Reviews Report
- Reviews.com scores Allstate auto insurance a 4.2 out of 5, based on financial strength, online resources, and coverage.
- Allstate has superior financial strength, indicating a history of paying customer claims in full.
- Allstate received average rankings for purchase experience and overall auto insurance satisfaction, but above average rankings for claims satisfaction in J.D. Power 2020 and 2021 studies.
Allstate auto insurance began in 1931 under Sears, Roebuck & Co. chairman Robert E. Wood. In 1939, Allstate was the first car insurance company to base quote rates on age, mileage, and usage, offering more competitive and personalized policy premiums. The industry followed suit and now, Allstate is the fourth largest car insurer in the country.
With a wide range of coverages and a decent package of discounts, Allstate offers reliable coverage backed by positive customer ratings. Allstate has above average rankings for claims customer satisfaction, offering a Claim Satisfaction Guarantee in 43 states. Allstate offers multiple ways to file a claim 24/7 and uses local agents, which is becoming rare in the auto insurance industry.
Allstate’s Full Coverage Average Premiums in the U.S.
Data Source: Coverage.com
Allstate Car Insurance Overview
According to YouGov, Allstate is the sixth most popular insurance brand, with 45% of respondents giving the company a positive opinion. Allstate also received Fortune’s World’s Most Admired Companies award in 2020, with multiple awards received in recent years for inclusive diversity and innovation.
In 13 states, Allstate offers pay-as-you-drive insurance and telematics programs, which can reduce annual premiums based on mileage and driving habits. Allstate received rankings two points below average in J.D. Power 2020 studies for purchase experience and overall customer satisfaction. With an above-average claims satisfaction ranking, Allstate seems to live up to its Claim Satisfaction Guaranteed, offered in select states.
PROS
CONS
Allstate Car Insurance Highlights
Allstate Car Insurance vs. The Competition
| Reviews.com Score | J.D. Power Customer Satisfaction J.D. Power scores are based on surveys for customer satisfaction and product quality. | AM Best AM Best rates insurance providers creditworthiness. Ratings are based on the provider’s ability to follow through with a payout when a consumer files a claim. | No. of Discounts | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pin Allstate | 4.2 | 825* | A+ | 11 | |
| Pin Auto-Owners | 4.4 | 845* | A++ | 13 | |
| Pin Geico | 4.8 | 833* | A++ | 16 | |
| Pin State Farm | 5 | 847* | A++ | 13 |
Information accurate as of October 2021 *J.D. Power’s 2021 Auto Insurance Satisfaction Study average rating across all regions. Based on a 1,000-point scale.
Allstate vs. Auto-Owners
While Allstate only lists 11 discount options for car insurance, Auto-Owners indicates it offers 13. Auto-Owners also has above average scores for customer satisfaction, with 845 points compared to Allstate’s 825 in J.D. Power’s study. However, both companies offer superior financial strength to pay claims, though Auto-Owners J.D. Power score for claims satisfaction beats Allstate with 890 points vs. Allstate’s 876 points, which reflects Auto-Owners “no problem” claims process. While Allstate is available nationwide, Auto-Owners is only offered in 26 states, mostly on the east coast.
Allstate vs. Geico
Geico beats all the competitors by offering 16 discounts on auto insurance, with Allstate having the least with 11 discounts. Though Geico beats Allstate’s customer satisfaction score by 8 points, Allstate’s ranking for claims satisfaction is higher by five points. Geico leads in purchase experience as the No. 1 large insurer while Allstate trails behind with one point below the average score. Geico also beats Allstate in overall customer satisfaction in all regions except for Florida, where Allstate is ranked No. 2 and Geico is below-average.
Allstate vs. State Farm
Allstate and State Farm are very close in ranking scores on the J.D. Power 2020 and 2021 studies, with State Farm having higher scores for overall customer satisfaction in seven of the 11 regional studies. However, State Farm offers 13 discount options for drivers while Allstate only offers 11. Allstate offers pay-per-mile insurance but State Farm only offers a discount for low mileage drivers. Allstate also has more coverage options to customize your auto insurance than State Farm. Both Allstate and State Farm offer local agents, which are not an option with the other competitors.
Allstate Car Insurance FAQ
Methodology
We evaluated Allstate based on discounts, coverage, online resources, financial strength and customer satisfaction to determine Reviews.com scores and create our best car insurance reviews. To compare car insurance companies with other providers across the board, we calculate each Reviews.com score based on the following:
- Discounts: Auto insurance companies that advertised more discounts received higher scores in our methodology.
- Financial Stability: Reviews.com utilized AM Best ratings to assign a score based on each car insurance company’s financial stability.
- Customer Satisfaction: J.D. Power ranks car insurance companies by customer satisfaction, so we used its 2021 Auto Insurance Satisfaction Study to compare the average rating of insurers across all regions.
- Coverage: Car insurance companies were awarded higher scores for advertised coverages beyond the body liability, property liability, collision and personal injury protection.
- Online Resources: We reviewed the digital resources of each car insurance company and awarded higher scores to insurers with mobile claim estimates, digital insurance cards, and more.
About the Authors
Mandy Sleight is an insurance writer for Reviews.com. Over the last three years, she has covered insurance providers, coverage, costs of insurance, and more at MoneyGeek, Bankrate, and The Simple Dollar.
