The Best Natural Deodorant
The best natural deodorant fends off odor without using ingredients that are likely to be toxic or irritating. After talking with a dermatologist, a chemist, and two natural deodorant creators, we hand-tested 23 to find our top picks: aluminum-free formulas with pleasant scents, goop-free application, and minimal residue.
Schmidt's Natural Deodorant
Two brands of long-lasting, aluminum-free sticks that leave little clumping or flaking. Both come in a wide range of scents.
For Pit's Sake! Natural Deodorant
Not two, but all three of our wishlist odor-fighting ingredients. Unfortunately, it comes with a stickier application experience.
The Best Natural Deodorant
Sam’s Natural Deodorant
$10 for 3 ounces
Schmidt’s Natural Deodorant
$10 for 3.25 ounces
For Pit’s Sake! Natural Deodorant
$9 for 2.5 ounces
Green Tidings All-Natural Deodorant
$14 for 2.7 ounce
Fatco Women’s Stank Stop Deodorant
$12 for 1 ounce (also available in men's)
Agent Natuer & Shiva Rose Holi Rose Deodorant
$25 for 1.7 ounces
In the world of deodorant, “natural” is often code for “aluminum-free.” But we wanted more: a product that was also easy to apply and effective at stopping odors. Call us dreamers.
Sam's Natural Deodorant checked every box on our list. The product is free of aluminum, free of common irritants, and its first two ingredients (coconut oil and baking soda) are verified odor-blockers. We found the circular stick easy to maneuver across our pits, and it left minimal goop on clothes and only a faint sheen on skin. The Cedar and Women’s scents that we tested both lasted through two hours of wear — without smelling overpowering — and if neither of these options appeals to you, Sam’s offers 13 more scents. Each stick is reasonably priced ($10 for 3 ounces) and an easy gateway for anyone interested in transitioning to a natural product.
We nearly missed Schmidt's Natural Deodorant altogether since some of its other product lines, including its jar formulas and sensitive skin sticks, only feature one of our targeted ingredients. But Schmidt’s sticks for regular skin boast the same odor-busting coconut oil and baking soda as Sam’s, in a similarly flake- and residue-free formula. We tried four of its seven scents and liked the cool “freshly fallen rain” nose of the Charcoal+Magnesium formula — although if you like a pop of floral, its Rose+Vanilla certainly delivers. The price point is about the same as Sam’s: around $10 for 3 ounces.
For Pit's Sake is an excellent runner-up. This product comes in a stick that leaves almost no residue, but we did have to use quite a bit of force to fully coat our pits, which some of our hairy-pitted testers weren’t too into. That said, it includes all three of the odor-blocking ingredients we pinpointed in our research — coconut oil, baking soda, and zinc — at a comfortable $9.
If buying organic is your top priority, we’d suggest Green Tidings. Like Sam’s and Schmidt’s, this deodorant is vegan and cruelty-free, but its ingredients are also certified organic by the US Department of Agriculture (USDA) and it’s made in a solar-powered plant. The trade-off? It’s a little more expensive, at $8 for a 1-ounce tube. Green Tidings is aluminum-free and includes baking soda and (organic) coconut oil to fend off body odor. The subtle scent (courtesy of organic lavender essential oil) didn’t last as long as Sam’s, but after two hours, we didn’t notice any BO, either. Testers did find the product a bit gritty, but some of them liked this added assurance that they’d successfully coated their underarms.
We also unearthed a couple more intriguing options. Fatco Stank Stop Deodorant was the only other natural dedorant we tested that included all three of our wish-list odor-blockers. (It’s also Certified Paleo, and includes beef tallow as a moisturizer.) Fatco is a cream, which means you’ll need to dip your fingers into a (very small) jar to apply the product — a process our testers weren’t wild about. But the deodorant itself was very effective, with a pleasant smell and minimal residue.
Some of us also really loved Agent Nateur & Shiva Rose Holi (Rose) Deodorant, which seemed almost like a combination of deodorant and women’s perfume (although not everyone liked the rose and sandalwood scent). Holi Rose leaves very little residue, and while it was also the most expensive product that we tested ($25 for 1.7 ounces), it’s a good high-end option if you’re concerned about protecting delicate fabric.
