author-profile
ByJulian Dossett

Julian is a tech and finance writer, covering stories from artificial intelligence to cryptocurrency. He lives with his wife in Albuquerque, New Mexico.

American Home Shield Review

Offering the first home warranty back in 1971, American Home Shield helped form its industry. The company now serves nearly 2 million customers across all states except for Alaska.

With approximately 1,800 employees and a national network of over 15,000 independent home service contractors and more than 45,000 service technicians, American Home Shield has a broad reach in the U.S. and is the go-to option for many homeowners looking for a little extra peace of mind.

American Home Shield Overview

  • Plan types: Appliances, Systems, Combo, and Build-Your-Own
  • Pricing: Varies by location and plan
  • Service fees: $75, $100 or $125
  • Workmanship guarantee: 30-day guarantee
  • Contract length: One year (standard)
  • BBB rating: B
  • Home inspection required? No
  • States served: 49
  • Available appliance and system coverage: offered separately, bundled or customized
  Appliances Systems Combo Build Your Own
Price Varies Varies Varies Varies
Appliances Covered Refrigerators
Ovens/cooktops
Clothes washers
Clothes dryers
Dishwashers
Built-in microwave ovens
Trash Compactors
Freestanding ice makers
Garage door openers
Built-in food centers
None Refrigerators
Ovens/cooktops
Clothes washers
Clothes dryers
Dishwashers
Built-in microwave ovens
Trash Compactors
Freestanding ice makers
Garage door openers
Built-in food centers
*all options available for customized plan
Systems Covered None Air-conditioning with ductwork
Heating with ductwork
Electrical
Doorbells
Smoke detectors
Ceiling fans
Plumbing (including stoppages)
Water Heaters
Garbage Disposals
Instant H/C Water Dispensers
Central Vacuums
Air-conditioning with ductwork
Heating with ductwork
Electrical
Doorbells
Smoke detectors
Ceiling fans
Plumbing (including stoppages)
Water Heaters
Garbage Disposals
Instant H/C Water Dispensers
Central Vacuums
*all options available for customized plan

Who is this best for?

Due to the high customization, the company offers in its warranties, American Home Shield works best for homeowners who want to have more control over which home appliances and systems will be covered under their personal plan. The plans offered by American Home Shield are straightforward and transparent, and the company’s sample contract should help to clear up questions.

Pros

  • Customizable plans make American Home Shield a solid choice for people who need a policy that does not conform to any preexisting plans offered on the market. With four flexible plans, every homeowner should be able to find a plan that works for them.
  • Company longevity offers a little extra reassurance that the American Home Shield will be around long enough to settle any claims that occur. It also lays claim that it started the concept of home warranties in the first place.
  • Service fee options give homeowners more freedom for how they want their plan to work. If the homeowner chooses a plan with a higher service fee, then the plan will have a lower monthly payment—and vice versa.
  • No inspection required means that the homeowner can sign up for an American Home Shield home warranty without worrying over a home inspection first, which gives homeowners an easier experience starting out.

Cons

  • Lack of monthly pricing information makes it more difficult for people to find out how much the plan will cost every month. Homeowners will need to get a quote before they know what the monthly cost will be after signing up.
  • Short workmanship guarantee means that repairs covered by the plan will only be guaranteed for 30 days. Considering that many other companies selling home warranties offer workmanship guarantees for 90 or 180 days, American Home Shield falls short of the competition in this area.

The Competition

  American Home Shield Cinch Home Warranty Complete Protection AFC Home Club
States served
49 48 36 46
Reviews.com rating
3.80/5 3.83/5 N/A 3.77/5
Service fee
$75, $100, or $125 $100, $125, or $150 $0 $75, $100 or $125
Workmanship guarantee
30 days 180 days None guaranteed until contract ends
Customizable
Yes No Yes Yes
Other
Four plans offered
Online portal available
Three plans offered
Online portal available
Four plans offered
No online portal
Four plans offered
No online portal

All information accurate as of 02/07/2020.

American Home Shield compared to Cinch

American Home Shield and Cinch (now Cinch Home Services) are fairly comparable in terms of what is offered in the plans. However, one big difference is customization. American Home Shield offers plans that can be customized to virtually anything a homeowner wants, while Cinch Home Services requires you to stick to the plans the company offers.

Cinch Home Services definitely wins in the category of workmanship guarantees. Cinch offers a 180-day guarantee with its plans, which is significantly more than the length of time that American Home Shield offers under its own plans. American Home Shield does offer lower service fees, which somewhat makes up for its short guarantees. So if something breaks down after American Home Shield’s 30-day guarantee is up, at least it will be less expensive to have someone come out again.

Due to the difference in cost by location, it’s a good idea to get quotes from both companies to see which one will work best for your area.

American Home Shield compared to Complete Protection

American Home Shield and Complete Protection offer very different kinds of home warranties. With American Home Shield, people signing up can expect plans that are traditionally structured—meaning the plans come with a contract, a service fee, and a workmanship guarantee. Complete Protection offers a separate take on home warranties that is less traditional than American Home Shield’s plans.

With Complete Protection home warranties, homeowners don’t have to worry about contracts or service fees. Complete Protection offers cancellation anytime, with some refunds available depending on the company’s prorating formula. Complete Protection also has quite a few restrictions on what its home warranties cover, so it’s a good idea to make sure that the home appliances and system that you want to be covered will be available under the plan.

Choosing between American Home Shield and Complete Protection largely depends on what kind of home warranty fits in with your lifestyle and how you want your appliances and systems covered.

The Bottom Line

The high level of customization that American Home Shield offers in its plans makes this company a sound choice for homeowners who might have unusual home warranty needs and are looking to create individualized plans. However, for anyone who wants a long workmanship guarantee, American Home Shield is probably not the right plan, as there are plenty of competitors with longer guarantees. Ultimately, the best choice will rest with the needs of the homeowner and what they want out of their home warranty.

You might also like