats Savory Lamb And Garden Variety In Gravy, Oven-Baked Tradition Chicken Stew Canned Dog Food, Oven-Baked Tradition Turkey Stew Canned Dog Food, Oven-Baked Tradition Turkey Stew Canned Dog Food, Petcurean: Go! Chicken Stew Recipe, Petcurean: Go! Grain Free Chicken, Turkey + Duck Stew Recipe, Petcurean: Go! Grain Free Chicken, Turkey + Trout Stew Recipe, Petcurean: Go! Turkey Stew Recipe, Petcurean: Now Fresh Grain Free Pork Stew With Bone Broth, Petcurean: Now Fresh Grain Free Turkey Stew With Bone Broth, PetGuard Chicken Stew In Gravy, PetGuard Chicken Stew In Gravy, PetGuard Gumbo With Gravy, PetGuard Gumbo With Gravy, PetGuard Turkey & Sweet Potato Stew In Gravy, PetGuard Turkey & Sweet Potato Stew In Gravy, PetKind: That’s It Canned Beef Tripe, PetKind: That’s It Canned Bison Tripe, PetKind: That’s It Canned Duck, PetKind: That’s It Canned Lamb Tripe, PetKind: That’s It Canned Venison Tripe, PetKind: That’s It Canned Wild Salmon, President’s Choice Nutrition First Pc Nutrition First Duck, Chicken, Pumpkin, Carrot & Sweet Potato Dog Food, President’s Choice Nutrition First Pc Nutrition First Sole, Cod, Sweet Potato, Spinach & Blueberry Dog Food, President’s Choice Nutrition First Pc Nutrition First Turkey, Sweet Potato & Cranberry Stew Premium Dog Food, President’s Choice Nutrition First Pc Nutrition First Veal, Sweet Potato, Broccoli & Avocado Stew Dog Food, Satori Beef & Chicken Recipe, Satori Duck & Lamb Recipe, Victor Turkey And Sweet Potato Stew Dog Food, Wegmans Beef & Chicken Natural Dog Food, Wegmans Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe Natural Dog Food, Wegmans Chicken Dinner Natural Dog Food, Wegmans Chicken Natural Dog Food, Wegmans Dog Food, Chicken, Turkey & Brown Rice Recipe, Wegmans Grain Free Turkey & Chicken Natural Dog Food, Wegmans Lamb Dinner Natural Dog Food, Weruva: Dog Cuisine Amazon Liver, Weruva: Dog Cuisine Bed And Breakfast, Weruva: Dog Cuisine Cirque De La Mer, Weruva: Dog Cuisine Funky Chunky, Weruva: Dog Cuisine Grandma’s Chicken Soup, Weruva: Dog Cuisine Green Eggs And Chicken, Weruva: Dog Cuisine Jammin’ Salmon, Weruva: Dog Cuisine Marbella Paella, Weruva: Dog Cuisine Paw Lickin’ Chicken, Weruva: Dog Cuisine Peking Ducken, Weruva: Dog Cuisine Wok The Dog

Cut: Product lines with inconsistent quality

Large dog food companies cater to lots of customers, which means different formulas from the same brand can vary in price and quality: We cut AvoDerm’s “Grain Free” line because it had too many plant-based fillers, but the AvoDerm “Revolving Menu” recipes passed with flying colors thanks to including high-quality proteins.

We certainly don’t begrudge companies for offering lower-tier dog foods. For some pet owners, it’s the only affordable option. That said, we want to ensure the formulas within a single line offered consistent quality. Take PureVita’s Grain-Free Dry Food: It comes in five flavors — duck, salmon, turkey, beef and venison — all sold in virtually identical bags. We cut three because they contained garlic. We cut one because it had artificial flavoring. One was totally fine. But we could see ourselves grabbing a new flavor at the grocery store without realizing there was a difference.

So we cut any product lines that weren’t uniformly great. If you’re partial to Nutro’s “Limited Ingredient” line, you can purchase any flavor and rest assured your pet’s food quality won’t change.