How We Found the Best Natural Deodorant
We started with 155 products all marketed as natural deodorants. Our picks included recommendations from “best of” lists in magazines like Allure, Good Housekeeping, and Men’s Journal, as well as best-sellers from mainstream retailers (think Walgreens) and natural- and organic-oriented e-commerce sites, like Thrive Market and Swanson Health Products.
Then we had to figure out what “natural” even means.
When it comes to beauty and bodycare products, it turns out that neither the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) nor the USDA regulates the term “natural.” And that can be a problem.
“Natural means nothing. Hemlock is natural, but hemlock can kill you,” says Nathan Morin, the self-proclaimed Deodorant King of Chicago, and creator and CEO of North Coast Organics, a maker of certified organic natural deodorants. “People misuse the term; people misunderstand it.” Case in point:
For most people, “natural” simply means “no aluminum.”
According to the experts we consulted, many natural deodorants were specifically developed because of concerns about aluminum. Research stretching back more than 50 years has suggested that aluminum exposure might increase your risk of developing Alzheimer’s disease, and separate studies have also linked aluminum exposure to breast cancer. However, the National Cancer Institute, American Cancer Society, and FDA all believe there’s not enough evidence to support either claim. The FDA does require aluminum-based antiperspirants to come with a label advising anyone with severe kidney issues to consult with their doctor before using it (aluminum is eliminated from the body by the kidneys), but even here, the National Kidney Foundation indicates that risk is low.
Still, concern over the safety of aluminum-based antiperspirants persists, both from venerated news sources (including Scientific American and Time) and newer, “green”-centric blogs, like mindbodygreen and TreeHugger. For more, read our review on the best antiperspirant.
We cut any deodorant containing aluminum — in any form.
Cutting aluminum was an obvious choice, but it also meant we had to avoid potassium alum. This ingredient is a mineral salt often used in products marketed as natural deodorants (including products from both Tom’s of Maine and Crystal). Because potassium alum is mined from the ground, you can argue that it’s “natural.” But it’s still a type of aluminum.
“That marketing is misleading,” explains Morin. “Brands will clarify the form of aluminum and write on the label ‘Aluminum Chlorohydrate-Free’ instead of ‘Aluminum-Free.’ In our industry, we call that green washing.”
Crystal Body Deodorant Roll-On Unscented, Crystal Body Deodorant Spray – Unscented, Crystal Body Deodorant Stick, Crystal Body Deodorant Stick for Men, Crystal Body Deodorant Towelettes, Crystal Body Sport Deodorant Stick, Crystal Essence Body Spray – Lavender & White Tea, Crystal Essence Mineral Deodorant Towelettes – Pomegranate, Crystal Essence Mineral Essence Mineral Deodorant Roll-On Pomegranate, Crystal Rock Body Deodorant Stick for Men, Crystal Rock Deo Body Spray Unscented, Crystal Rock Onyx Storm Body Spray, Herban Cowboy Dusk Maximum Protection Deodorant, Herban Cowboy Maximum Protection Deodorant Unscented, Herban Cowboy Maximum Protection Deodorant Womens Love, Kiss My Face Liquid Rock Deodorant Fragrance Free, Kiss My Face Liquid Rock Deodorant Patchouli, Lafe’s Natural Deodorant Roll-On Unscented, Lafe’s Natural Deodorant Spray Lavender, Lafe’s Natural Deodorant Spray Unscented, Lafe’s Natural Roll-On Deodorant Active Citrus & Bergamot, Le Couvent des Minimes Everyday Deodorant, Naturally Fresh Deodorant Crystal Roll-On Original, Naturally Fresh Deodorant Crystal Spray Mist Body Deodorant, Naturally Fresh Deodorant Crystal with Aloe Vera, Naturally Fresh Roll-On Fragrance-Free, RazoRock Aloe Alum Roll-On Deodorant, RazoRock Aloe Alum Spray Deodorant, Tom’s of Maine Natural Confidence Deodorant Crystal Citrus Zest, Tom’s of Maine Natural Confidence Deodorant Crystal Fragrance Free
Then, we struck out potential irritants.
Most of us apply deodorant every day, on an area of skin that’s already thin and delicate — especially if you shave regularly. We wanted to ditch anything that increased the chance of itchy, bumpy pits.
