Select Home Warranty offers home warranty coverage in 45 states and leverages a large network of local contractors to complete home repairs. And, Select home warranty reviews are largely positive. The company is known for great sign-up bonuses like free roof leak coverage and two months of free protection if you pay annually.
With multiple plans to choose from and a 90-day workmanship guarantee, Select is a solid choice for homeowners looking for best-fit coverage and confidence that repair work will be completed correctly the first time.
In our Select Home Warranty review, we dig into the pros and cons of this protection company and discover how it stacks up against some of the industry’s top competitors.
Select Home Warranty Overview
While customers must get a quote to see starting prices for home warranty plans. Warranties are available for condos, manufactured homes, and rental properties — an impressive array of coverage.
Customers also benefit from a 90-day workmanship guarantee and no home inspection requirement. And you can add a warranty add-on to less common appliances and systems including spas, pools, lawn sprinkler systems, and stand alone freezers.
- Sign-up bonuses Select Home Warranty offers two months of free coverage when you pay annually, plus free roof leak protection.
- Multiple plan choices Choose the Bronze Care plan to protect appliances or the Gold Care plan to cover home systems, or get the best of both worlds with the Platinum Care plan.
- Customizable optional coverage Opt-in for extra coverage including septic systems, lawn sprinklers, or sump pumps.
- Substantial workmanship guarantee Select Home Warranty offers a 90-day workmanship guarantee on all home repairs.
- Prices are variable Prices vary by state and are typically higher than home warranty competitors.
- Service callouts may incur multiple charges If necessary repair work affects multiple systems, such as plumbing and electrical, you may be charged multiple fees.
- Some gaps in coverage While the Bronze Care plan offers appliance protection, no systems are covered. Similarly, the Gold Care plan provides system solutions but leaves your appliances unprotected.
- Short claim reporting period To be eligible for home warranty coverage, claims must be reported to Select Home Warranty (online or by phone) within three days of homeowners discovering the issue.
Select Home Warranty Highlights
Select Home Warranty’s Bronze Plan covers the basic appliances of the home, like the washer and dryer and kitchen refrigerator — but it doesn’t cover any home systems. Inversely, The Gold Plan covers home systems, such as heating, cooling, and ductwork, but doesn’t include home appliances. Finally, Select’s Platinum Plan covers both appliances and systems, but is the most expensive option.
Customers can also add optional coverage such as pool/spa, central vacuum, and sprinkler systems for additional monthly charges.
Work repairs are guaranteed for 90 days. That means if the contractor who completes the repairs makes a mistake or the same problem reappears through no fault of the homeowner, the customer doesn’t have to pay extra to have it made right within this time period.
Monthly pricing depends on ZIP code, so prices available to customers in Arizona will be different than prices in North Carolina. Furthermore, opting into annual billing will result in 14 months of coverage, but with two months free, which can be a boon for savers.
Select Home Warranty Plans
- Garbage disposal
- Microwave oven (built-in)
- Free roof coverage
- Heating system
- Plumbing system
- Electrical system
- Water heater
- Free roof coverage
Platinum Care includes everything that Gold and Bronze does, plus:
- Plumbing stoppage
- Garage door opener
- Ceiling fan
- Free roof coverage
- Central vacuum
- Lawn sprinkler system
- Roof leak
- Septic system
- Standalone freezer
- Sump pump
- Well pump
Select Home Warranty vs. The Competition
|Provider||Reviews.com Score||Price||Service Fee||States Served|
|Select Home Warranty||2||Not Listed||$60–$75||45 (excludes California, Nevada, New York, Washington and Wisconsin)|
|OneGuard Home Warranty||3.8||$25–$56/mo.||$69||Arizona, Nevada and Texas|
|Landmark Home Warranty||3.5||$35/mo. or $55.84/mo.||$60 or $100||Arizona, Idaho, Nevada, Oregon, Texas, Utah|
|American Residential Warranty||3.2||$34.9–-$59.99/mo.||$55||50|
Information accurate as of March, 2021
Select Home Warranty vs. OneGuard Home Warranty
Both Select Home Warranty and OneGuard Home Warranty offer three protection plans and similar service fees, but there are substantial differences between these two coverage competitors.
For example, while OneGuard offers coverage in just three states, Select Home Warranty provides plans across 45 states. But a larger coverage area also comes with more variable pricing — OneGuard offers some of the most affordable plans on the market with packages starting at just $30 per month.
OneGuard also has a high claims approval rate at 95%, but doesn’t offer any sign-up bonuses for new clients like Select Home Warranty does. It’s also worth considering service technicians — while both companies supply their own tradespeople, Select Home Warranty always uses local contractors.
Select Home Warranty vs. Landmark Home Warranty
Landmark Home Warranty only offers two plans for homeowners, but includes 20 different add-on coverages compared to Select Home Warranty’s nine optional add-ons. Select Home Warranty, meanwhile, provides greater flexibility with its three-plan model.
When it comes to workmanship, it’s worth noting that Landmark Home Warranty only offers a 30-day guarantee, while Select Home Warranty provides 90 days of protection against defects or other issues.
Landmark does earn top marks in customer service with an A- rating from the BBB, but only offers coverage across six states. Select doesn’t fare as well with only a B rating from the BBB, but does provide coverage across 45 states. Landmark home warranty coupons offer a way to save money, while Select has occasional discounts that apply to all new sign ups.
Select Home Warranty vs. American Residential Warranty
American Residential Warranty is available in every state, lending itself to a more comprehensive network than Select, which excludes five states. American Residential Warranty also has more consistent pricing, whereas Select rates may vary depending on where you live.
Both companies have multiple tiers of service plus add-ons available. American has bundles, premium plans, and add-ons that make customizing for your needs a bit easier. Select’s plans are divided into appliance coverage, systems coverage, and a comprehensive plan with coverage for both.
Select Home Warranty FAQ
Select Home Warranty reviews from customers are middle-of-the-road, but it does offer a wide range of services and potentially a reasonable monthly fee. Some areas may have a wider network of contractors available than others.
You don’t pay a deductible for Select Home Warranty, but rather a service fee. These range from $60 to $75 per visit, depending on the type of claim.
The best home warranty for affordability is Global Home Protection, but the Select Home Warranty offers the most comprehensive plans, plus add-ons.
American Home Shield will be available in every state, but Select Home Warranty is only available in 45 states. On the other hand, Select makes it easier to get a single plan to cover all systems. For convenience, Select is the winner if it’s available in your state.
We evaluated Select Home Warranty based on customer experience, customer satisfaction, monthly cost, trade service fees and coverage to determine Reviews.com scores and create our best home warranty reviews. To compare home warranty companies with other providers across the board, we calculate each Reviews.com score based on the following:
- Starting Monthly Price: The lower the cost of a home warranty company’s monthly contract, the higher the score. Inversely, the higher the cost of the monthly contract, the lower the score in this metric.
- Trade Service Fee: We awarded higher scores to home warranty companies with lower trade service fees.
- Customer Satisfaction: Reviews.com utilized the Better Business Bureau ratings to assign customer satisfaction scores to home warranty companies.
- Customer Experience: Using the Better Business Bureau, we reviewed rating of customer complaints lodged and resolved with BBB.
- Coverage: We compared available coverage and add-ons offered by home warranty companies to assign Reviews.com scores.