What we cut: 217

Dry: 29
Authority – Loaf Fish And Potato (Adult), Authority – Loaf Chicken And Brown Rice (Mature), Dr. Tim’s: Extreme Athlete Fusion, Evanger’s Chicken With Brown Rice Dry Dog Food, Evanger’s Grain Free Whitefish & Sweet Potato Dry Food, Evanger’s Pheasant & Brown Rice Dry Dog Food, Fromm: Four-Star Chicken À La Veg, Fromm: Four-Star Chicken Au Frommage, Fromm: Four-Star Duck & Sweet Potato, Fromm: Four-Star Game Bird, Fromm: Four-Star Hasen Duckenpfeffer, Fromm: Four-Star Lamb & Lentil, Fromm: Four-Star Pork & Applesauce, Fromm: Four-Star Salmon À La Veg, Fromm: Four-Star Salmon Tunalini, Fromm: Four-Star Surf & Turf, Fromm: Four-Star Whitefish & Potato, Grandma Mae’s Country Naturals Adult Dog Formula–For Sensitive Stomachs, Grandma Mae’s Country Naturals Grain Free Non-Gmo Chicken Recipe, Grandma Mae’s Country Naturals Grain Free Non-Gmo Lamb Recipe, Grandma Mae’s Country Naturals Grain Free Non-Gmo Large Breed Formula, Grandma Mae’s Country Naturals Grain Free Non-Gmo Low Fat Recipe, Grandma Mae’s Country Naturals Grain Free Non-Gmo Small Breed Formula, Grandma Mae’s Country Naturals Grain Free Non-Gmo Turkey Recipe, Grandma Mae’s Country Naturals Grain Free Non-Gmo Whitefish Recipe, Nature’s Select Select Cold Water Recipe, Petcurean: Gather Free Acres, Petcurean: Gather Wild Ocean, Petcurean: Go! Limited Ingredient Venison Recipe For Dogs, Purevita: Grain Free Venison & Red Lentils Grain Free Entree, Victor Yukon River Canine