FDA Loopholes The FDA requires any retail cosmetic to list its ingredients, usually individually. The two exceptions: “fragrance” and “flavor.” The Fair Packaging and Labeling Act (FPLA) deemed fragrance and flavor to be complex mixtures of many natural and synthetic chemical ingredients; asking a company to reveal these might force it to tell its trade secrets.
Fragrance “can cause mild to severe irritation,” says Dr. Audrey Kunin, dermatologist and creator of the DERMAdoctor skincare line. “As a dermatologist, I formulate products to be fragrance-free for this reason.” Other dermatologists we spoke to told us the same. Cutting anything with synthetic fragrance also increases transparency, as the term can mask any number of unidentified chemicals.
Simple alcohols can have bacteria-fighting properties — a good thing because it’s the bacteria that feast on your sweat that cause body odor. But they can also ruin the skin’s protective lipid barrier, causing irritation. On an ingredients label, simple alcohols may appear as isopropyl alcohol, SD alcohol, or denatured alcohol.
Propylene glycol and propanediol are both frequently used in body care products as solvents and preservatives, but there’s a growing body of research suggesting they could be toxic. “They are no longer being used regularly due to some data that they might be harmful,” confirms cosmetic chemist Ron Robinson, of BeautyStat.com. Indeed, both are included on Whole Foods’ list of unacceptable ingredients for premium body care.
Alvera All-Natural Roll-On Deodorant Aloe and Almonds, Arm & Hammer Essentials Deodorant with Natural Deodorizers, Arm & Hammer Essentials Deodorant with Natural Deodorizers Unscented, Aubrey E Plus High C Roll-On Deodorant, Aubrey Men’s Stock Natural Dry Deodorant Herbal Pine, Aubrey Organics Calendula Blossom Natural Deodorant Spray, Burt’s Bees Herbal Deodorant, Desert Essence Natural Roll-On Deodorant, Dr. Hauschka Deodorant in Rose, Earth Science Liken Plant Natural Deodorant Herbal Parfume, Earth Science Liken Plant Natural Deodorant Unscented, GEODEO Natural Deodorant with Detox Complex, Herbal Clear 24-Hour Natural Sport Deodorant, Home Health Herbal Magic Roll-On Deodorant Herbal Scent, InstaNatural Natural Deodorant, JASON Deodorant Stick Tea Tree, JASON Dry Spray Deodorant Fresh Cucumber, JASON Men Dry Spray Deodorant Forest Fresh, Kiss My Face Natural Active Life Aluminum Free Deodorant Stick Fragrance Free, Kiss My Face Natural Active Life Aluminum Free Deodorant Stick Lavender, Kiss My Face Natural Man DEO All Day Deodorant Aqua, Kiss My Face Quick Dry Spray Deodorant Cucumber & Green Tea, Kiss My Face Smooth Deo Aluminum-Free Deodorant Lemongrass Mint & Aloe, Lavilin Roll-On Deodorant, Lavilin Underarm Deodorant Cream, Lucky Tiger Head to Tail Deodorant and Body Spray, Malin + Goetz Eucalyptus, Nature’s Gate Green Tea & Blue Cypress Deodorant Stick, Nourish Organic Fresh & Dry Deodorant Almond Vanilla, Queen Helene All Day Strength Mint Julep Deodorant, The Honest Company Honest Deodorant in Bergamot Sage, Tom’s of Maine Long Lasting Natural Deodorant Refreshing Lemongrass, Tom’s of Maine Long Lasting Natural Deodorant Unscented, Tom’s of Maine Original Care Natural Deodorant Stick Unscented
From there, we looked for formulas that included coconut oil, zinc oxide, and/or baking soda.
Companies tout a slew of naturally derived ingredients for their ability to mask smells and fight bacteria. But we found the strongest evidence in support of coconut oil, zinc oxide, and baking soda — and these three options were also mentioned again and again by our experts.
Coconut oil “contains lauric acid, which is very good at killing odor-causing bacteria,” says Morin. Additional research from the journal Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy confirms lauric acid’s bacteria-killing powers.
Zinc oxide has been used in deodorant products since the 19th century. (Fun fact: It was actually the active ingredient in Mum, the first trademarked deodorant.) Today, research from the Society of Cosmetic Chemists (login required) shows that it can neutralize odor by converting smelly, short fatty acids released by bacteria when they feast on your sweat into odorless zinc salts. In fact, the same study found zinc oxide to be three times more effective at this process than aluminum chlorohydrate, a common active ingredient in traditional antiperspirants.
