Everyone knows how important it is to carry auto insurance, but even the best car insurance companies don’t provide coverage for most mechanical breakdowns. For post‑factory protection, shoppers typically choose a vehicle service contract (VSC) from the automaker or a third‑party provider. Recent editorials and consumer guidance emphasize that manufacturer‑backed plans often deliver the smoothest claims and dealer acceptance, while a small group of third‑party providers (notably Endurance, Olive, CARCHEX, and autopom!) are frequently recommended in 2024–2025 rankings for coverage breadth and buying experience (U.S. News; Forbes Advisor).

Technically speaking, extended car warranties aren’t warranties at all – they’re service contracts. Consumer regulators advise getting the full sample contract, confirming who administers and insures the plan, and reviewing exclusions and claim steps before you sign. OEM‑backed plans (e.g., from Toyota, Honda, Ford, GM, or Stellantis) are typically accepted at franchised dealers and use OEM parts, which can reduce disputes compared with some third‑party contracts (Edmunds; Consumer Reports).

Before you purchase a VSC, compare total cost, deductible type, and coverage tier. Typical prices for multi‑year plans fall around $1,500–$4,000, and financed options often run about $100–$200 per month; common deductibles range from $0 to $250 per visit. Subscription‑style, cancel‑anytime options are also growing—Olive is frequently cited for instant online quotes and month‑to‑month flexibility (Kelley Blue Book; Edmunds; Forbes Advisor).

The 5 Top Extended Car Warranty Companies

• Olive: Best Basic/Online & Month-to-Month
• Manufacturer-backed (OEM): Best for Newer Cars
• Endurance – Best for High-Mileage Vehicles
• CARCHEX – Most Customizable
• Autopom! – Best for Frequent Travelers

Guide to Extended Car Warranties

What is an Extended Car Warranty?

An extended car warranty is really a vehicle service contract (VSC) you purchase to cover specified mechanical and electrical repairs after the factory warranty ends. These contracts are optional and governed by their terms and exclusions—not advertising. Many include roadside assistance, towing, rental reimbursement, and trip interruption. Regulators advise reading the entire contract, confirming the administrator and any insurer backing, and getting promises in writing (FTC).

What is Covered by Extended Car Warranties?

Coverage depends on plan type. Common tiers are powertrain (engine/transmission/driveline), stated‑component (named systems like HVAC, fuel, steering, electrical), and exclusionary plans that cover everything except listed exclusions. Top‑tier plans increasingly include electronics, infotainment, and ADAS modules and calibrations when tied to a covered repair; EV traction batteries are typically handled under separate OEM warranties, while many VSCs list EV drive units, inverters, and on‑board chargers as covered components (KBB guide; Ford Protect; Consumer Reports).

What’s typically included

• Covered repairs or replacements for listed parts or, on exclusionary plans, for any non‑excluded failure
• Roadside assistance and towing benefits; many plans reimburse rental cars
• Trip interruption (lodging/meals) with daily and aggregate caps spelled out in the contract
• Diagnostics/calibrations when required to complete an authorized covered repair (plan‑specific)

What’s excluded

• Routine maintenance and wear items (oil, filters, brake pads/rotors as wear, tires) and cosmetic/body/glass/trim
• Pre‑existing conditions, misuse/abuse, and failures due to lack of required maintenance or undocumented service history
• Aftermarket modifications or non‑factory accessories unless explicitly covered in the contract
• Stand‑alone adjustments/alignments or ADAS calibrations unless tied to an approved covered repair with prior authorization

Decide Whether You Need an Extended Warranty

Unlike auto insurance, extended warranties aren’t required by law. Value depends on your vehicle’s reliability, technology content, and repair‑cost risk. Typical multi‑year contracts run about $1,500–$4,000, with monthly payments often $100–$200 if financed; common deductibles range from $0 to $250 per visit (Edmunds; KBB). Also consider mechanical breakdown insurance (MBI) offered by some insurers as an alternative; compare eligibility, deductibles, and claim processes (NerdWallet).

Watch Out for Red Flags

If you encounter any of these warning signs, it’s probably best to steer clear of a company:

• Urgent calls/texts about “expiring” coverage: Treat unsolicited warranty pitches with caution. Regulators report high fraud losses and have tightened rules: the FCC now requires seller‑specific consent for autodialed calls/texts (implementation in 2025), and the FTC strengthened Telemarketing Sales Rule recordkeeping in 2024 (FTC fraud data; FCC; FTC TSR update).
• Dealer claims it’s required for financing: Add‑on products must be optional. California law prohibits charging for add‑ons that provide no benefit (e.g., duplicative or ineligible coverage) and bars misrepresentations that add‑ons are required (California AB 265).
• Contract isn’t provided up front: Demand the full sample contract and verify the administrator/insurer, exclusions, deductible type (per visit vs per repair), and claims steps (FTC guidance).

Decide on the Type of Extended Warranty You Need

Match coverage to your vehicle and ownership horizon. Older or high‑mileage cars often fit a powertrain or mid‑tier plan, while newer vehicles with advanced driver‑assistance systems (ADAS) and complex infotainment may merit exclusionary coverage. EV owners should check whether the plan covers drive units, inverters, and charging modules—and verify that the high‑voltage traction battery is addressed by the OEM’s separate warranty, not the VSC (KBB guide; Consumer Reports).

You should also think about the warranty term and how long you plan to own your vehicle. Contracts typically span 2–8 years and may be transferable or cancellable for a prorated refund (fees and state rules vary). OEM programs for some brands offer up to about 8 years/120,000–150,000 miles on eligible vehicles (Honda Care; Mopar Maximum Care).

Choose the Best Coverage for Your Needs

Most providers let you tailor coverage by tier, term, and deductible. Compare like‑for‑like quotes (same term/mileage and deductible), verify what’s covered/excluded, and check benefit caps for towing, rental, and trip interruption. Clarify whether deductibles apply per visit or per repair item, and how diagnostics/calibrations are handled if a failure isn’t covered (J.D. Power; FTC).

If you frequently drive long distances, consider travel‑friendly tiers with roadside assistance and trip interruption, unless you already have these through insurance or OEM coverage. Digital‑first options and subscription‑style plans have expanded—Olive is often cited for instant quotes and cancel‑anytime terms—and many administrators are investing in faster, more transparent digital claims experiences ( check your auto insurance policy first; Forbes Advisor; Cox Automotive).

How We Chose the Best Car Warranties

Reviews.com evaluates coverage tiers and exclusions, eligibility and term limits, contract transparency (administrator/insurer identified), pricing and deductibles, and verified consumer guidance. For this 2025 update, we synthesized major editorial rankings (U.S. News; Forbes Advisor) and consumer advice favoring OEM‑backed plans for smoother claims (Edmunds; Consumer Reports), plus regulatory guidance on service contracts and telemarketing risks (California DOI; FTC). We also considered customer‑experience context: the FTC reported over $10 billion in consumer fraud losses in 2024 and the CFPB logged about 1.6 million complaints, underscoring the importance of transparent sales and easy cancellation (FTC Sentinel; CFPB).

Extended Car Warranties FAQ

Keep Reading

Car Insurance Buyer’s Guide

The Best Companies for Bundling Home and Auto Insurance in 2025

How to Switch Car Insurance Companies