Wet: 188
4Health 4Health Chicken & Rice Formula Dog Food, 4Health 4Health Lamb & Rice Formula Dog Food, 4Health 4Health Salmon & Potato Dinner Dog Food, 4Health 4Health Senior Chicken & Rice Formula Dog Food, Addiction: Canned Black Forest Rabbit & Blueberries Entree, Addiction: Canned Herbed Duck Confit & Sweet Potato Entree, Addiction: Canned Safari Buffalo Meatloaf, Addiction: Canned Turkey With Cranberries & Apples Entree, Authority – Grain Free Chicken And Carrots, Authority – Grain Free Chicken And Vegetables (Mature), AvoDerm Chicken And Rice, AvoDerm Original, Blue Buffalo: Blue Basics – Small Breed Lamb And Potato, Blue Buffalo: Blue Basics – Small Breed Salmon And Potato, Blue Buffalo: Blue Basics – Small Breed Turkey And Potato, Blue Buffalo: Blue Basics Duck And Potato, Blue Buffalo: Blue Basics Lamb And Potato, Blue Buffalo: Blue Basics Salmon And Potato, Blue Buffalo: Blue Basics Turkey And Potato, Blue Buffalo: Blue Basics Turkey And Potato, Blue Buffalo: Blue Freedom Beef, Blue Buffalo: Blue Freedom Chicken, Blue Buffalo: Blue Freedom Lamb, Blue Buffalo: Blue Freedom Small Breed, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Bayou Blend, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Beef And Chicken Grill, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Denali Dinner, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Duck And Chicken Grill, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Flatland Feast, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Healthy Weight Turkey And Chicken Grill, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Red Meat Dinner, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Salmon And Chicken Grill, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Snake River Grill, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Trout And Chicken Grill, Blue Buffalo: Blue Wilderness Turkey And Chicken Grill, Blue Homestyle Recipes Beef Dinner With Garden Vegetables, Blue Homestyle Recipes Chicken Dinner With Garden Vegetables, Blue Homestyle Recipes Chicken Dinner With Garden Vegetables Healthy Weight, Blue Homestyle Recipes Chicken Dinner With Garden Vegetables Large Breed, Blue Homestyle Recipes Chicken Dinner With Garden Vegetables Small Breed, Blue Homestyle Recipes Chicken Dinner With Garden Vegetables Toy Breed, Blue Homestyle Recipes Fish And Sweet Potato Dinner With Garden Vegetables, Blue Homestyle Recipes Turkey Meatloaf Dinner With Garden Vegetables, Boreal Angus Beef And Nz Lamb, Boreal Atlantic Salmon, Boreal Cobb Chicken And Angus Beef, Boreal Cobb Chicken And Heritage Turkey, Boreal Cobb Chicken Formula, Boreal Heritage Turkey, Canidae: Under The Sun Duck, Canidae: Under The Sun Lamb, Canidae: Under The Sun Salmon, Canine Caviar Brushtail, Canine Caviar Duck, Canine Caviar Goat, Canine Caviar Lamb, Canine Caviar Turkey, Canine Caviar Unagi, Canine Caviar Wild Salmon, Castor & Pollux Organix Tiny Feasts Grain Free Organic Chicken Recipe, Castor & Pollux Organix Tiny Feasts Grain Free Organic Turkey Recipe, Chicken Soup for the Soul: Grain Free Grain Free Lamb And Lentil Limited Ingredient Recipe, Dave’s Pet Food: 95% Premium 95% Premium Meats™ Canned Dog Food Beef & Chicken Recipe, Dave’s Pet Food: 95% Premium 95% Premium Meats™ Canned Dog Food Beef Recipe, Dave’s Pet Food: 95% Premium 95% Premium Meats™ Canned Dog Food Chicken Recipe, Dave’s Pet Food: 95% Premium 95% Premium Meats™ Canned Dog Food Turkey Recipe, Dave’s Pet Food: 95% Premium Beef And Chicken Recipe, Dave’s Pet Food: 95% Premium Beef Recipe, Dave’s Pet Food: 95% Premium Chicken Recipe, Dave’s Pet Food: 95% Premium Turkey Recipe, Dave’s Pet Food: Grain Free for Dogs Chicken, Salmon And Sweet Potato Entree, Dave’s Pet Food: Grain Free for Dogs Chicken, Sweet Potato And Quinoa Recipe, Dave’s Pet Food: Grain Free for Dogs Duck And Sweet Potato Recipe, Dave’s Pet Food: Grain Free for Dogs Pork And Sweet Potato Entree, Dave’s Pet Food: Grain Free for Dogs Salmon Entree Supplement, Dave’s Pet Food: Grain Free for Dogs Turkey And Bacon Recipe, Dave’s Pet Food: Naturally Healthy Beef And Rice Recipe, Dave’s Pet Food: Restricted Diet Chicken And Rice, Dave’s Pet Food: Restricted Diet Chicken And Rice Delicate Dinner, Dave’s Pet Food: Restricted Diet Lamb And Rice, Dave’s Pet Food: Restricted Diet Lamb And Rice, Evanger’s Super Premium Beef Dinner, Evanger’s Super Premium Chicken Dinner, Evanger’s Super Premium Duck And Sweet Potato Dinner, Evanger’s Super Premium Lamb And Rice, FirstMate Chicken, FirstMate Chicken And Wild Tuna, FirstMate Turkey, FirstMate Turkey And Wild Tuna, FirstMate Wild Salmon And Wild Tuna, FirstMate Wild Tuna, Fromm Beef & Barley Pâté, Fromm Chicken & Duck Pâté, Fromm Chicken & Sweet Potato Pâté, Fromm Chicken Pâté, Fromm Lamb & Sweet Potato Pâté, Fromm Salmon & Chicken Pâté, Fromm Turkey Pâté, Fromm Turkey, Duck, & Sweet Potato Pâté, Fromm Whitefish & Lentil Pâté, Good Natured Chicken, Salmon And Vegetable Casserole, Halo – Grain Free for Senior Dogs Beef Recipe, Halo – Small Breed Grain Free Chicken And Chickpea