Baking soda “is one of the most effective ingredients for eliminating acidic odor-causing bacteria,” says Jaime Schmidt, the founder and chief product officer of Schmidt’s Naturals. Robinson agrees: “It deodorizes due to its ability to neutralize a wide variety of substances.” Baking soda can raise the pH of an environment, which, in the case of a sweaty (and therefore acidic) armpit, makes the area inhospitable to bacteria.
To capture the most deodorizing power, we looked for formulas with at least two of these three ingredients. That left us with 19 natural deodorant formulas in a variety of of scents to try out for ourselves.
Alba Botanica Clear Enzyme Deodorant Stick, All Good Natural Deodorant Tea Tree and Basil, All Good Natural Deodorant Unscented, Biotherm Deo Pure Natural Protect Deodorant Stick, Bubble and Bee Lemongrass Rosemary “Odor Bee Gone” Organic Deodorant Stick, Bubble and Bee Natural Deodorant Spray, Bubble and Bee Spearmint & Tea Tree Sensitive Skin Organic Deodorant, Bubble and Bee Truly Herbal Organic Deodorant Stick, Bulldog Natural Skincare Deodorant for Men Cedarwood & Patchouli, Burt’s Bees Natural Skin Care for Men Deodorant, Desert Essence Lemon Tea Tree Deodorant, EO Organic Deodorant Spray Vetiver, EO Organic Deodorant Wipes Lavender, Erbaviva Organic Deodorant in Jasmine Grapefruit, Every Man Jack Deodorant Cedarwood, Every Man Jack Fragrance-Free Deodorant, Fatco Pit Spritz, GEODEO Unscented Natural Deodorant, Home Health Herbal Magic Roll-On Deodorant Unscented, Honeybee Gardens Deodorant Powder for Men Bay Rum, Hugo Naturals Dual Action Deodorant Stick Mexican Lime and Bergamot, Hugo Naturals Dual Action Deodorant Stick Unscented, JASON Deodorant Stick Naturally Fresh Unscented for Women, JASON Fragrance-Free Deodorant Stick, JASON Men Stick Deodorant Forest Fresh, Junglejuice All-Natural Deodorant, Jungleman All-Natural Deodorant, Junglemint All-Natural Deodorant, Junglewoman All-Natural Deodorant, Lafe’s Natural and Organic Deodorant Stick Unscented, Lafe’s Natural Deodorant Twist-Stick Active, Lavanila The Healthy Deodorant in Vanilla Lavender, Lavanila The Healthy Deodorant Unscented, Lavilin Fragrance-Free Roll-On Deodorant, LoveFresh Mandarin Lime Deodorant Stick, Meow Meow Tweet Lavender Bergamot Deodorant Stick, Miessence Aroma-Free Roll-On Deodorant, Miessence Roll-On Deodorant, Mill Creek Herbal Deodorant, Mill Creek Unscented Deodorant, Nasanta Magnesium Deodorant Men, Nasanta Magnesium Deodorant Women, Nine Naturals Natural Protection Deodorant Unscented, Nubian Heritage 24-Hour All-Natural Deodorant Indian Hemp & Haitian Vetiver, Nullo Deodorant Tablets, Osmia Organics Deodorant Cream, RazoRock The Best Deodorant on Earth, RL Linden & Co. Close to Me Uplifting Deodorant Spray, Schmidt’s Deodorant in Lavender + Sage, Schmidt’s Deodorant Natural Deodorant Fragrance-Free, Schmidt’s Sensitive Deodorant Tea Tree, Schmidt’s Sensitive Unscented Deodorant, Schmidt’s Stick Deodorant Fragrance Free for Sensitive Skin, Schmidt’s Unscented Deodorant Cream, Soapwalla Deodorant Cream, Terressentials Organic Lavender Fresh Super Protection Deodorant, Thai Deodorant Stone, Thai Deodorant Stone Pure and Natural Crystal Deodorant Stone, Thai Deodorant Stone Pure and Natural Powder, Thai Deodorant Stone Pure Natural Crystal Deodorant Mist, Tom’s of Maine Long Lasting Men’s Mountain Spring Deodorant, Tom’s of Maine Natural Long Lasting Women’s Deodorant Beautiful Earth, Via Nature Natural Deodorant Spray, Via Nature Natural Deodorant Stick, Via Nature Natural Roll-On Deodorant, Violets Are Blue Extra Strength Sport Deodorant with Baking Soda and Kanolin Clay, Weleda Wild Rose Deodorant, Zion Health ClayDry Natural Deodorant
- AC Nature Natural Deodorant Cream
