Direct Auto Insurance Review

Direct Auto Insurance is part of National General (an Allstate company) and focuses on non‑standard auto coverage for high-risk drivers. The brand sells policies in a limited 13‑state footprint and supports in‑person service through a large local store network (About; verify availability by state at Direct Auto locations).

Direct Auto offers the core auto coverages and a broad set of common discounts, but it operates in only 13 states and the National Association of Insurance Commissioners’ (NAIC) complaint index for National General’s private‑passenger auto business has often been above the industry baseline of 1.00 (industry average = 1.00; see current results via the NAIC consumer complaint tool). For drivers needing SR‑22/FR‑44 filings or flexible, in‑person service, this carrier can be a practical option (Direct Auto: Car insurance).

• In business since: 1991
• J.D. Power auto claims satisfaction score: Not ranked; see the latest regional results in the J.D. Power U.S. Auto Insurance Study
• AM Best financial strength: National General Group: A (Excellent), Outlook Stable; Parent Allstate Insurance Group: A+ (Superior), Outlook Stable

Direct Auto Insurance Review

The Auto Insurance Factors We Analyzed

Pricing

Average rates aren’t published by Direct Auto. Pricing is highly individualized by state, vehicle, mileage, driving history, and credit (where permitted). Marketwide, premiums have remained elevated; the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reported motor vehicle insurance costs up about 18.9% year over year as of the September 2024 CPI release (BLS). In response, shopping has surged to record highs and more drivers are considering telematics programs to manage price (J.D. Power Insurance Shopping Study). If you’re a low‑mileage or consistently safe driver, a usage‑based/telematics program can sometimes lower costs—availability varies and programs require data sharing (NAIC). Direct Auto does not widely advertise a telematics program across all states; confirm options with a local agent.

Customer experience

AM Best rates insurers (and pooled groups) on financial strength rather than consumer brands. Direct Auto policies are commonly issued by members of National General Group, which carries an A (Excellent) Financial Strength Rating (Outlook Stable). For parent context, Allstate Insurance Group is rated A+ (Superior). AM Best explains these ratings reflect an insurer’s ability to meet ongoing obligations (About AM Best ratings). On complaints, NAIC data show the private‑passenger auto complaint index for National General exceeds the 1.00 industry baseline at times (use NAIC’s tool for the current value). Broadly, customer satisfaction across finance/insurance sectors has stabilized in the mid‑70s on the 0–100 ACSI scale (ACSI finance/insurance), while the 2024 J.D. Power U.S. Auto Insurance Study highlights continued price pressure and regional score differences; USAA is not rank‑eligible due to membership limits and GEICO performs above average in several regions.

Coverage

Direct Auto offers the core protections most drivers consider: liability (bodily injury/property damage), collision, comprehensive, plus state‑dependent medical payments or PIP, and uninsured/underinsured motorist. Common add‑ons include rental reimbursement and roadside assistance; the company also helps with SR‑22/FR‑44 filings where required (Direct Auto; learn about SR‑22 basics here). Industry‑wide, optional coverages such as GAP/loan‑lease, OEM parts, rideshare endorsements, and EV battery/charger protections have expanded, but Direct Auto does not publicly advertise these across its footprint—availability is state‑ and underwriting‑dependent (see market context from the Insurance Information Institute and coverage trends in Deloitte’s 2025 outlook and Verisk (EV repair/risk)). If you need specific endorsements like rideshare, OEM parts, or GAP, verify availability before you buy (the CFPB has flagged concerns around dealer‑sold GAP add‑ons: CFPB).

Deals, discounts, and add-ons

Discounts vary by state and underwriting company. Typical opportunities include bundling (multi‑policy), multi‑vehicle, safe/accident‑free driving, good student and driver training, vehicle safety/anti‑theft features, and administrative savings like paperless, autopay, early signing, and pay‑in‑full (III; examples from major carriers: GEICO, Progressive, Allstate). Usage‑based/telematics programs can add savings for safe, low‑risk driving, but participation and impact vary widely (NAIC). Direct Auto emphasizes flexible payment options and cash/in‑store payments via its local office network (Direct Auto).

You can also purchase roadside assistance and emergency protection plans to add to your policy; confirm terms and state availability with an agent.

Direct Auto Insurance Overview: Financial Strength, Availability and History

Founded in 1991 and headquartered in Nashville, TN, Direct Auto operates through hundreds of local offices within its 13‑state footprint and also supports online account access. Under the National General/Allstate umbrella, Direct Auto’s underwriting companies are part of National General Group (AM Best A (Excellent), Outlook Stable), while the parent Allstate Insurance Group carries an A+ (Superior) AM Best rating. J.D. Power’s latest U.S. Auto Insurance Study reports ongoing price‑driven satisfaction pressure and regional score differences; USAA remains not rank‑eligible due to membership limits, and GEICO posts above‑average results in several regions (2021 J.D. Power Auto Insurance Study; link points to the latest study).

The Competition

All information is accurate as of November 2025

Direct Auto Insurance vs. USAA

USAA serves active-duty military, veterans, and eligible family members (membership required). Direct Auto’s niche is non‑standard risks and SR‑22 help with in‑person service and flexible billing. USAA emphasizes digital service and offers a telematics program—SafePilot—that can provide up to a 30% discount for safe driving (availability and savings vary by state; USAA SafePilot).

USAA’s membership restriction is the primary barrier for non‑eligible consumers. If you’re eligible and prefer a telematics‑driven discount with a strong mobile experience, USAA may be a fit; if you need walk‑in support, cash payments, or SR‑22 filings, Direct Auto is designed for that use case.

Direct Auto Insurance vs. Geico

Geico is a national carrier with strong digital tools and generally competitive pricing for many profiles. It offers the DriveEasy telematics program to potentially reduce rates based on measured driving (GEICO DriveEasy) and a differentiating Mechanical Breakdown Insurance (MBI) option for eligible newer vehicles (GEICO MBI). Direct Auto emphasizes non‑standard underwriting, storefront service, and flexible payments, but does not widely advertise a telematics or MBI‑style program across its footprint.

If you prioritize app‑based self‑service, telematics, or MBI for a newer car, GEICO may be a better fit. If you’re rebuilding your driving record or need SR‑22/FR‑44 filings with the option to pay in person, compare quotes with Direct Auto.

The Bottom Line

Direct Auto Insurance is targeted to higher‑risk drivers who value SR‑22 support, storefront service, and flexible billing. Availability is limited to 13 states and NAIC data indicate complaint levels above the industry baseline; digital tools and optional add‑ons like rideshare endorsements, accident forgiveness, telematics, or OEM parts are not broadly advertised—verify needs before purchasing (availability; NAIC). In a market with elevated premiums, compare multiple quotes and consider telematics programs where offered (NAIC).

Direct Auto Insurance FAQ

Recently Added

Millenial Report

The Best Florida Car Insurance Companies

The Best Car Insurance Companies in Arizona