Recipe, Halo – Small Breed Grain Free Healthy Weight Salmon And Venison Recipe, Holistic Health Extension Duck Entree, Holistic Health Extension Lamb Entree, Holistic Health Extension Salmon, Holistic Health Extension Turkey Entree, K9 Natural Beef Feast Can, K9 Natural Lamb Feast Can, K9 Natural Venison Feast Can, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Limited Ingredient Diet Can Duck, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Limited Ingredient Diet Can Lamb, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Limited Ingredient Diet Can Rabbit, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Limited Ingredient Diet Can Turkey, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Original Can Beef, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Original Can Chicken, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Original Can Duck, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Original Can for Small Breed Beef, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Original Can Lamb, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Original Can Rabbit, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Original Can Salmon, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Original Can Venison, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Ultimate Protein Can Beef, Nature’s Variety: Instinct: Ultimate Protein Can Chicken, Newman’s Own Organics: Canned Beef, Newman’s Own Organics: Canned Beef And Liver, Newman’s Own Organics: Canned Chicken, Newman’s Own Organics: Canned Chicken And Brown Rice, Newman’s Own Organics: Canned Chicken And Liver Dinner, Newman’s Own Organics: Canned Chicken Dinner, Newman’s Own Organics: Canned Liver, Newman’s Own Organics: Canned Turkey And Brown Rice, Newman’s Own Organics: Canned Turkey And Chicken, Newman’s Own Organics: Canned Turkey And Liver Dinner, Newman’s Own Organics: Canned Turkey Dinner, Nutro: Kitchen Classics Steamed Fish And Sweet Potato Dinner, Pet-Tao Harmony Limited, Pet-Tao Solution Chill, Pet-Tao Solution Zing, Petcurean: Go! Grain Free Duck Pâté Recipe, Petcurean: Go! Grain Free Freshwater Trout + Salmon Pâté Recipe, Petcurean: Go! Salmon Pâté Recipe, PetGuard Chicken & Herbed Brown Rice Dinner, PetGuard Chicken & Herbed Brown Rice Dinner, PetGuard Chicken, Liver & Vegetables Dinner For Senior Or Less Active Adult Dogs, PetGuard Chicken, Liver & Vegetables Dinner For Senior Or Less Active Adult Dogs, PetGuard Liver, Vegetable & Wheat Germ Dinner, PetGuard Liver, Vegetable & Wheat Germ Dinner, PetGuard Organic Chicken & Vegetable Formula, PetGuard Organic Chicken & Vegetable Formula, PetGuard Turkey & Barley Dinner, PetGuard Turkey & Barley Dinner, Precise: Naturals Chicken And Rice Foundation, President’s Choice Nutrition First Pc Nutrition First Chicken, Rice, Red Peppers And Bananas Premium Dog Food, President’s Choice Nutrition First Pc Nutrition First Lamb, Rice, Barley & Peas Premium Dog Food, President’s Choice Nutrition First Pc Nutrition First Wet Dog Food- Salmon, White Fish & Sweet Potatoes, Pure Balance Pure Balance 95 Percent Beef And Chicken Wet Dog Food, 12.5 Oz, Pure Balance Pure Balance Canned Chicken Dinner Wet Dog Food, 3.5 Oz, Pure Balance Pure Balance Canned Salmon Potato Wet Dog Food, 12.5 Oz, Pure Balance Pure Balance Canned Salmon Sweet Potato Wet Dog Food, 3.5 Oz, Pure Balance Pure Balance Canned Turkey & Potato Wet Dog Food, 12.5 Oz, Pure Balance Pure Balance Grain Free Canned Lamb Dinner Wet Dog Food, 3.5 Oz, Pure Balance Pure Balance Grain Free Turkey & Sweet Potato Wet Dog Food, 3.5 Oz, Purina Beyond Grain Free Beef, Potato & Green Bean Recipe Ground Entrée Wet Dog Food, Purina Beyond Grain Free Chicken, Carrot & Pea Recipe Ground Entrée Wet Dog Food, Purina Beyond Grain Free Salmon & Sweet Potato Recipe Ground Entrée Wet Dog Food, Simply Nourish Simply Nourish™ Limited Ingredient Diet Dog Food – Natural, Grain Free, Duck & Potato, Simply Nourish Simply Nourish™ Limited Ingredient Diet Dog Food – Natural, Grain Free, Fish & Sweet Potato, Simply Nourish Simply Nourish™ Limited Ingredient Diet Dog Food – Natural, Grain Free, Venison & Sweet Potato, Solid Gold Barking At The Moon® Beef Recipe, Solid Gold Green Cow® Beef Tripe Grain & Gluten Free Green Beef Tripe In Beef Broth, Solid Gold Howling At The Stars™ Turkey, Ocean Whitefish & Sweet Potato Recipe, Solid Gold Hund-N-Flocken® Lamb, Brown Rice & Barley Recipe, Solid Gold Leaping Waters™ Chicken & Salmon Recipe With Vegetables, Solid Gold Star Chaser™chicken & Brown Rice Recipe With Vegetables, Solid Gold Sun Dancer® Chicken Recipe, Solid Gold Sunday Sunrise™ Lamb, Sweet Potato & Pea Recipe, VeRUS Fish And Potato Formula, VeRUS Garden Select Formula, VeRUS Lamb And Rice Formula, VeRUS Turkey And Veggie Formula, Victor Chicken And Rice Formula Dog Food, Victor Lamb And Rice Formula Dog Food, Wellness: Complete Health Wet Chicken And Sweet Potato, Wellness: Complete Health Wet Duck And Sweet Potato, Wellness: Complete Health Wet Turkey And Sweet Potato, Wellness: Complete Health Wet Venison And Sweet Potato

