Please enter a valid zip code
Why do you need my ZIP code?
Which companies will quote you – and at what price – changes by ZIP. State and local market conditions, catastrophe exposure, and active underwriting appetites determine availability. For example, state tools like Texas’s HelpInsure and California’s Home Insurance Finder show that admitted carriers and estimated rates can differ across nearby ZIP codes. In higher-risk areas, carriers sometimes pause new business or impose moratoriums, and consumers may need to rely on residual markets such as state FAIR Plans or wind/windstorm pools; this has been more common in wildfire- and hurricane‑exposed ZIPs in recent cycles, amid elevated catastrophe losses documented by NOAA. Entering your ZIP lets us surface carriers actively writing policies near you right now.
Comparing Renters Insurance Quotes
Renters insurance (HO‑4) remains relatively affordable, but prices vary by insurer and location. Current market analyses show most renters pay about $14–$18 per month (≈$168–$216 per year) for a standard profile, depending on limits and deductible; see NerdWallet, Policygenius, and ValuePenguin. The latest NAIC‑based benchmark summarized by the Insurance Information Institute is roughly $173 per year. Over the past year, premiums have generally trended higher, a pattern also reflected in the BLS CPI “tenants’ and household insurance” 12‑month percent change.
Because each insurer uses its own data and rating formula, quotes for the same coverage can differ. The best approach is to compare multiple companies using identical assumptions (e.g., $30,000 personal property, $100,000 liability, $500 or $1,000 deductible). State-by-state and ZIP‑level differences are common; coastal and severe‑storm corridors tend to run higher than parts of the Upper Midwest, per 2025 state comparisons from Bankrate and ValuePenguin.
Factors That Affect Renters Insurance Rates
Insurers price HO‑4 using a mix of location risk, building characteristics, your coverage choices and deductible, and personal signals like prior claims and (where allowed) credit‑based insurance scores. Current market research highlights several additional levers: building age and construction (frame vs. masonry), local fire protection quality (e.g., Verisk’s PPC), protective devices (sprinklers, monitored alarms), and discounts for bundling or being claims‑free. Replacement cost coverage for contents typically costs more than actual cash value; endorsements (e.g., jewelry, water backup, identity theft/personal cyber) add premium. External conditions – elevated catastrophe losses and reinsurance costs – also influence overall price levels (NOAA; Gallagher Re; Triple‑I).
Your Location
ZIP code is one of the strongest predictors of renters rates because it concentrates multiple risks: theft, fire response, and catastrophic weather. The U.S. has experienced unusually high counts of billion‑dollar weather and climate disasters in recent years, with severe convective storms a major driver – a backdrop that contributes to higher baseline property loss costs (NOAA). Coastal wind/hail corridors, wildfire‑adjacent areas, and older urban cores with higher theft tend to carry higher base rates than well‑protected, lower‑risk areas.
Insurers also rate at a micro level. Community fire protection and distance to a responding station/hydrant can influence price; many carriers reference fire‑protection grading systems such as Verisk’s Public Protection Classification. Building features (sprinklers, controlled access) and security devices can earn credits that partially offset territorial risk (Triple‑I).
Availability can also vary by ZIP. State comparison portals (e.g., HelpInsure in TX; Home Insurance Finder in CA) show which companies are actively writing. In high‑risk ZIPs, carriers may limit new policies or nonrenew more frequently, pushing some renters to residual market options like FAIR Plans or wind/windstorm pools (NOAA context).
Your Insurance History
Prior claims are a strong pricing signal. Insurers verify loss history through CLUE reports that include up to seven years of auto and personal‑property claims data (LexisNexis CLUE). Many carriers primarily weigh losses from the last three to five years for rating, and multiple or recent property claims can remove claim‑free discounts or lead to surcharges and, in some cases, eligibility issues (see Triple‑I on homeowners pricing for how prior claims affect property insurance).
If you’ve filed a claim before, expect it to be considered across lines (renters, homeowners, auto). Frequency and recency matter more than a single small loss. You can request your CLUE report and dispute inaccuracies under your consumer rights (LexisNexis CLUE).
Your Credit Score
Where permitted, insurers use a credit‑based insurance score (CBIS) – not your lending score – because it correlates with expected claim frequency/severity. Research and regulatory primers explain how CBIS is used and where it’s restricted (NAIC CIPR; Insurance Information Institute). Some states impose limits or bans on specific uses; for example, California, Hawaii, and Massachusetts prohibit the use of credit in private‑passenger auto rating, while property lines like renters are generally allowed with guardrails that vary by state (NAIC). Studies have shown a statistical link between higher credit tiers and lower claim likelihood.
If you’re shopping soon, improving on‑time payments and lowering utilization can help your CBIS over time where it’s used. Model governance and fairness are also in focus following regulators’ adoption of an AI use bulletin – part of broader scrutiny of external consumer data in pricing and underwriting (NAIC AI Model Bulletin).
Your Coverage
Higher limits and broader protection cost more. Increasing personal property or liability limits, adding endorsements (e.g., scheduled jewelry, water backup, earthquake, identity/cyber), or choosing replacement cost for contents instead of actual cash value will raise premium. Because renters coverage is typically inexpensive (marketwide averages around $14–$18 per month; NAIC‑based benchmark ≈$173/year), it’s worth pricing a few limit/deductible combinations to balance protection and cost (Triple‑I; NerdWallet; Policygenius).
Ask about common discounts (auto+renters bundle, claim‑free, monitored alarm, gated/secured access, pay‑in‑full/paperless). These can offset part of the cost of higher limits or endorsements (Triple‑I).
Your Deductible
You might have heard that a higher deductible gets you cheaper rates on your car insurance. The same trade‑off applies to renters: raising your deductible shifts more first‑dollar risk to you and lowers the premium on the contents portion of your policy. While exact credits are insurer‑ and state‑specific, consumer and regulatory sources confirm the direction of savings for larger deductibles, and residual‑market guides note substantial reductions when selecting higher percentage deductibles for wind/hail where applicable (NAIC consumer resources; TWIA; HLDI on deductible mechanics). A common step like moving from $500 to $1,000 generally yields a noticeable credit on the property portion of premium; compare quotes using the same limits to see the actual savings in your ZIP.
Before increasing your deductible, run a quick break‑even check: divide the extra deductible you’d take on by the annual premium savings to estimate how many claim‑free years it would take to “pay for” the higher deductible. Ensure you could comfortably cover that out‑of‑pocket amount if a loss occurs (NAIC).