The Best Cheap Pet Insurance Providers
How We Found the Best Cheap Pet Insurance Providers
12 providers evaluated
4 experts interviewed
2 top picks
The Best Cheap Pet Insurance Providers
The best cheap pet insurance offers comprehensive coverage, no annual limits, and top-notch customer service. To help you compare your options, we took a deep dive into our top picks’ premiums, deductibles, and reimbursement options. But because your premium is unique to your pet, you’ll want to compare quotes from all three.
How We Chose the Best Cheap Pet Insurance Providers
Comprehensive medical coverage
The most important factor in a pet insurance policy is what it actually covers. Any number of costly medical conditions can come up with your pet, and we wanted providers that would cover all of them. In addition to the standard accident and injury protection, we went through policies with a fine-tooth comb to make sure they didn’t exclude any specific conditions like cherry eye or liver shunts. We also required continual coverage in all of our plans. That means if your pet’s receiving care for cancer or another chronic illness, it won’t stop at the end of your policy year.
Coverage based on vet bills
All pet insurance companies work on a reimbursement model — you pay the bill upfront, and they pay you back for approved expenses. That said, some companies use benefit schedules or “usual and customary” charges to determine how much they’ll reimburse. The issue with these reimbursements is that the company sets a limit for how much it’ll pay based on your pet’s diagnosis. That means if your vet happens to charge more than what they have designated for that condition, you’ll end up footing the difference. We eliminated any companies that didn’t base their reimbursement amount on what you actually pay to the vet initially.
No annual limits on specific conditions or incidents
The best pet insurance plans also don’t put a ceiling on how much they’ll pay for specific conditions or incidents. While most plans have a general annual limit (usually around $10,000) that encompasses all of your vet fees for the entire year, some plans also have caps for individual expenses. For instance, if your dog gets into the garbage and needs surgery to remove something harmful, you might find out that only 20% of your $10,000 benefit can be used. We wanted policies that would have you covered no matter what comes up, so we cut any providers with these types of limits.
Prescription drug coverage
As any pet owner can tell you, every pet will need prescription drugs at some point. Pet Health and Safety Coach Arden Moore told us that this coverage can make or break an insurance policy: “Many conditions require continual medication, which can quickly get expensive without this provision.” Prescriptions for issues like ear infections and stomach issues might only cost $20 per bottle, but that adds up fast if your pet has to be on them permanently. Unfortunately, this doesn’t apply to preventative medications like flea treatments, but anything your vet prescribes will be covered.
Finally, we ranked each of our five remaining contenders on their customer service experience. We wanted to find out how it would feel to actually use their policies, so we called and emailed each company with specific policy questions, used their live chat features when available, and graded their websites on how easy they made it to find the answers to our questions.
The 2 Best Cheap Pet Insurance Providers
Why we chose it
There’s no fine print when it comes to Figo’s unlimited coverage. It extends to exam fees, reimburses you within 30 days, and even waives coinsurance and deductibles if your pet needs lifesaving care — features no other provider offers.
Its broad coverage doesn’t hide any massive exclusions or long coverage waiting periods, either. If your vet says your particular dog or cat is likely to face an expensive illness throughout its life, such as hip dysplasia — a common (and costly) issue for big dogs — you’re going to need more coverage than someone who owns a pet with little risk (like an indoor cat).
Figo enables you to tailor your coverage and monthly premium in a few ways. First, you can choose one of three base plans that offer different coverage and maximum yearly benefit amounts. We recommend the unlimited “Ultimate” plan; the Essential and Preferred plan come with a lower premium, but they cap out at $10,000 and $14,000 in yearly benefits, respectively.
From there, you can choose among four annual deductibles and four reimbursement options. When we ran our sample pup through the process, the annual deductible we could choose ranged from $100 to $750. This range, however, will vary based on a number of factors including location, pet breed, and age; we saw deductibles as high as $1,500. To its credit, Figo was our only top pick to offer 100% reimbursement — an option that might pay off if you know your pet is liable to rack up several big bills over its lifetime.