Accessibility

We made sure our remaining picks were easy to locate. Some, like Born Free, we could find only in brick-and-mortar pet shops in the Midwest. Others, like Dynamite, could be purchased directly through the manufacturer’s site but nowhere else. We’ve listed these harder-to-find brands as runners-up, and they’re great options if you’re inclined to track them down. But our favorites were all-around winners not only for their top-notch formulas, but because you can easily find them at national retailers like Chewy, Petco and Amazon.

Guide to Finding the Best Dog Food

How to find the right dog food for your dog

Explore flavors

Just like humans, dogs have preferences. One of our office dogs, for example, devours salmon with gusto, but acts offended if he’s served bison. Since no single protein source is superior, it’s fine to cater to your dog’s preferences — or to explore a variety of flavors if you’re a new pup owner.

Consider allergies

Signs that your dog may have a food allergy include itchy skin, diarrhea and gassiness. If you don’t think your dog has a food allergy, he’s probably fine: Food allergies make up 10 percent of all dog allergies. But if you’ve noticed any of the issues above, it might be time to switch formulas. “When pets have food sensitivities or allergies, it is most commonly due to protein in the food,” Dr. Gary Richter told us. “Sometimes the problem is a meat like chicken or beef, and sometimes it is the protein component of plant material, such as wheat, corn or rice.”

Research availability

Our top picks are all readily available online, but some companies only distribute regionally or in specialty stores. If you prefer in-person shopping, you might run into some of our regional runners-up on the shelves. Rest assured that they are excellent choices as well.

Look at cost

No matter what your budget looks like, don’t feel guilty about sticking to it. If you’re willing and able, and want to splurge for our most expensive dry food (Ziwi Peak), go for it. If you prefer paying less for Fromm Classic, our cheapest pick, we’re confident that it’s a balanced, nutritious and high-quality option. Don’t feel pressured to get the most expensive food in order to be a No. 1 dog parent.

Consult your vet

After hundreds of hours of ingredient research and expert interviews, we ended up with 30 top brands. They’re all great and we’d feel good feeding any of them to our pets. However, you know your dog’s needs best. If you have any concerns, it’s a good idea to talk to your vet about which food will work well. If they’re unfamiliar with the presented issues, it’s recommended to reach out to a Boarded Veterinary Nutritionist for help or clarification. Veterinary nutritionists willing to give advice may be contacted through the American College of Veterinary Nutritionists.

Dog Food FAQs

How often should I feed my dog?

All dog food labels include feeding suggestions, which list the recommended amount of food per day according to your dog’s weight. Feed your dog about two times each day at 8-12 hour intervals, making sure not to overfeed him.

How much should I feed my dog?

Your dog’s metabolism and lifestyle will factor into how much and how often he should be fed. Dr. Gary Richter notes, “Just as with humans, a highly active pet is going to require more calories and protein to maintain muscle mass and energy levels.” In addition to feeding guidelines provided on food labels, pay attention to your dog’s body shape and energy levels to figure out how much food he needs to stay active and trim.

How long can canned dog food be left out?

Dr. Lindsey Bullen recommends that wet food should never be left out for longer than 30 minutes to an hour: “Water creates the perfect environment for microbial contamination, so make sure to clean up quickly if your pup leaves leftover food in his bowl. Additionally, regardless of food type, food bowls should be cleaned on a regular basis.”

How do I know if my dog is overweight?

When viewed from above, your dog should have a visible waist, which looks like a gentle taper between the ribcage and hips. You should be able to feel, but not see, his ribs when placing your hands on the sides of his chest. If your dog’s ribs are showing, he’s too skinny. But if he’s oval when viewed from above, and has a wobbling belly when viewed from the side, he’s likely overweight.

Can I leave dog food out all day?

Dr. Lindsey Bullen warns that free feeding isn’t a recommended feeding method; rather a minimum of 2-3 meals per day is suggested for the average pet (more frequent meals may be required in certain circumstances, like if your dog is ​pregnant or ​nursing puppies).

How do I file a pet food complaint?

You can report complaints or concerns about any commercial pet food through the FDA, which can investigate if enough complaints are directed at the same company. You can also contact a manufacturer directly, through the toll-free customer inquiry number listed on the product label.

Why isn't my dog food listed?

You and your vet know what works best for your dog. We looked at over 3,000 formulas, but some may still slip through the cracks. It’s also possible your dog food was cut based on the criteria we outlined above. If you’re concerned about yours not making the cut, check the ingredients against our list and speak with your vet.

The Best Dog Food: Summed Up

Brand/Line
Type
Price
Available Online
First Ingredient on Label
Fromm Classic
Dry Food
$1.20-$1.33 per pound
Chicken
Chicken Soup for the Soul Life Stages Wet Dog Food
Wet Food
$0.11 per ounce
Chicken
Fromm Gold
Puppy Food
$1.64-$2.70 per pound
Duck
Holistic Health Extension
Grain-Free Food
$2.29-$3.99 per pound
Organic deboned chicken
NomNomNow
Dog Food Delivery Service
$3.00-$10.00 per day
Beef/pork/​chicken/turkey