- AC Nature Natural Deodorant Stick
- Agent Nateur No. 4 Holi (Rose) Deodorant
- Bubble and Bee Lemon & Clove Pit Putty Organic Deodorant Cream
- Bubble and Bee Lemongrass Pit Putty Organic Deodorant
- Fatco Stank Stop Deodorant, Cypress & Coriander
- Fatco Women’s Stank Stop Deodorant
- For Pit’s Sake Lime & Clove
- Green Tidings All-Natural Deodorant
- Lulu Organics Deodorant Cream
- Meow Meow Tweet Deodorant Cream
- North Coast Organics Death by Lavender
- North Coast Organics Naked
- NOW Foods Long Lasting Deodorant Stick
- PiperWai Natural Deodorant
- PiperWai Natural Deodorant Stick
- Primal Pit Paste Natural Deodorant for Men
- Primal Pit Paste Stick Lavender
- Sam’s Natural Deodorant
- Sam’s Natural Deodorant for Women
- Schmidt’s Natural Deodorant – Charcoal+ Magnesium
- Schmidt’s Natural Deodorant – Rose+Vanilla
- Schmidt’s Natural Deodorant – Bergamot+Lime
- Schmidt’s Natural Deodorant – Lavender+Sage
- SoapMe with Nature Don’t Sweat It! All-Natural Deodorant Citrus Fresh
- Trim Healthy Mama Hippie Stick – All-Natural Bouquet
- Trim Healthy Mama Hippie Stick – Unscented
We tested each one for scent, ease of application, and residue.
To test our remaining options, we enlisted 14 subjects — men and women, with both shaved and hairy pits. We asked them to evaluate each natural deodorant on three qualities: scent, application, and residue (similar to our testing process for the best antiperspirant).
First, our subjects sniffed each product in its container, and then again on their own skin two hours after application. We were looking for a fresh, neutral scent — nothing too noxious or overwhelming.
We also wanted to check out the application process. Some of our finalists, like Fatco’s Stank Stop Deodorant, were creams that you dipped into and rubbed in with your fingers; others, like Bubble and Bee Lemon & Clove Pit Putty Organic Deodorant, were technically sticks, but so soft that excess product kept globbing around the rim of the applicator. Regardless of application method, we wanted to weed out products that clumped, crumbled, or refused to glide on.
Wearability was important, too. After applying each product to our underarms, we evaluated how it felt after a couple of hours: Sticky? Tacky? Too thick? At that two-hour mark, our testers also swiped a square of black T-shirt fabric against their armpits to evaluate how much of the product wiped off. The less residue, the better. We expect the best natural deodorant to stay on our skin, not our shirts.
Our Picks for the Best Natural Deodorants
Sam’s Natural Deodorant has all the right ingredients (and none of the wrong ones), with baking soda and coconut oil topping the list. As a bonus, Sam’s also includes shea butter as a moisturizer, and tea tree oil. (Tea tree oil might have antimicrobial qualities although more clinical research is needed to confirm. But our experts agreed that it certainly doesn’t hurt to have it included.)
Sam’s comes in 15 scents. We tested both its “Women’s” and Cedar options, but a quick look at ingredient labels confirmed the only difference is the essential oil used for scent. Of the two we tested, Cedar was slightly fainter, and Women’s had an herby lavender smell (although some of our testers described it as “citrusy”). Both scents were fairly unisex, pleasant upon first application, and held up well when we checked in two hours later.
Do men and women need different deodorants? The short answer: no.
Research published in Experimental Physiology confirms that there are differences in how men and women sweat: Men sweat more and begin sweating at a lower body temperature than women. But sweat is essentially sweat, and the same research found that the salt and water content, regardless of sex, is pretty much the same.
