HomepageInsuranceRentersThe Best Renters Insurance Companies
Last updated on Jun 11, 2020

The Best Renters Insurance Companies

Fact-checked with
We recommend products and services based on unbiased research from our editorial team. We may receive compensation if you click on a link. Read More.

Like homeowners insurance, the ideal renters insurance provider will be financially secure, with great coverage options and excellent customer service. Our free quote tool can help you compare rates.

It pays to shop around. Enter your ZIP code to compare rates.

How We Found the Best Renters Insurance Companies

related highlight icon

68 companies vetted

related highlight icon

3 key ratings evaluated

related highlight icon

5 top picks

Protecting your personal possessions by way of an insurance policy can help you recover from a disaster quickly and with minimal impact on your finances. If you rent your primary residence, getting a quality renters insurance policy can cover your personal possessions in the event of unexpected disasters, such as a fire, burglary, tornado, or other unforeseen events.

Policies for renters are surprisingly affordable; many renters can secure a standard policy for $10 to $20 a month. Since many households have over $20,000 worth of personal possessions, a renters insurance policy is an affordable way to protect the investment of your personal belongings. 

After reviewing the top rental insurance companies on several key factors, we selected the best renters insurance companies for 2020 below.

  • USAA
  • State Farm
  • American Family Insurance
  • Allstate
  • Nationwide

USAA – Best for Military Members and Veterans

Reviews.com Score: 4.8/5

Unlike many of the other top renters insurance companies, USAA provides flood and earthquake coverage as part of its standard policies, which protects military and ex-military renters wherever they may live. 

Although USAA provides comprehensive coverage starting at just $10 a month, renters without a military association may need to seek coverage elsewhere, as USAA only issues policies to active military, veterans, and their family members.

Read Full Review on USAA

State Farm – Best for Coverage Options

Reviews.com Score: 3.8/5

Standard renters policies with State Farm include comprehensive protection for property, liability, medical expenses, and loss of use. State Farm also offers many add-on options, including coverage for identity restoration, pet insurance, and business protection.  

Read Full Review on State Farm

American Family Insurance – Best Value

Reviews.com Score: 3.6/5

American Family Insurance provides a great combination of low premiums and comprehensive coverage, making it our pick for the best value for renters insurance. Although the company offers low premiums as a standard, it still provides plenty of opportunities for additional discounts for bundling, using AutoPay, or going paperless. Unfortunately, this company may not be for you if you don’t live in one of the 17 states that fall within their limited coverage area.

Read Full Review on American Family Insurance

Allstate – Best for Bundling

Reviews.com Score: 3.3/5

Although nearly every insurance company offers some kind of discount for bundling, few go to the lengths that Allstate does to help customers save through bundling discounts. Allstate offers an entire page of resources for bundling, including providing easy-to-navigate options for bundling renters insurance with auto, motorcycle, off-road vehicles, or life insurance.

Read Full Review on Allstate

Nationwide – Best Self-Help Options

Reviews.com Score: 3.3/5

While Nationwide’s customer service ratings weren’t as high as other insurers, customers who prefer to use self-help options in managing their renters insurance policies may appreciate the ease of access available with Nationwide. Through the company’s online portal, customers can easily get quotes, file claims, manage accounts, and pay bills.

Read Full Review on Nationwide

The 5 Best Renters Insurance Companies

Looking for the right insurer for you? We’re here to help. Check out our top-ranked renters insurance companies and see how they stack up when it comes to customer experience and financial stability:

CompanyBest ForReviews.com Overall ScoreCustomer Experience ScoreFinancial Strength Score
USAAMilitary/Veterans4.8/55/54.3/5
State FarmCoverage Options3.8/54/53/5
American FamilyValue3.6/54/52.3/5
AllstateBundling3.3/53/54/5
Nationwide3.3/53/54/5
Farmers3.1/53/53.3/5
Amica2.9/53.3/51.6/5
SafeCo2.8/53/52/5
Travelers2.5/52/54/5
Liberty Mutual2.3/52/53/5
Progressive1.8/51/54/5

Each of our categories was rated against the highest standards. We rewarded companies that have all of the rating factors we were looking for. So a lower category score doesn’t necessarily mean the company isn’t right for you, but the lower score stems from underperformance or missing results in key studies. To learn more about how we scored these categories, check out our methodology below.

What Does Renters Insurance Cover?

  • Personal property – If the building you’re renting is ever damaged or destroyed due to accidents, weather, or vandalism, it’s likely your personal property will suffer damage, too. This section of your renters insurance policy pays for repairs or to replace your items—from clothing and books to furniture and electronics—up to your policy limits.
  • Liability If your visitors incur property damage or are injured while in your rented home or apartment, the liability portion of your policy covers these costs, including medical expenses, property replacement, or legal defense for lawsuits arising from the incident.
  • Loss of use – In the event you’re no longer able to stay at your home as a result of a covered loss, this portion of your policy pays additional living expenses while you’re unable to use your rental property. Covered expenses typically include a temporary hotel stay or additional gas for a longer work commute.

Other Types of Coverage

  • Personal liability umbrella Covers additional expenses for major claims that exceed the standard liability expenses.
  • Scheduled property – Provides additional coverage for valuable items, such as jewelry or collectibles.
  • Water backup Protects against damage caused by backed-up sewers or drains.
  • Earthquake/flood – Pays for damages caused by earthquakes or floods that would otherwise be excluded under a basic policy.
  • Identity theft – Covers legal expenses and lost wages if your identity is stolen.
  • Pet insurance – Pays for veterinary costs or final expenses for your pets if they are hurt during a claim incident.
  • Medical payments – Provides medical care for two groups of people: those injured by you or someone in your family living with you, and those who are injured while a guest in your home. 

How to Save on Renters Insurance

Although renters insurance may be an additional expense, there are several ways to save money on your monthly premiums. By bundling with other insurance products, qualifying for administrative discounts, and adjusting your deductible level, you can save hundreds of dollars each year.

Deductibles

The deductible is the amount you pay before your policy begins to pay out on a claim. In general, lower deductibles are associated with higher premiums, so consider increasing your deductible to reduce your monthly costs.

Discounts

Most insurers offer discounts for things like autopay, paperless billing, loyalty discounts, installing smart home devices, remaining claims-free, and bundling with other product lines. Check with your provider for specifics on which discounts are available and how to qualify.

FAQs

Who needs renters insurance?

Anyone renting their primary place of residence should carry renters insurance. Although some landlords don’t require tenants to have renters insurance as a condition of their lease, insurance protects you if the property you’re renting is damaged. 

Who has the cheapest renters insurance?

The cost of a renters insurance policy varies based on a number of factors, but based on our findings in general, the cheapest policies are with USAA, State Farm, and American Family Insurance.

What is not covered by renters insurance?

While renters insurance is designed to cover your possessions inside the home or apartment you’re renting, it doesn’t cover the structure itself. Renters insurance also generally doesn’t cover damage caused by natural disasters, pests, or damage to your personal vehicle.

About the Authors

Julia Taylor is a freelance writer based in Nashville, TN. She takes complex business, financial, and technical topics and makes them easy to understand. She worked in the insurance industry for several years as a licensed agent in Tennessee. You can find her work published on a variety of business blogs, including Paychex, Kapitus, Sanford Brown, Fortis Educational Institutes, American University of Antigua, and Interest.com. She also earned her bachelor's degree in business from the University of Tennessee and her MBA from Tennessee Tech University. When she's not working on her next writing piece, you can find her working in the yard or spending time with her three teenaged children.