Figo’s generosity shines in its customer service, too. When we called with questions, a confident, assuring customer service representative picked up immediately and patiently answered our questions in full. It also offers a cloud-based storage system for you to file and track claims and upload your pet’s medical records all in one place. Say you’re out of town and your dog swallows her toy; you can use the smartphone app to find the nearest vet and quickly pull up her history to ensure the best possible treatment.
Points to consider
Doesn’t cover preventive treatment
We’ll be honest, it was hard to find anything to dislike about Figo. However, one thing we would have liked to see covered is routine wellness and preventive costs — things like rabies vaccines and preventive flea, tick, and heartworm medications. These are some of the most frequent expenses for pet owners but are surprisingly not covered by any of our top picks.
If this is a dealbreaker for you, Nationwide was the best provider we saw that covered preventive treatment. Fair warning, though: We eliminated it because it reimburses on a benefit schedule rather than your actual vet bill, and it also has some pretty broad exclusions for pre-existing conditions.
**Not available in the state of Washington
Why we chose it
Unlike Figo, Healthy Paws only offers one pet insurance plan. However, that plan doesn’t have any benefit payout limit and there are often many options for customization within it. Depending on the age of your pet, you can influence your monthly premium by choosing from multiple reimbursement options and annual deductibles. Like Figo, these ranges vary depending on factors like the breed of your pet and your location, but we found it easy to adjust until we found the right balance for our needs.
When we requested quotes from each provider, we found that, on average, Healthy Paws offered the lowest monthly premiums, slightly edging out Figo. The difference is most stark for older dogs, making Healthy Paws a great place to start looking for pets four years or older (unless they have hip dysplasia — more on that below).
Short waiting period
The plan offers a 15-day waiting period for illness and injury coverage (besides hip dysplasia), the shortest of our top picks. A waiting period is the amount of time between when you purchase your policy and when your pet starts being covered. That means if you buy a Healthy Paws policy on June 1, you’ll be covered for any illness or injury starting on June 16.
Points to consider
Limited hip dysplasia policy
Healthy Paws has strict limits on hip dysplasia coverage. Hip displasia is an expensive genetic disorder that’s common in older dogs — statistics from the Canine Health Information center show that 72% of bulldogs and 70% of pugs are dysplastic.
If you choose a plan with Healthy Paws, coverage for hip dysplasia isn’t covered at all if your pet is enrolled after they turn six. And there’s a year-long waiting period for that coverage to kick in if your pet is under six years old. Before enrolling, check with your vet to see how likely your dog is to develop hip dysplasia in its lifetime.
Guide to Cheap Pet Insurance
How to save on your premium
Buy insurance early
This probably comes as no surprise, but the younger your pet is when you purchase an insurance policy, the better. For one, the longer you wait, the more likely it is that your pet will develop a condition that could be called pre-existing, and thus not coverable. The best time to get insurance is when your pet is under a year old, but the “earlier is better” rule still applies if you adopt an older animal.
Ask your vet about health risks
Before you start collecting quotes from different providers, it’s a good idea to narrow down what conditions need to be covered in your policy. Your vet can give you some guidance here on what risks are most associated with your pet’s breed. This can help even if you have a mix — knowing your dog is part rottweiler means you’ll probably want an insurer that covers hip dysplasia and cancer, for example. Once you’ve homed in on the issues your pet might be prone to, ask your vet to list a typical price tag associated with each condition. This will help you determine the right deductible and reimbursement amounts for your specific pet.
Most insurance providers offer a discount for paying your premium annually instead of monthly. If you can afford to pay it all upfront, this can be a significant source of savings on your premium costs.
Look for discounts
While you’re comparing quotes, make sure you check company websites for any available discounts. Figo was especially generous in this area: It provides discounts for insuring multiple pets, for adopting from an animal shelter or humane society, and for veterans or active duty military members.