So why are so many deodorants marketed toward a specific gender? When we reviewed antiperspirants, we spoke with Dr. David Pariser, senior physician at Pariser Dermatology, who told us: “In terms of active ingredients, there’s no difference between men’s and women’s products. The main difference is scent.”
But for natural deodorants, this distinction seemed a bit pointless. Our testers thought most of the scents we tried were pretty unisex. To find our top picks, we ultimately focused on the best ingredients and strongest test results.
Sam’s also performed well in our application and residue tests. The product comes in a circular stick that was easy to maneuver across our pits. In fact, our testers generally preferred circular sticks (like Sam’s, Primal Pit Paste, and SoapMe) over ovals (like Hippie Stick and For Pit’s Sake). The shape seemed to fit better inside our armpits and left less excess goop on our underarms and around the stick’s rim.
Sam’s coverage felt so sheer that one of our testers questioned whether it was going on, but a test swipe on her forearm left a slight sheen: The product was applying — it just wasn’t leaving a layer of goop. (This was in stark contrast with SoapMe, which left large clumps after application. Ick.)
Sam’s also left minimal residue on T-shirt fabric — one subject noted “almost nothing, no flaking or clumps” when he checked. The only deodorants to outperform Sam’s in our residue test were For Pit’s Sake and Agent Nateur No. 4 Holi (Rose) Deodorant.
However, For Pit’s Sake and Agent Nateur both featured scents that were more polarizing: One tester likened For Pit’s Sake’s Lime & Clove to “the musty scent of someone who had been out working in the woods,” although it does also come in Unscented, Lavender, and Citrus. Agent Nateur got a more positive reception, but was dubbed extremely “feminine” thanks to its blend of rose and sandalwood, with one tester saying it was “a little grandma-y.” In short, both our Sam’s deodorants were more universally appealing.
At $10 for a 3-ounce stick, Sam’s also falls a little below the median price of our 23 finalists (which ranged from roughly $6 to $25). And if you want something that’s kind to the planet (and not just your wallet), you’ll be happy to know that Sam’s is hand-crafted in New Hampshire and vegan and cruelty-free.
If you like the sound of Sam’s, you’re going to have a tough time ignoring Schmidt’s. The formula in its Natural Deodorant Sticks isn’t quite as creamy as Sam’s — we had to press it into our pits to warm it up for a few moments when putting it on. And it comes in a traditional oval applicator as opposed to our preferred round. But Schmidt’s ingredients list is spot on: baking soda and coconut oil, plus shea butter and arrowroot powder to help it glide.
We nearly missed Schmidt’s in this review — its other product lines, including its sensitive skin sticks and its cream formula, only feature one of our three targeted ingredients. But we were glad we did a second sweep and discovered its regular-skin formulas, which matched Sam’s lack of flaking and residue. Sam’s wins with its sheer number of scents — 15 to Schmidt’s seven — but we give credit to Schmidt’s newest addition, Charcoal+Magnesium. Its “freshly fallen rain” aroma was the ultimate favorite of everything we tested. You can grab a stick of Schmidt’s for about $10.
For Pit’s Sake was one of only two natural deodorants we tested that contained baking soda, coconut oil, and zinc oxide, not just two of our wishlist ingredients like most of our other top. This combination is definitely a winning formula: Testers were unable to detect any body odor at the two-hour mark, and For Pit’s Sake did an outstanding job on our residue test (tying with Agent Nateur, an option we touch on below). “Did I even put it on? I know I did because I can smell it, but wow there’s no residue at all,” noted one of our testers.
But some of us found it a little too dry, with one of our hairy-pitted testers complaining that it “wasn’t very giving” and that he had to do “repeated passes” to achieve full coverage. The stick also had a flat top, with edges that added to our discomfort.
Almost unanimously, we did not like the lime and clove scent that we tried (it was sort of like a combination of “margarita” and “grandmother’s holiday punch”). But, fortunately, you can get For Pit’s Sake in three other scents, including unscented. We’d suggest giving one of those a try. Each stick runs about $9.
Other Natural Deodorants to Consider
If you’re looking for an organic deodorant, look no further than Green Tidings Natural Deodorant, which is our favorite of the six we tested that use ingredients that have been certified organic by the USDA. It’s also advertised as vegan, cruelty-free, and is made in a solar-powered facility. (Unfortunately, sustainable manufacturing practices aren’t always the most cost-effective, which may explain why a 1-ounce tube ran us about $8.)
The ingredient list is similar to Sam’s: Baking soda and coconut oil are at the top of the list, and shea butter is included as a moisturizer.
Lavender = Ladies After scrutinizing 155 deodorants, it became very obvious that lavender tends to be the go-to scent for natural deodorants marketed toward women. Other common “womanly” scents include jasmine, rose, and honeysuckle.
We tested Green Tidings’ lavender formula, although an unscented option is also available. Once again, our testers thought the scent was fairly unisex, with a very mild herbal aroma that omits the citrus notes of Sam’s. While the smell didn’t last long, neither was it replaced by body odor. When we checked in at the two-hour mark, our pits basically smelled like nothing.
Green Tidings’ scent performance was in contrast with AC Nature’s Natural Deodorant Stick, another organic option that we really wanted to like, but which one tester described as smelling “gross,” and “like Play-Doh.” AC Nature also didn’t do a great job of masking sweat after a couple of hours. (As our disappointed tester put it, “It’s like I’ve traded one bad scent for another.”)
Green Tidings did feel a little gritty going on. One tester actually liked this, saying the grit made it so she could “really feel it in my pits” and know the product had applied. And unlike certified organic finalists from North Coast Organics and Bubble and Bee, Green Tidings comes in a circular stick and left no goopy clumps on our skin or hanging off the tube. When we tried our T-shirt test, Green Tidings also left way less residue than North Coast Organics Death by Lavender and Bubble and Bee Lemon & Clove Pit Putty Organic Deodorant Stick. The photos speak for themselves.
One thing to note: There is a difference between a deodorant that has been USDA-certified organic and one that uses ingredients that are USDA-certified. We confirmed with Green Tidings that its ingredients are USDA-certified, but the company is still in the process of getting its actual deodorant certified (the process can be lengthy).
Our testers generally preferred stick application, partly because it felt familiar — it’s essentially the same as rolling on a traditional antiperspirant. More importantly, creams were goopier, and most of our testers didn’t like having to wipe off their fingers after every application. But among the seven cream natural deodorant brands we tested, Fatco Stank Stop stood out. Its formula is one of only two among our finalists to combine all three of our preferred odor-fighting ingredients: baking soda, coconut oil, and zinc oxide.
Stank Stop also contains tallow (aka fat) from organic grass-fed cow as a moisturizer, which might seem odd until you realize Fatco is Paleo-certified and promotes “looking to the past for fundamentals of healthy living.” Tallow is actually one of its flagship ingredients. (Note that we found nothing to indicate that tallow makes for a better deodorant.)
Fatco Stank Stop Deodorant comes in two scents: a Men’s Cypress + Coriander and a Women’s Lavender + Clary Sage. As with other gender-specific deodorants, the ingredients differed only by the scent of the essential oil. We really liked both and suggest Cypress + Coriander for something a bit more woodsy, and Lavender + Clary Sage if you want a gentle aroma reminiscent of a spa treatment.
Some of our testers thought dipping their fingers into goop, rubbing it onto their armpits, and then washing their fingers was just too messy, and Fatco’s small jars forced some of us to dip our fingers in several times to get enough product, which seemed impractical for anyone with big hands. One tester noted that the scent also lingered on his fingers even after washing.
That said, the accepted rationale for using a cream deodorant is that this application method gives you more control — you can ensure you’ve got an even coating across your entire armpit. If that compels you, go ahead and give Fatco a try. A 1-ounce jar will run you about $12.
Agent Nateur & Shiva Rose Holi (Rose) Deodorant was another runner-up. Like our top picks, this product uses baking soda and coconut oil, but it’s a little fancier than a standard odor-blocker. It’s pretty obviously geared toward women, with a white, pink, and gold package that feels reminiscent of department store cosmetics. As for the scent, one tester noted the blend of rose and sandalwood smelled “like perfume,” although another cautioned that, while she liked it, she did find it a little “powdery.”
The company behind this product has a manifesto to “bring beauty and luminosity to women in a way that is nourishing and nurturing,” aka synthetic-, GMO-, and pesticide-free (although the deodorant does contain castor oil, which is on Whole Foods’ list of ingredients to avoid). We’d suggest trying Holi Rose if you’re looking for a high-end option. At $25, it was our most expensive finalist — but it also tied with For Pit’s Sake as a top performer in our fabric residue test. If you’re dressing for a special occasion or have a wardrobe dominated by dark colors or expensive fabrics, it could be a worthwhile investment.
Did You Know?
There’s a difference between antiperspirants and deodorants.
While an antiperspirant stops sweat (typically via aluminum), a deodorant’s primary aim is to neutralize or mask body odor. Sweat is actually odorless when secreted from your body; the smell is a byproduct released by the bacteria that feast on sweat.
One perk of opting for a natural deodorant? The aluminum found in most antiperspirants can coat fabric, giving sebum (an oil secreted by hair follicles) a place to stick — which can mean more yellow pit stains on your white shirts. An aluminum-free product helps avoid the issue.
Lots of claims have been made about the most common ingredients in natural deodorants — but very few have been verified.
We looked for baking soda, coconut oil, and zinc oxide in our top picks because we found ample research to back up their bacteria-busting properties. But those are far from the only ingredients that get touted. You might also see:
Experts were torn on these two (very similar) ingredients. The team at Schmidt’s Deodorant described arrowroot powder, which shows up in Sam’s and Fatco, as a “star ingredient” and “an absorbent powder that can help to keep you dry without aluminum.” Morin, on the other hand, said that arrowroot and cornstarch only “help to a tiny degree with sweat” and that their “main reason for inclusion is to create a creamier texture — important, but not critical.”
A composite organism of fungus and algae (aka the gray-green patches that grow on the sides of rocks and trees). Research shows that lichens can have antimicrobial qualities, but they haven’t made their way into many natural deodorants yet. Only 13 of the 155 formulas we looked at included lichen — none of our top picks — and Robinson acknowledged that while lichens do appear to protect from odor, he “had not seen any studies comparing them to other odor-fighting ingredients.”
Magnesium may act similarly to baking soda “by neutralizing acidic odor-causing bacteria,” said the team at Schmidt’s Deodorant. Magnesium oil shows up in Green Tidings.
A rich moisturizer that, according to Morin, helps a deodorant glide on smoothly. Coconut oil performs a similar function (but has the added benefit of bacteria-fighting lauric acid).
Both Robinson and Schmidt’s Deodorant mentioned the purported antifungal and antimicrobial qualities of this oil, derived from the leaves of an Australian tree. But while it does show up in Sam’s, our top pick, neither expert felt it was a must-have. (Remember, the research on the antimicrobial activity of tea tree oil mostly says that more research is needed to confirm.)
According to Schmidt, this ingredient “can lead to uncomfortably wet, sticky, or skin-drying formulations, but does have deodorizing properties.” It doesn’t show up in any of our top picks.
This ingredient “is a salt that is said to help absorb bacteria and ‘trap’ it so that the nose doesn’t necessarily smell it,” the Schmidt’s Deodorant team told us. “It’s also reputed by many to be an ineffective deodorizer that can trigger skin reactions.” Indeed, type the name into Google and two suggested searches will add “rash” and “safety.” It doesn’t appear in any of our top picks.
“Natural” isn’t regulated — but “organic” is.
If a deodorant is made with agricultural products that can meet USDA standards for organic production, handling, processing, and labeling, it may be eligible for certification under the USDA’s National Organic Program.
There are three possible tiers of certification:
- “100% Organic” is limited to products comprised entirely (save for water and salt) of organic ingredients.
- “Organic” refers to products comprised of 95 to 99 percent organic ingredients.
- “Made with Organic Ingredients” can be applied to products made with 70 to 94 percent organic ingredients.
But does a deodorant that’s certified organic or that uses certified organic ingredients actually perform differently? “A cold-pressed certified organic unrefined coconut oil-based deodorant is going to be more effective,” said Morin, explaining that the refining process (which includes high levels of heat, bleaching, and deodorizing) can degrade the integrity of a plant-based ingredient, impacting its efficacy.
But the team at Schmidt’s also points out that organic ingredients are subject to some of the same challenges in achieving effectiveness as their non-organic counterparts, including weather, crop quality, and freshness — qualities a certified organic seal simply doesn’t address.
We didn’t make certified organic ingredients a criterion across all our top picks, but if it’s a quality you value, Green Tidings is a good choice, as are products from Morin’s company, North Coast Organics.